Under the shadow of defeat: the state and the commemoration of the Franco-Prussian war, 1871-1914

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The French defeat in the Franco‐Prussian War represented a crushing blow for the Second Empire, the fledgling Republic and the French nation. While intellectuals and policymakers embarked on a process of soul‐searching, the French public responded to the defeat with an unprecedented wave of commemorative acts predicated on the belief that the French national defence was more honourable and more glorious than the German victory. In recent years, much attention has been devoted to the Third Republic's celebration of the French revolutionary past, and the role these celebrations played in developing and sustaining republican values. In this article, however, I examine the Republic's comparative neglect of its more recent past. The first section outlines the practical considerations and obligations behind the state's work to bury those who died in the Franco‐Prussian War. The second section explores the government's intervention in and influence over certain commemorative acts. In the third section, the article examines sustained government resistance to the creation of a commemorative medal for veterans of the war. I argue that successive governments adopted a relatively passive role in the war commemorations owing to fears that resurrecting memories of the war might serve to undermine the stability and legitimacy of the Republic.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)323-344
Number of pages22
JournalFrench History
Volume16
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2002

Fingerprint

Defeat
Franco-Prussian War
Commemoration
Government
Second Empire
Waves
Obligation
Legitimacy
Neglect
Revolution
Politicians
Victory
Republican
Third Republic
Medal
Veterans

Keywords

  • Franco-Prussian war
  • france
  • defeat
  • commemoration

Cite this

@article{1664539ac4b94a949033202d6c900fce,
title = "Under the shadow of defeat: the state and the commemoration of the Franco-Prussian war, 1871-1914",
abstract = "The French defeat in the Franco‐Prussian War represented a crushing blow for the Second Empire, the fledgling Republic and the French nation. While intellectuals and policymakers embarked on a process of soul‐searching, the French public responded to the defeat with an unprecedented wave of commemorative acts predicated on the belief that the French national defence was more honourable and more glorious than the German victory. In recent years, much attention has been devoted to the Third Republic's celebration of the French revolutionary past, and the role these celebrations played in developing and sustaining republican values. In this article, however, I examine the Republic's comparative neglect of its more recent past. The first section outlines the practical considerations and obligations behind the state's work to bury those who died in the Franco‐Prussian War. The second section explores the government's intervention in and influence over certain commemorative acts. In the third section, the article examines sustained government resistance to the creation of a commemorative medal for veterans of the war. I argue that successive governments adopted a relatively passive role in the war commemorations owing to fears that resurrecting memories of the war might serve to undermine the stability and legitimacy of the Republic.",
keywords = "Franco-Prussian war, france, defeat, commemoration",
author = "Karine Varley",
year = "2002",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1093/fh/16.3.323",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "323--344",
journal = "French History",
issn = "0269-1191",
number = "3",

}

Under the shadow of defeat : the state and the commemoration of the Franco-Prussian war, 1871-1914. / Varley, Karine.

In: French History, Vol. 16, No. 3, 09.2002, p. 323-344.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Under the shadow of defeat

T2 - the state and the commemoration of the Franco-Prussian war, 1871-1914

AU - Varley, Karine

PY - 2002/9

Y1 - 2002/9

N2 - The French defeat in the Franco‐Prussian War represented a crushing blow for the Second Empire, the fledgling Republic and the French nation. While intellectuals and policymakers embarked on a process of soul‐searching, the French public responded to the defeat with an unprecedented wave of commemorative acts predicated on the belief that the French national defence was more honourable and more glorious than the German victory. In recent years, much attention has been devoted to the Third Republic's celebration of the French revolutionary past, and the role these celebrations played in developing and sustaining republican values. In this article, however, I examine the Republic's comparative neglect of its more recent past. The first section outlines the practical considerations and obligations behind the state's work to bury those who died in the Franco‐Prussian War. The second section explores the government's intervention in and influence over certain commemorative acts. In the third section, the article examines sustained government resistance to the creation of a commemorative medal for veterans of the war. I argue that successive governments adopted a relatively passive role in the war commemorations owing to fears that resurrecting memories of the war might serve to undermine the stability and legitimacy of the Republic.

AB - The French defeat in the Franco‐Prussian War represented a crushing blow for the Second Empire, the fledgling Republic and the French nation. While intellectuals and policymakers embarked on a process of soul‐searching, the French public responded to the defeat with an unprecedented wave of commemorative acts predicated on the belief that the French national defence was more honourable and more glorious than the German victory. In recent years, much attention has been devoted to the Third Republic's celebration of the French revolutionary past, and the role these celebrations played in developing and sustaining republican values. In this article, however, I examine the Republic's comparative neglect of its more recent past. The first section outlines the practical considerations and obligations behind the state's work to bury those who died in the Franco‐Prussian War. The second section explores the government's intervention in and influence over certain commemorative acts. In the third section, the article examines sustained government resistance to the creation of a commemorative medal for veterans of the war. I argue that successive governments adopted a relatively passive role in the war commemorations owing to fears that resurrecting memories of the war might serve to undermine the stability and legitimacy of the Republic.

KW - Franco-Prussian war

KW - france

KW - defeat

KW - commemoration

U2 - 10.1093/fh/16.3.323

DO - 10.1093/fh/16.3.323

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 323

EP - 344

JO - French History

JF - French History

SN - 0269-1191

IS - 3

ER -