Video ethics with infants: international perspectives and challenges.

Jayne White, Helen Marwick, Katia de Souza Amorim, Maria Clotilde Rossetti-Ferreira, Meripa Toso, Tim Baice, Elisabeth Ravlich, Corinne Rivalland , Hilary Monk, Niina Rutanen

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

International teams of researchers located across New Zealand, Scotland, Finland, Samoa, Cook Islands, USA, Australia and Brazil embarked on a video project last year. Their quest was to try to understand the social and emotional experience of infants as they enter into early childhood education services for the first time. Since the project draws heavily on video excerpts of key events such as arrival, departure, routine, play and interactions, each team sought ethical consent to undertake this work. This presentation outlines some of the many and diverse perspectives towards such an undertaking for each country, and, in doing so, highlights the considerable challenges facing researchers who work in this field. The research that informs this presentation is based on a current Teaching, Research and Learning Initiative that seeks to better understand the pedagogic nature of two-year-old dialogues in preschool classrooms that were initially established to support older learners. Two year-olds, their peers, and teachers were simultaneously filmed from their visual fields: the first tracking the two year-old explicitly; the second from the teachers visual standpoint; the third taking into account the wider visual field. Teachers across two different early childhood education sites were separately asked to interpret a series of dialogic events of pedagogic significance for two year-olds based on this polyphonic
footage during their staff meetings. Researchers undertook the same process in the Video Lab. Their collective insights were subsequently shared as a secondary source of visual surplus which informed subsequent phases of analysis and provided a multi-voiced polyphony of insight concerning two year-old experience, the role of teachers, peers and the wider environment in promoting (or stifling) learning. The analysis draws from Bakhtin’s dialogic methodology (1986) which posits that calls upon interlocutors and researchers alike to immerse themselves in the communicative links that grant meaning through a chorus of (plural) voices.
LanguageEnglish
Pages173-174
Number of pages2
Publication statusPublished - 18 Jun 2017
EventAssociation for Visual Pedagogies Conference - Aalborg University, Aalborg, Denmark
Duration: 15 Jun 2017 → …

Conference

ConferenceAssociation for Visual Pedagogies Conference
CountryDenmark
CityAalborg
Period15/06/17 → …

Fingerprint

infant
video
moral philosophy
teacher
pedagogics
childhood
key event
Samoa
Polynesia
teaching research
Finland
learning
education
New Zealand
experience
Brazil
dialogue
staff
classroom
event

Keywords

  • early childhood education
  • research
  • video
  • pedagogy

Cite this

White, J., Marwick, H., Amorim, K. D. S., Rossetti-Ferreira, M. C., Toso, M., Baice, T., ... Rutanen, N. (2017). Video ethics with infants: international perspectives and challenges.. 173-174. Paper presented at Association for Visual Pedagogies Conference, Aalborg, Denmark.
White, Jayne ; Marwick, Helen ; Amorim, Katia de Souza ; Rossetti-Ferreira, Maria Clotilde ; Toso, Meripa ; Baice, Tim ; Ravlich, Elisabeth ; Rivalland , Corinne ; Monk, Hilary ; Rutanen, Niina. / Video ethics with infants : international perspectives and challenges. Paper presented at Association for Visual Pedagogies Conference, Aalborg, Denmark.2 p.
@conference{83ac5322e1164570ad5157c35c955ffd,
title = "Video ethics with infants: international perspectives and challenges.",
abstract = "International teams of researchers located across New Zealand, Scotland, Finland, Samoa, Cook Islands, USA, Australia and Brazil embarked on a video project last year. Their quest was to try to understand the social and emotional experience of infants as they enter into early childhood education services for the first time. Since the project draws heavily on video excerpts of key events such as arrival, departure, routine, play and interactions, each team sought ethical consent to undertake this work. This presentation outlines some of the many and diverse perspectives towards such an undertaking for each country, and, in doing so, highlights the considerable challenges facing researchers who work in this field. The research that informs this presentation is based on a current Teaching, Research and Learning Initiative that seeks to better understand the pedagogic nature of two-year-old dialogues in preschool classrooms that were initially established to support older learners. Two year-olds, their peers, and teachers were simultaneously filmed from their visual fields: the first tracking the two year-old explicitly; the second from the teachers visual standpoint; the third taking into account the wider visual field. Teachers across two different early childhood education sites were separately asked to interpret a series of dialogic events of pedagogic significance for two year-olds based on this polyphonicfootage during their staff meetings. Researchers undertook the same process in the Video Lab. Their collective insights were subsequently shared as a secondary source of visual surplus which informed subsequent phases of analysis and provided a multi-voiced polyphony of insight concerning two year-old experience, the role of teachers, peers and the wider environment in promoting (or stifling) learning. The analysis draws from Bakhtin’s dialogic methodology (1986) which posits that calls upon interlocutors and researchers alike to immerse themselves in the communicative links that grant meaning through a chorus of (plural) voices.",
keywords = "early childhood education, research, video, pedagogy",
author = "Jayne White and Helen Marwick and Amorim, {Katia de Souza} and Rossetti-Ferreira, {Maria Clotilde} and Meripa Toso and Tim Baice and Elisabeth Ravlich and Corinne Rivalland and Hilary Monk and Niina Rutanen",
year = "2017",
month = "6",
day = "18",
language = "English",
pages = "173--174",
note = "Association for Visual Pedagogies Conference ; Conference date: 15-06-2017",

}

White, J, Marwick, H, Amorim, KDS, Rossetti-Ferreira, MC, Toso, M, Baice, T, Ravlich, E, Rivalland , C, Monk, H & Rutanen, N 2017, 'Video ethics with infants: international perspectives and challenges.' Paper presented at Association for Visual Pedagogies Conference, Aalborg, Denmark, 15/06/17, pp. 173-174.

