Why educational interventions are not always effective: a theory‐based process evaluation of a randomised controlled trial to improve non‐prescription medicine supply from community pharmacies

Margaret C. Watson, Anne Walker, Jeremy Grimshaw, Christine M. Bond

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) has been used to explore health professionals' intentions to behave in a particular way. This study measured community pharmacists' behavioural intention and actual behaviour as part of an evaluation of a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of two educational interventions to promote the appropriate treatment of vaginal candidiasis in community pharmacies. This study aimed to explore reasons for the success or failure of educational interventions by conducting a theory-based process evaluation alongside the RCT.
Method: The RCT was conducted in 60 community pharmacies in Grampian, Scotland, and compared educational outreach visits and continuing education workshops. A postal questionnaire was conducted, comprising five measures derived from TPB: behaviour; behavioural intention, attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioural control; together with a measure of clinical knowledge of candidiasis and its treatment; and a measure of guideline compliance. Guideline compliance was assessed using four scenarios. Simulated patient visits were made to participating pharmacies to derive objective measures of actual behaviour.
Results: Completed questionnaires were returned from 50 pharmacists (response rate: 83%). Forty (80%) respondents were fully guideline compliant (correct response with all four scenarios). Pharmacists' knowledge was high and they had positive attitudes towards the supply of antifungals, as well as strong intentions to sell them appropriately. No statistically significant differences were shown in questionnaire responses or actual behaviour across the four trial groups.
Conclusion: This evaluation demonstrates that the interventions may have failed because of psychological ceiling effects, i.e. existing attitudes and intentions were already strong. Further studies are needed to identify factors that prevent strong intentions from being put into practice, in order to develop effective interventions.
LanguageEnglish
Pages249-254
Number of pages6
JournalInternational Journal of Pharmacy Practice
Volume14
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 18 Feb 2010

Fingerprint

Pharmacies
Prescriptions
Randomized Controlled Trials
Ceilings
Technical presentations
Pharmacists
Candidiasis
Education
Health
Guidelines
Compliance
Continuing Education
Scotland
Psychology
Surveys and Questionnaires
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • pharmacists
  • antifungal agent
  • non prescription drug
  • clinical practice

Cite this

@article{f87e93f6e9a440749603e07fb54f2b3d,
title = "Why educational interventions are not always effective: a theory‐based process evaluation of a randomised controlled trial to improve non‐prescription medicine supply from community pharmacies",
abstract = "Objective: The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) has been used to explore health professionals' intentions to behave in a particular way. This study measured community pharmacists' behavioural intention and actual behaviour as part of an evaluation of a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of two educational interventions to promote the appropriate treatment of vaginal candidiasis in community pharmacies. This study aimed to explore reasons for the success or failure of educational interventions by conducting a theory-based process evaluation alongside the RCT. Method: The RCT was conducted in 60 community pharmacies in Grampian, Scotland, and compared educational outreach visits and continuing education workshops. A postal questionnaire was conducted, comprising five measures derived from TPB: behaviour; behavioural intention, attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioural control; together with a measure of clinical knowledge of candidiasis and its treatment; and a measure of guideline compliance. Guideline compliance was assessed using four scenarios. Simulated patient visits were made to participating pharmacies to derive objective measures of actual behaviour. Results: Completed questionnaires were returned from 50 pharmacists (response rate: 83{\%}). Forty (80{\%}) respondents were fully guideline compliant (correct response with all four scenarios). Pharmacists' knowledge was high and they had positive attitudes towards the supply of antifungals, as well as strong intentions to sell them appropriately. No statistically significant differences were shown in questionnaire responses or actual behaviour across the four trial groups. Conclusion: This evaluation demonstrates that the interventions may have failed because of psychological ceiling effects, i.e. existing attitudes and intentions were already strong. Further studies are needed to identify factors that prevent strong intentions from being put into practice, in order to develop effective interventions.",
keywords = "pharmacists, antifungal agent, non prescription drug, clinical practice",
author = "Watson, {Margaret C.} and Anne Walker and Jeremy Grimshaw and Bond, {Christine M.}",
year = "2010",
month = "2",
day = "18",
doi = "10.1211/ijpp.14.4.0004",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "249--254",
journal = "International Journal of Pharmacy Practice",
issn = "0961-7671",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Why educational interventions are not always effective

T2 - International Journal of Pharmacy Practice

AU - Watson, Margaret C.

