Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Purpose - This chapter approaches the topic of teaching the Western scholarly tradition in non-Western countries like the United Arab Emirates (UAE) from three perspectives employing the following metaphors: as a Public Servant motivated by public service to the goals and aims of the country's development articulated by UAE rulers and its citizens; as Cultural Diplomat, representing the Western tradition and its scholarly achievements while respecting other traditions; and as Intellectual Imperialist, aiming at a colonising incorporation of the UAE into the Western academic world.

Methodology/approach - The main methodology adopted is the Weberian ideal type, located within a comparative and historical context that produces the metaphors as analytically possible perspectives as a western expatriate faculty member. Additional critique is drawn from Bourdieu, Said, Freire, Giroux, Foucault, Goffman and cross-cultural organisation studies.

Findings - The findings consist of an analytic framework consisting of public servant, cultural diplomat and intellectual imperialist as a set of conceptions for analysing possible orientations of Western expatriate academics in developing countries.

Social implications - The implications are threefold: on a personal level, what experientially does each of the metaphors mean for one's sense of identity, profession, values and relationships; on a pedagogical level, what principles and values distinguish the curriculum and teaching styles as well as orientation to Arab and Islamic scholarship; and politically, what is the potential impact and unintended consequences for the indigenous culture, sovereignty and societal survival of a country under the heavy influence of globalisation. The contention of this chapter is that one cannot avoid adopting one or more of these roles and may even perform in contradictory ways.

Originality/value - The originality is in establishing a new set of analytic categories drawing on post-colonial, diplomacy and critical studies.

LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationInvesting in our Education
Subtitle of host publicationLeading, Learning, Researching and the Doctorate
EditorsAlison Taysum, Stephen Rayner
PublisherEmerald Publishing Limited
Pages93-123
Number of pages31
Volume13
ISBN (Electronic)9781784411312
ISBN (Print)9781784411329
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Publication series

NameInternational Perspectives on Higher Education Research
PublisherEmerald
Volume13
ISSN (Print)1479-3628

Fingerprint

United Arab Emirates
imperialism
diplomacy
public service
metaphor
diplomat
servants
leadership
Teaching
Values
teaching style
ideal type
methodology
sovereignty
profession
globalization
developing country
citizen
curriculum

Keywords

  • critical theory
  • globalisation
  • islamic scholarship
  • middle East
  • weberian critique

Cite this

Samier, E. A. (2014). Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates. In A. Taysum, & S. Rayner (Eds.), Investing in our Education: Leading, Learning, Researching and the Doctorate (Vol. 13, pp. 93-123). (International Perspectives on Higher Education Research; Vol. 13). Emerald Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-362820140000013005
Samier, Eugenie A. / Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates. Investing in our Education: Leading, Learning, Researching and the Doctorate . editor / Alison Taysum ; Stephen Rayner. Vol. 13 Emerald Publishing Limited, 2014. pp. 93-123 (International Perspectives on Higher Education Research).
@inbook{0fb49ff50eb145f8b70059dc603f6df4,
title = "Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates",
abstract = "Purpose - This chapter approaches the topic of teaching the Western scholarly tradition in non-Western countries like the United Arab Emirates (UAE) from three perspectives employing the following metaphors: as a Public Servant motivated by public service to the goals and aims of the country's development articulated by UAE rulers and its citizens; as Cultural Diplomat, representing the Western tradition and its scholarly achievements while respecting other traditions; and as Intellectual Imperialist, aiming at a colonising incorporation of the UAE into the Western academic world.Methodology/approach - The main methodology adopted is the Weberian ideal type, located within a comparative and historical context that produces the metaphors as analytically possible perspectives as a western expatriate faculty member. Additional critique is drawn from Bourdieu, Said, Freire, Giroux, Foucault, Goffman and cross-cultural organisation studies.Findings - The findings consist of an analytic framework consisting of public servant, cultural diplomat and intellectual imperialist as a set of conceptions for analysing possible orientations of Western expatriate academics in developing countries.Social implications - The implications are threefold: on a personal level, what experientially does each of the metaphors mean for one's sense of identity, profession, values and relationships; on a pedagogical level, what principles and values distinguish the curriculum and teaching styles as well as orientation to Arab and Islamic scholarship; and politically, what is the potential impact and unintended consequences for the indigenous culture, sovereignty and societal survival of a country under the heavy influence of globalisation. The contention of this chapter is that one cannot avoid adopting one or more of these roles and may even perform in contradictory ways.Originality/value - The originality is in establishing a new set of analytic categories drawing on post-colonial, diplomacy and critical studies.",
keywords = "critical theory, globalisation, islamic scholarship, middle East, weberian critique",
author = "Samier, {Eugenie A.}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1108/S1479-362820140000013005",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781784411329",
volume = "13",
series = "International Perspectives on Higher Education Research",
publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
pages = "93--123",
editor = "Alison Taysum and Stephen Rayner",
booktitle = "Investing in our Education",

}

Samier, EA 2014, Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates. in A Taysum & S Rayner (eds), Investing in our Education: Leading, Learning, Researching and the Doctorate . vol. 13, International Perspectives on Higher Education Research, vol. 13, Emerald Publishing Limited, pp. 93-123. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-362820140000013005

Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates. / Samier, Eugenie A.

