Understanding citizenship within a health and social care context in Scotland using community based participatory research methods

Gillian MacIntyre, Nicola Cogan, Ailsa Stewart, Neil Quinn, Michael Rowe, Maria O'Connell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Community based participatory research (CBPR) principles were used to develop a conceptual framework of citizenship for people experiencing mental health problems and/or other life disrupting events in Scotland. This case study illustrates the use of a participatory methodology replicating an approach adopted as part of an international collaboration in understanding citizenship across diverse social and cultural contexts. Reflecting on the approach taken, we argue that it encourages the development of a model of citizenship that is entirely grounded in the perspectives and lived experiences of the participants. We consider the importance of ‘meaningfully’ engaging peer researchers throughout the research process, exploring the methodological issues, challenges and opportunities when working in partnership. The importance of adopting a reflexive approach throughout the research approach is emphasised. We consider how the need for adequate resources, preparatory work, training and research management is key to the success of a CBPR approach with peer researchers. Finally, we suggest making appropriate adaptations to any research methodology when working with diverse populations, particularly the ‘seldom heard’ groups within society, in order to inform health and social policy and practice.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages15
JournalSAGE Research Methods Cases
Early online date17 Dec 2018
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 17 Dec 2018

Fingerprint

research method
citizenship
research approach
health
community
methodology
research process
health policy
mental health
event
management
resources
experience
Group
Society
Social Policy

Keywords

  • social policy
  • public policy
  • mental health policy
  • citizenship

Cite this

@article{3124a93ebb4b4b38a854d88301828ea1,
title = "Understanding citizenship within a health and social care context in Scotland using community based participatory research methods",
abstract = "Community based participatory research (CBPR) principles were used to develop a conceptual framework of citizenship for people experiencing mental health problems and/or other life disrupting events in Scotland. This case study illustrates the use of a participatory methodology replicating an approach adopted as part of an international collaboration in understanding citizenship across diverse social and cultural contexts. Reflecting on the approach taken, we argue that it encourages the development of a model of citizenship that is entirely grounded in the perspectives and lived experiences of the participants. We consider the importance of ‘meaningfully’ engaging peer researchers throughout the research process, exploring the methodological issues, challenges and opportunities when working in partnership. The importance of adopting a reflexive approach throughout the research approach is emphasised. We consider how the need for adequate resources, preparatory work, training and research management is key to the success of a CBPR approach with peer researchers. Finally, we suggest making appropriate adaptations to any research methodology when working with diverse populations, particularly the ‘seldom heard’ groups within society, in order to inform health and social policy and practice.",
keywords = "social policy, public policy, mental health policy, citizenship",
author = "Gillian MacIntyre and Nicola Cogan and Ailsa Stewart and Neil Quinn and Michael Rowe and Maria O'Connell",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "17",
doi = "10.4135/9781526484918",
language = "English",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Understanding citizenship within a health and social care context in Scotland using community based participatory research methods

AU - MacIntyre, Gillian

AU - Cogan, Nicola

AU - Stewart, Ailsa

AU - Quinn, Neil

AU - Rowe, Michael

AU - O'Connell, Maria

PY - 2018/12/17

Y1 - 2018/12/17

N2 - Community based participatory research (CBPR) principles were used to develop a conceptual framework of citizenship for people experiencing mental health problems and/or other life disrupting events in Scotland. This case study illustrates the use of a participatory methodology replicating an approach adopted as part of an international collaboration in understanding citizenship across diverse social and cultural contexts. Reflecting on the approach taken, we argue that it encourages the development of a model of citizenship that is entirely grounded in the perspectives and lived experiences of the participants. We consider the importance of ‘meaningfully’ engaging peer researchers throughout the research process, exploring the methodological issues, challenges and opportunities when working in partnership. The importance of adopting a reflexive approach throughout the research approach is emphasised. We consider how the need for adequate resources, preparatory work, training and research management is key to the success of a CBPR approach with peer researchers. Finally, we suggest making appropriate adaptations to any research methodology when working with diverse populations, particularly the ‘seldom heard’ groups within society, in order to inform health and social policy and practice.

AB - Community based participatory research (CBPR) principles were used to develop a conceptual framework of citizenship for people experiencing mental health problems and/or other life disrupting events in Scotland. This case study illustrates the use of a participatory methodology replicating an approach adopted as part of an international collaboration in understanding citizenship across diverse social and cultural contexts. Reflecting on the approach taken, we argue that it encourages the development of a model of citizenship that is entirely grounded in the perspectives and lived experiences of the participants. We consider the importance of ‘meaningfully’ engaging peer researchers throughout the research process, exploring the methodological issues, challenges and opportunities when working in partnership. The importance of adopting a reflexive approach throughout the research approach is emphasised. We consider how the need for adequate resources, preparatory work, training and research management is key to the success of a CBPR approach with peer researchers. Finally, we suggest making appropriate adaptations to any research methodology when working with diverse populations, particularly the ‘seldom heard’ groups within society, in order to inform health and social policy and practice.

KW - social policy

KW - public policy

KW - mental health policy

KW - citizenship

UR - http://methods.sagepub.com/cases

U2 - 10.4135/9781526484918

DO - 10.4135/9781526484918

M3 - Article

ER -