Video ethics with infants : international perspectives and challenges. / White, Jayne; Marwick, Helen; Amorim, Katia de Souza ; Rossetti-Ferreira, Maria Clotilde ; Toso, Meripa ; Baice, Tim ; Ravlich, Elisabeth; Rivalland , Corinne ; Monk, Hilary; Rutanen, Niina.

2017. 173-174 Paper presented at Association for Visual Pedagogies Conference, Aalborg, Denmark.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Video ethics with infants

T2 - international perspectives and challenges.

AU - White, Jayne

AU - Marwick, Helen

AU - Amorim, Katia de Souza

AU - Rossetti-Ferreira, Maria Clotilde

AU - Toso, Meripa

AU - Baice, Tim

AU - Ravlich, Elisabeth

AU - Rivalland , Corinne

AU - Monk, Hilary

AU - Rutanen, Niina

PY - 2017/6/18

Y1 - 2017/6/18

N2 - International teams of researchers located across New Zealand, Scotland, Finland, Samoa, Cook Islands, USA, Australia and Brazil embarked on a video project last year. Their quest was to try to understand the social and emotional experience of infants as they enter into early childhood education services for the first time. Since the project draws heavily on video excerpts of key events such as arrival, departure, routine, play and interactions, each team sought ethical consent to undertake this work. This presentation outlines some of the many and diverse perspectives towards such an undertaking for each country, and, in doing so, highlights the considerable challenges facing researchers who work in this field. The research that informs this presentation is based on a current Teaching, Research and Learning Initiative that seeks to better understand the pedagogic nature of two-year-old dialogues in preschool classrooms that were initially established to support older learners. Two year-olds, their peers, and teachers were simultaneously filmed from their visual fields: the first tracking the two year-old explicitly; the second from the teachers visual standpoint; the third taking into account the wider visual field. Teachers across two different early childhood education sites were separately asked to interpret a series of dialogic events of pedagogic significance for two year-olds based on this polyphonicfootage during their staff meetings. Researchers undertook the same process in the Video Lab. Their collective insights were subsequently shared as a secondary source of visual surplus which informed subsequent phases of analysis and provided a multi-voiced polyphony of insight concerning two year-old experience, the role of teachers, peers and the wider environment in promoting (or stifling) learning. The analysis draws from Bakhtin’s dialogic methodology (1986) which posits that calls upon interlocutors and researchers alike to immerse themselves in the communicative links that grant meaning through a chorus of (plural) voices.

AB - International teams of researchers located across New Zealand, Scotland, Finland, Samoa, Cook Islands, USA, Australia and Brazil embarked on a video project last year. Their quest was to try to understand the social and emotional experience of infants as they enter into early childhood education services for the first time. Since the project draws heavily on video excerpts of key events such as arrival, departure, routine, play and interactions, each team sought ethical consent to undertake this work. This presentation outlines some of the many and diverse perspectives towards such an undertaking for each country, and, in doing so, highlights the considerable challenges facing researchers who work in this field. The research that informs this presentation is based on a current Teaching, Research and Learning Initiative that seeks to better understand the pedagogic nature of two-year-old dialogues in preschool classrooms that were initially established to support older learners. Two year-olds, their peers, and teachers were simultaneously filmed from their visual fields: the first tracking the two year-old explicitly; the second from the teachers visual standpoint; the third taking into account the wider visual field. Teachers across two different early childhood education sites were separately asked to interpret a series of dialogic events of pedagogic significance for two year-olds based on this polyphonicfootage during their staff meetings. Researchers undertook the same process in the Video Lab. Their collective insights were subsequently shared as a secondary source of visual surplus which informed subsequent phases of analysis and provided a multi-voiced polyphony of insight concerning two year-old experience, the role of teachers, peers and the wider environment in promoting (or stifling) learning. The analysis draws from Bakhtin’s dialogic methodology (1986) which posits that calls upon interlocutors and researchers alike to immerse themselves in the communicative links that grant meaning through a chorus of (plural) voices.

KW - early childhood education

KW - research

KW - video

KW - pedagogy

M3 - Paper

SP - 173

EP - 174

ER -

White J, Marwick H, Amorim KDS, Rossetti-Ferreira MC, Toso M, Baice T et al. Video ethics with infants: international perspectives and challenges.. 2017. Paper presented at Association for Visual Pedagogies Conference, Aalborg, Denmark.