Investing in our Education: Leading, Learning, Researching and the Doctorate . ed. / Alison Taysum; Stephen Rayner. Vol. 13 Emerald Publishing Limited, 2014. p. 93-123 (International Perspectives on Higher Education Research; Vol. 13).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates

AU - Samier, Eugenie A.

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Purpose - This chapter approaches the topic of teaching the Western scholarly tradition in non-Western countries like the United Arab Emirates (UAE) from three perspectives employing the following metaphors: as a Public Servant motivated by public service to the goals and aims of the country's development articulated by UAE rulers and its citizens; as Cultural Diplomat, representing the Western tradition and its scholarly achievements while respecting other traditions; and as Intellectual Imperialist, aiming at a colonising incorporation of the UAE into the Western academic world.Methodology/approach - The main methodology adopted is the Weberian ideal type, located within a comparative and historical context that produces the metaphors as analytically possible perspectives as a western expatriate faculty member. Additional critique is drawn from Bourdieu, Said, Freire, Giroux, Foucault, Goffman and cross-cultural organisation studies.Findings - The findings consist of an analytic framework consisting of public servant, cultural diplomat and intellectual imperialist as a set of conceptions for analysing possible orientations of Western expatriate academics in developing countries.Social implications - The implications are threefold: on a personal level, what experientially does each of the metaphors mean for one's sense of identity, profession, values and relationships; on a pedagogical level, what principles and values distinguish the curriculum and teaching styles as well as orientation to Arab and Islamic scholarship; and politically, what is the potential impact and unintended consequences for the indigenous culture, sovereignty and societal survival of a country under the heavy influence of globalisation. The contention of this chapter is that one cannot avoid adopting one or more of these roles and may even perform in contradictory ways.Originality/value - The originality is in establishing a new set of analytic categories drawing on post-colonial, diplomacy and critical studies.

AB - Purpose - This chapter approaches the topic of teaching the Western scholarly tradition in non-Western countries like the United Arab Emirates (UAE) from three perspectives employing the following metaphors: as a Public Servant motivated by public service to the goals and aims of the country's development articulated by UAE rulers and its citizens; as Cultural Diplomat, representing the Western tradition and its scholarly achievements while respecting other traditions; and as Intellectual Imperialist, aiming at a colonising incorporation of the UAE into the Western academic world.Methodology/approach - The main methodology adopted is the Weberian ideal type, located within a comparative and historical context that produces the metaphors as analytically possible perspectives as a western expatriate faculty member. Additional critique is drawn from Bourdieu, Said, Freire, Giroux, Foucault, Goffman and cross-cultural organisation studies.Findings - The findings consist of an analytic framework consisting of public servant, cultural diplomat and intellectual imperialist as a set of conceptions for analysing possible orientations of Western expatriate academics in developing countries.Social implications - The implications are threefold: on a personal level, what experientially does each of the metaphors mean for one's sense of identity, profession, values and relationships; on a pedagogical level, what principles and values distinguish the curriculum and teaching styles as well as orientation to Arab and Islamic scholarship; and politically, what is the potential impact and unintended consequences for the indigenous culture, sovereignty and societal survival of a country under the heavy influence of globalisation. The contention of this chapter is that one cannot avoid adopting one or more of these roles and may even perform in contradictory ways.Originality/value - The originality is in establishing a new set of analytic categories drawing on post-colonial, diplomacy and critical studies.

KW - critical theory

KW - globalisation

KW - islamic scholarship

KW - middle East

KW - weberian critique

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84918506272&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1108/S1479-362820140000013005

DO - 10.1108/S1479-362820140000013005

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781784411329

VL - 13

T3 - International Perspectives on Higher Education Research

SP - 93

EP - 123

BT - Investing in our Education

A2 - Taysum, Alison

A2 - Rayner, Stephen

PB - Emerald Publishing Limited

ER -

Samier EA. Western doctoral programmes as public service, cultural diplomacy or intellectual imperialism? Expatriate educational leadership teaching in the United Arab Emirates. In Taysum A, Rayner S, editors, Investing in our Education: Leading, Learning, Researching and the Doctorate . Vol. 13. Emerald Publishing Limited. 2014. p. 93-123. (International Perspectives on Higher Education Research). https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-362820140000013005