AU - Walker, Anne

AU - Grimshaw, Jeremy

AU - Bond, Christine M.

PY - 2010/2/18

Y1 - 2010/2/18

N2 - Objective: The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) has been used to explore health professionals' intentions to behave in a particular way. This study measured community pharmacists' behavioural intention and actual behaviour as part of an evaluation of a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of two educational interventions to promote the appropriate treatment of vaginal candidiasis in community pharmacies. This study aimed to explore reasons for the success or failure of educational interventions by conducting a theory-based process evaluation alongside the RCT. Method: The RCT was conducted in 60 community pharmacies in Grampian, Scotland, and compared educational outreach visits and continuing education workshops. A postal questionnaire was conducted, comprising five measures derived from TPB: behaviour; behavioural intention, attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioural control; together with a measure of clinical knowledge of candidiasis and its treatment; and a measure of guideline compliance. Guideline compliance was assessed using four scenarios. Simulated patient visits were made to participating pharmacies to derive objective measures of actual behaviour. Results: Completed questionnaires were returned from 50 pharmacists (response rate: 83%). Forty (80%) respondents were fully guideline compliant (correct response with all four scenarios). Pharmacists' knowledge was high and they had positive attitudes towards the supply of antifungals, as well as strong intentions to sell them appropriately. No statistically significant differences were shown in questionnaire responses or actual behaviour across the four trial groups. Conclusion: This evaluation demonstrates that the interventions may have failed because of psychological ceiling effects, i.e. existing attitudes and intentions were already strong. Further studies are needed to identify factors that prevent strong intentions from being put into practice, in order to develop effective interventions.

AB - Objective: The Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) has been used to explore health professionals' intentions to behave in a particular way. This study measured community pharmacists' behavioural intention and actual behaviour as part of an evaluation of a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of two educational interventions to promote the appropriate treatment of vaginal candidiasis in community pharmacies. This study aimed to explore reasons for the success or failure of educational interventions by conducting a theory-based process evaluation alongside the RCT. Method: The RCT was conducted in 60 community pharmacies in Grampian, Scotland, and compared educational outreach visits and continuing education workshops. A postal questionnaire was conducted, comprising five measures derived from TPB: behaviour; behavioural intention, attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioural control; together with a measure of clinical knowledge of candidiasis and its treatment; and a measure of guideline compliance. Guideline compliance was assessed using four scenarios. Simulated patient visits were made to participating pharmacies to derive objective measures of actual behaviour. Results: Completed questionnaires were returned from 50 pharmacists (response rate: 83%). Forty (80%) respondents were fully guideline compliant (correct response with all four scenarios). Pharmacists' knowledge was high and they had positive attitudes towards the supply of antifungals, as well as strong intentions to sell them appropriately. No statistically significant differences were shown in questionnaire responses or actual behaviour across the four trial groups. Conclusion: This evaluation demonstrates that the interventions may have failed because of psychological ceiling effects, i.e. existing attitudes and intentions were already strong. Further studies are needed to identify factors that prevent strong intentions from being put into practice, in order to develop effective interventions.

KW - pharmacists

KW - antifungal agent

KW - non prescription drug

KW - clinical practice

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33845922041&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1211/ijpp.14.4.0004

DO - 10.1211/ijpp.14.4.0004

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 249

EP - 254

JO - International Journal of Pharmacy Practice

JF - International Journal of Pharmacy Practice

SN - 0961-7671

IS - 4

ER -