'Why are we learning this?': does studying the Holocaust encourage better citizenship values? : preliminary findings from Scotland

Henry Maitles

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The relationship between learning about the Holocaust and the development of positive values may seem common sense but in reality there is a complex level of development and understanding. This research (which was sponsored by the Scottish Government) was designed to ascertain whether learning about the Holocaust impacts on young people's general citizenship values and attitudes; does learning about the Holocaust allow them to extrapolate from the events of the Holocaust to present day issues, such as racism and discrimination. The research followed a cohort of approximately 100 pupils (aged 11-12) who had studied the Holocaust and compared their values one year later both in comparison to their earlier attitudes and compared to their peers who had not studied the Holocaust. This paper reports the findings. As we might expect, the results were not always as predicted, particularly when it came to the pupils understanding of anti-Semitism or genocide; in general though, our core group had maintained more positive values than they had before their lessons on the Holocaust and were more positive than their peers.
LanguageEnglish
Pages341-352
Number of pages12
JournalGenocide Studies and Prevention
Volume3
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2008

Fingerprint

Holocaust
citizenship
learning
Values
pupil
antisemitism
genocide
racism
discrimination
event
present
Group

Keywords

  • holocaust
  • values
  • citizenship
  • curricular studies
  • Scotland
  • schools

Cite this

@article{453ca47610364a6184c21a045f0ea133,
title = "'Why are we learning this?': does studying the Holocaust encourage better citizenship values? : preliminary findings from Scotland",
abstract = "The relationship between learning about the Holocaust and the development of positive values may seem common sense but in reality there is a complex level of development and understanding. This research (which was sponsored by the Scottish Government) was designed to ascertain whether learning about the Holocaust impacts on young people's general citizenship values and attitudes; does learning about the Holocaust allow them to extrapolate from the events of the Holocaust to present day issues, such as racism and discrimination. The research followed a cohort of approximately 100 pupils (aged 11-12) who had studied the Holocaust and compared their values one year later both in comparison to their earlier attitudes and compared to their peers who had not studied the Holocaust. This paper reports the findings. As we might expect, the results were not always as predicted, particularly when it came to the pupils understanding of anti-Semitism or genocide; in general though, our core group had maintained more positive values than they had before their lessons on the Holocaust and were more positive than their peers.",
keywords = "holocaust, values, citizenship, curricular studies, Scotland, schools",
author = "Henry Maitles",
year = "2008",
month = "12",
doi = "10.3138/gsp.3.3.341",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "341--352",
journal = "Genocide Studies and Prevention",
issn = "1911-0359",
number = "3",

}

'Why are we learning this?' : does studying the Holocaust encourage better citizenship values? : preliminary findings from Scotland. / Maitles, Henry.

In: Genocide Studies and Prevention, Vol. 3, No. 3, 12.2008, p. 341-352.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'Why are we learning this?'

T2 - Genocide Studies and Prevention

AU - Maitles, Henry

PY - 2008/12

Y1 - 2008/12

N2 - The relationship between learning about the Holocaust and the development of positive values may seem common sense but in reality there is a complex level of development and understanding. This research (which was sponsored by the Scottish Government) was designed to ascertain whether learning about the Holocaust impacts on young people's general citizenship values and attitudes; does learning about the Holocaust allow them to extrapolate from the events of the Holocaust to present day issues, such as racism and discrimination. The research followed a cohort of approximately 100 pupils (aged 11-12) who had studied the Holocaust and compared their values one year later both in comparison to their earlier attitudes and compared to their peers who had not studied the Holocaust. This paper reports the findings. As we might expect, the results were not always as predicted, particularly when it came to the pupils understanding of anti-Semitism or genocide; in general though, our core group had maintained more positive values than they had before their lessons on the Holocaust and were more positive than their peers.

AB - The relationship between learning about the Holocaust and the development of positive values may seem common sense but in reality there is a complex level of development and understanding. This research (which was sponsored by the Scottish Government) was designed to ascertain whether learning about the Holocaust impacts on young people's general citizenship values and attitudes; does learning about the Holocaust allow them to extrapolate from the events of the Holocaust to present day issues, such as racism and discrimination. The research followed a cohort of approximately 100 pupils (aged 11-12) who had studied the Holocaust and compared their values one year later both in comparison to their earlier attitudes and compared to their peers who had not studied the Holocaust. This paper reports the findings. As we might expect, the results were not always as predicted, particularly when it came to the pupils understanding of anti-Semitism or genocide; in general though, our core group had maintained more positive values than they had before their lessons on the Holocaust and were more positive than their peers.

KW - holocaust

KW - values

KW - citizenship

KW - curricular studies

KW - Scotland

KW - schools

U2 - 10.3138/gsp.3.3.341

DO - 10.3138/gsp.3.3.341

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 341

EP - 352

JO - Genocide Studies and Prevention

JF - Genocide Studies and Prevention

SN - 1911-0359

IS - 3

ER -