Using old stuff and thinking in a new way: material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Past and current historiography and criticism of architecture have created a fictitious division - from the design point of view - between new architecture and conservation of the old. They have been dictated more by prejudices and fashionable visual imagery than by analysis of previous realisations, in which one could learn how pre-existences have influenced new architecture. Different phases in buildings are often ignored, treated as unitary creations belonging to a single design or privileging only one of their phases, limiting the critique to visual and formal aspects. This study of architectural transformations demonstrates that he way in which existing architecture is being reused, conserved and transformed reflects the culture of its time. The dialectics and attitudes of their architects, builders and patrons are expressed in the relationship of the new architecture with the existing material and how it is presented in the final project. Contrary to painting and sculpture practice, in architecture, materials and structures can be reused. Architecture goes beyond the idea and the object and can only be created and analysed as individual projects, where use and three-dimensional aspects are crucial.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Cultural Role of Architecture
Subtitle of host publicationContemporary and Historical Perspectives
EditorsP Emmons, J Lomholt, J Hendrix
Place of PublicationAbingdon
Pages68-77
Number of pages10
Publication statusPublished - 31 Jan 2012

Fingerprint

Material Culture
Conservation
Dialectics
Builders
Three-dimensional
Prejudice
Visual Imagery
Criticism
Historiography
Patron

Keywords

  • architectural conservation
  • architectural design
  • culture
  • architecture
  • historic buildings
  • physical and cultural context
  • transformation
  • architectural reuse
  • architects
  • patronage
  • fashion
  • material culture
  • conservation
  • theory
  • criticism

Cite this

Gonzalez-Longo, C. (2012). Using old stuff and thinking in a new way: material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture. In P. Emmons, J. Lomholt, & J. Hendrix (Eds.), The Cultural Role of Architecture: Contemporary and Historical Perspectives (pp. 68-77). Abingdon.
Gonzalez-Longo, Cristina. / Using old stuff and thinking in a new way : material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture. The Cultural Role of Architecture: Contemporary and Historical Perspectives. editor / P Emmons ; J Lomholt ; J Hendrix. Abingdon, 2012. pp. 68-77
@inbook{cd6d548b8df54b2bb1d60f32e8a1e0ff,
title = "Using old stuff and thinking in a new way: material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture",
abstract = "Past and current historiography and criticism of architecture have created a fictitious division - from the design point of view - between new architecture and conservation of the old. They have been dictated more by prejudices and fashionable visual imagery than by analysis of previous realisations, in which one could learn how pre-existences have influenced new architecture. Different phases in buildings are often ignored, treated as unitary creations belonging to a single design or privileging only one of their phases, limiting the critique to visual and formal aspects. This study of architectural transformations demonstrates that he way in which existing architecture is being reused, conserved and transformed reflects the culture of its time. The dialectics and attitudes of their architects, builders and patrons are expressed in the relationship of the new architecture with the existing material and how it is presented in the final project. Contrary to painting and sculpture practice, in architecture, materials and structures can be reused. Architecture goes beyond the idea and the object and can only be created and analysed as individual projects, where use and three-dimensional aspects are crucial.",
keywords = "architectural conservation, architectural design, culture, architecture, historic buildings, physical and cultural context, transformation, architectural reuse, architects, patronage, fashion, material culture, conservation, theory, criticism",
author = "Cristina Gonzalez-Longo",
year = "2012",
month = "1",
day = "31",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780415783415",
pages = "68--77",
editor = "P Emmons and J Lomholt and J Hendrix",
booktitle = "The Cultural Role of Architecture",

}

Gonzalez-Longo, C 2012, Using old stuff and thinking in a new way: material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture. in P Emmons, J Lomholt & J Hendrix (eds), The Cultural Role of Architecture: Contemporary and Historical Perspectives. Abingdon, pp. 68-77.

Using old stuff and thinking in a new way : material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture. / Gonzalez-Longo, Cristina.

The Cultural Role of Architecture: Contemporary and Historical Perspectives. ed. / P Emmons; J Lomholt; J Hendrix. Abingdon, 2012. p. 68-77.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Using old stuff and thinking in a new way

T2 - material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture

AU - Gonzalez-Longo, Cristina

PY - 2012/1/31

Y1 - 2012/1/31

N2 - Past and current historiography and criticism of architecture have created a fictitious division - from the design point of view - between new architecture and conservation of the old. They have been dictated more by prejudices and fashionable visual imagery than by analysis of previous realisations, in which one could learn how pre-existences have influenced new architecture. Different phases in buildings are often ignored, treated as unitary creations belonging to a single design or privileging only one of their phases, limiting the critique to visual and formal aspects. This study of architectural transformations demonstrates that he way in which existing architecture is being reused, conserved and transformed reflects the culture of its time. The dialectics and attitudes of their architects, builders and patrons are expressed in the relationship of the new architecture with the existing material and how it is presented in the final project. Contrary to painting and sculpture practice, in architecture, materials and structures can be reused. Architecture goes beyond the idea and the object and can only be created and analysed as individual projects, where use and three-dimensional aspects are crucial.

AB - Past and current historiography and criticism of architecture have created a fictitious division - from the design point of view - between new architecture and conservation of the old. They have been dictated more by prejudices and fashionable visual imagery than by analysis of previous realisations, in which one could learn how pre-existences have influenced new architecture. Different phases in buildings are often ignored, treated as unitary creations belonging to a single design or privileging only one of their phases, limiting the critique to visual and formal aspects. This study of architectural transformations demonstrates that he way in which existing architecture is being reused, conserved and transformed reflects the culture of its time. The dialectics and attitudes of their architects, builders and patrons are expressed in the relationship of the new architecture with the existing material and how it is presented in the final project. Contrary to painting and sculpture practice, in architecture, materials and structures can be reused. Architecture goes beyond the idea and the object and can only be created and analysed as individual projects, where use and three-dimensional aspects are crucial.

KW - architectural conservation

KW - architectural design

KW - culture

KW - architecture

KW - historic buildings

KW - physical and cultural context

KW - transformation

KW - architectural reuse

KW - architects

KW - patronage

KW - fashion

KW - material culture

KW - conservation

KW - theory

KW - criticism

UR - http://www.routledge.com/books/details/9780415783415/

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780415783415

SP - 68

EP - 77

BT - The Cultural Role of Architecture

A2 - Emmons, P

A2 - Lomholt, J

A2 - Hendrix, J

CY - Abingdon

ER -

Gonzalez-Longo C. Using old stuff and thinking in a new way: material culture, conservation and fashion in architecture. In Emmons P, Lomholt J, Hendrix J, editors, The Cultural Role of Architecture: Contemporary and Historical Perspectives. Abingdon. 2012. p. 68-77