Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making: reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings

Stephen Oliver, Saleh Seyedzadeh, Farzad Pour Rahimian

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Retrofit analysis relies on intuition and faith in the simulations used to justify strategy selection. However, intuition is built upon belief systems which become increasing unjustifiable as building operation deviates from design whether in utilisation, occupant behaviours or climate models. Higher education facilities are known for persistently low but well recorded occupant presence and density, and therefore are susceptible to counterintuitive behaviours related to utilisation. When operation has little correlation with design it is possible for performance issues to appear to be symptoms of design considerations rather than direct root of the issue. Using an EnergyPlus and SBEM virtual case study based on a floor of a university building and class registration data this paper describes how lighting retrofit simulation alludes to intuitive thermal property and HVAC efficiency concerns where heating management is the primary cause for concern. In doing so, it demonstrates a new approach to scheduling utilisation in higher education facilities and a method of meaningfully modelling BMS systems in EnergyPlus as replacement for the efficiency credits method. Results are discussed in terms of relevance to legislative compliance, cost-benefit analysis and how the scheduling methods contribute to intuitive analysis of low utilisation buildings.

Conference

Conference36th CIB W78 2019 Conference
Abbreviated titleCIB W78
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityNewcastle
Period18/09/1920/09/19

Fingerprint

Education
Decision making
Scheduling
Climate models
Cost benefit analysis
Thermodynamic properties
Lighting
Heating
Compliance
HVAC

Keywords

  • retrofit analysis
  • occupancy
  • compliance
  • low utilisation

Cite this

Oliver, S., Seyedzadeh, S., & Pour Rahimian, F. (2019). Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making: reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings. Paper presented at 36th CIB W78 2019 Conference, Newcastle, United Kingdom.
Oliver, Stephen ; Seyedzadeh, Saleh ; Pour Rahimian, Farzad. / Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making : reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings. Paper presented at 36th CIB W78 2019 Conference, Newcastle, United Kingdom.12 p.
@conference{75f31f2063ef419bbe51ac7fe68ab657,
title = "Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making: reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings",
abstract = "Retrofit analysis relies on intuition and faith in the simulations used to justify strategy selection. However, intuition is built upon belief systems which become increasing unjustifiable as building operation deviates from design whether in utilisation, occupant behaviours or climate models. Higher education facilities are known for persistently low but well recorded occupant presence and density, and therefore are susceptible to counterintuitive behaviours related to utilisation. When operation has little correlation with design it is possible for performance issues to appear to be symptoms of design considerations rather than direct root of the issue. Using an EnergyPlus and SBEM virtual case study based on a floor of a university building and class registration data this paper describes how lighting retrofit simulation alludes to intuitive thermal property and HVAC efficiency concerns where heating management is the primary cause for concern. In doing so, it demonstrates a new approach to scheduling utilisation in higher education facilities and a method of meaningfully modelling BMS systems in EnergyPlus as replacement for the efficiency credits method. Results are discussed in terms of relevance to legislative compliance, cost-benefit analysis and how the scheduling methods contribute to intuitive analysis of low utilisation buildings.",
keywords = "retrofit analysis, occupancy, compliance, low utilisation",
author = "Stephen Oliver and Saleh Seyedzadeh and {Pour Rahimian}, Farzad",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "18",
language = "English",
note = "36th CIB W78 2019 Conference, CIB W78 ; Conference date: 18-09-2019 Through 20-09-2019",

}

Oliver, S, Seyedzadeh, S & Pour Rahimian, F 2019, 'Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making: reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings' Paper presented at 36th CIB W78 2019 Conference, Newcastle, United Kingdom, 18/09/19 - 20/09/19, .

Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making : reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings. / Oliver, Stephen; Seyedzadeh, Saleh; Pour Rahimian, Farzad.

2019. Paper presented at 36th CIB W78 2019 Conference, Newcastle, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making

T2 - reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings

AU - Oliver, Stephen

AU - Seyedzadeh, Saleh

AU - Pour Rahimian, Farzad

PY - 2019/9/18

Y1 - 2019/9/18

N2 - Retrofit analysis relies on intuition and faith in the simulations used to justify strategy selection. However, intuition is built upon belief systems which become increasing unjustifiable as building operation deviates from design whether in utilisation, occupant behaviours or climate models. Higher education facilities are known for persistently low but well recorded occupant presence and density, and therefore are susceptible to counterintuitive behaviours related to utilisation. When operation has little correlation with design it is possible for performance issues to appear to be symptoms of design considerations rather than direct root of the issue. Using an EnergyPlus and SBEM virtual case study based on a floor of a university building and class registration data this paper describes how lighting retrofit simulation alludes to intuitive thermal property and HVAC efficiency concerns where heating management is the primary cause for concern. In doing so, it demonstrates a new approach to scheduling utilisation in higher education facilities and a method of meaningfully modelling BMS systems in EnergyPlus as replacement for the efficiency credits method. Results are discussed in terms of relevance to legislative compliance, cost-benefit analysis and how the scheduling methods contribute to intuitive analysis of low utilisation buildings.

AB - Retrofit analysis relies on intuition and faith in the simulations used to justify strategy selection. However, intuition is built upon belief systems which become increasing unjustifiable as building operation deviates from design whether in utilisation, occupant behaviours or climate models. Higher education facilities are known for persistently low but well recorded occupant presence and density, and therefore are susceptible to counterintuitive behaviours related to utilisation. When operation has little correlation with design it is possible for performance issues to appear to be symptoms of design considerations rather than direct root of the issue. Using an EnergyPlus and SBEM virtual case study based on a floor of a university building and class registration data this paper describes how lighting retrofit simulation alludes to intuitive thermal property and HVAC efficiency concerns where heating management is the primary cause for concern. In doing so, it demonstrates a new approach to scheduling utilisation in higher education facilities and a method of meaningfully modelling BMS systems in EnergyPlus as replacement for the efficiency credits method. Results are discussed in terms of relevance to legislative compliance, cost-benefit analysis and how the scheduling methods contribute to intuitive analysis of low utilisation buildings.

KW - retrofit analysis

KW - occupancy

KW - compliance

KW - low utilisation

UR - http://cibw78.northumbria-eee.co.uk/

M3 - Paper

ER -

Oliver S, Seyedzadeh S, Pour Rahimian F. Using real occupancy in retrofit decision-making: reducing the performance gap in low utilisation higher education buildings. 2019. Paper presented at 36th CIB W78 2019 Conference, Newcastle, United Kingdom.