Youth, generations, and collective action in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article examines concepts of youth, maturity, and generations in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy and perceived connections between young people and political and social unrest. I demonstrate that, rather than being consistent, the involvement of younger generations in radicalism was uneven, and varied significantly with historical contexts. I argue that the authorities frequently exaggerated associations between young people and radicalism as a subtle strategy of exclusion, as a means of downgrading the significance of collective action and portraying it as a criminal, emotional, or even recreational matter rather than a political one, a tendency that has often been reinforced in the historiography. Descriptions of youth and maturity should not be understood as merely reflections of age. They were not value-free, and served as indicators of individuals' social standing and political agency or lack thereof. Yet fighting in a rebellion offered an alternative to marriage, owning property, or education for the achievement of “manhood,” or adult status and political agency. The article also investigates how the Great Irish Famine shaped generational consciousness in the second half of the nineteenth century through an analysis of the participants in nationalist and agrarian violence. In all, over four thousand participants in collective action in Ireland and Italy are examined.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)934-966
Number of pages33
JournalComparative Studies in Society and History
Volume56
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 Oct 2014

Fingerprint

radicalism
maturity
collective behavior
Ireland
nineteenth century
Italy
historiography
consciousness
exclusion
marriage
violence
lack
Values
education
Collective Action
Radicalism
Maturity

Keywords

  • political unrest
  • youth
  • radicalism

Cite this

@article{992651a2b48e48d9ab854392b47e9bb8,
title = "Youth, generations, and collective action in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy",
abstract = "This article examines concepts of youth, maturity, and generations in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy and perceived connections between young people and political and social unrest. I demonstrate that, rather than being consistent, the involvement of younger generations in radicalism was uneven, and varied significantly with historical contexts. I argue that the authorities frequently exaggerated associations between young people and radicalism as a subtle strategy of exclusion, as a means of downgrading the significance of collective action and portraying it as a criminal, emotional, or even recreational matter rather than a political one, a tendency that has often been reinforced in the historiography. Descriptions of youth and maturity should not be understood as merely reflections of age. They were not value-free, and served as indicators of individuals' social standing and political agency or lack thereof. Yet fighting in a rebellion offered an alternative to marriage, owning property, or education for the achievement of “manhood,” or adult status and political agency. The article also investigates how the Great Irish Famine shaped generational consciousness in the second half of the nineteenth century through an analysis of the participants in nationalist and agrarian violence. In all, over four thousand participants in collective action in Ireland and Italy are examined.",
keywords = "political unrest, youth, radicalism",
author = "Niall Whelehan",
year = "2014",
month = "10",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1017/S0010417514000450",
language = "English",
volume = "56",
pages = "934--966",
journal = "Comparative Studies in Society and History",
issn = "0010-4175",
number = "4",

}

Youth, generations, and collective action in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy. / Whelehan, Niall.

In: Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol. 56, No. 4, 03.10.2014, p. 934-966.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Youth, generations, and collective action in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy

AU - Whelehan, Niall

PY - 2014/10/3

Y1 - 2014/10/3

N2 - This article examines concepts of youth, maturity, and generations in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy and perceived connections between young people and political and social unrest. I demonstrate that, rather than being consistent, the involvement of younger generations in radicalism was uneven, and varied significantly with historical contexts. I argue that the authorities frequently exaggerated associations between young people and radicalism as a subtle strategy of exclusion, as a means of downgrading the significance of collective action and portraying it as a criminal, emotional, or even recreational matter rather than a political one, a tendency that has often been reinforced in the historiography. Descriptions of youth and maturity should not be understood as merely reflections of age. They were not value-free, and served as indicators of individuals' social standing and political agency or lack thereof. Yet fighting in a rebellion offered an alternative to marriage, owning property, or education for the achievement of “manhood,” or adult status and political agency. The article also investigates how the Great Irish Famine shaped generational consciousness in the second half of the nineteenth century through an analysis of the participants in nationalist and agrarian violence. In all, over four thousand participants in collective action in Ireland and Italy are examined.

AB - This article examines concepts of youth, maturity, and generations in nineteenth-century Ireland and Italy and perceived connections between young people and political and social unrest. I demonstrate that, rather than being consistent, the involvement of younger generations in radicalism was uneven, and varied significantly with historical contexts. I argue that the authorities frequently exaggerated associations between young people and radicalism as a subtle strategy of exclusion, as a means of downgrading the significance of collective action and portraying it as a criminal, emotional, or even recreational matter rather than a political one, a tendency that has often been reinforced in the historiography. Descriptions of youth and maturity should not be understood as merely reflections of age. They were not value-free, and served as indicators of individuals' social standing and political agency or lack thereof. Yet fighting in a rebellion offered an alternative to marriage, owning property, or education for the achievement of “manhood,” or adult status and political agency. The article also investigates how the Great Irish Famine shaped generational consciousness in the second half of the nineteenth century through an analysis of the participants in nationalist and agrarian violence. In all, over four thousand participants in collective action in Ireland and Italy are examined.

KW - political unrest

KW - youth

KW - radicalism

UR - https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/comparative-studies-in-society-and-history

U2 - 10.1017/S0010417514000450

DO - 10.1017/S0010417514000450

M3 - Article

VL - 56

SP - 934

EP - 966

JO - Comparative Studies in Society and History

JF - Comparative Studies in Society and History

SN - 0010-4175

IS - 4

ER -