Troubling stories of the end of occupy: feminist narratives of betrayal at occupy Glasgow

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

This article offers a feminist take on the question of why Occupy camps closed down, in the form of a narrative analysis of interviews from participants in Occupy Glasgow. In response to the emergence of an activist discourse emphasising the role of external forces in camp closure and the existence of a longer-term legacy in terms of individual and community politicisation, I build here on feminist interventions that point instead to serious internal problems within the camps and thus to a more limited legacy. Interrogating the plotting, characterisation and denouement of interviewee narratives, I show that feminist participants in Occupy Glasgow characterise the trajectory of the camp as a tragedy, attribute responsibility for the camp’s demise to co-campers and sometimes to themselves, and present the outcome of Occupy Glasgow as limited, and in some cases even traumatic. This raises serious questions about the culmination and outcomes of Occupy in Glasgow and more generally, and indicates the extent of the hard work remaining if future mobilisation against neoliberal austerity is to be more inclusive and sustainable. The article closes by considering the theoretical implications for the wider question of why movements come to an end.
LanguageEnglish
Pages534-540
Number of pages7
JournalSocial Movement Studies
Volume17
Issue number5
Early online date9 Jul 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 17 Aug 2018

Fingerprint

narrative
politicization
mobilization
responsibility
discourse
interview
community

Keywords

  • occupy movement
  • Glasgow
  • mobilization
  • feminist critique
  • activist narratives

Cite this

@article{a411e1f68c584cc4bc42a444d86433b2,
title = "Troubling stories of the end of occupy: feminist narratives of betrayal at occupy Glasgow",
abstract = "This article offers a feminist take on the question of why Occupy camps closed down, in the form of a narrative analysis of interviews from participants in Occupy Glasgow. In response to the emergence of an activist discourse emphasising the role of external forces in camp closure and the existence of a longer-term legacy in terms of individual and community politicisation, I build here on feminist interventions that point instead to serious internal problems within the camps and thus to a more limited legacy. Interrogating the plotting, characterisation and denouement of interviewee narratives, I show that feminist participants in Occupy Glasgow characterise the trajectory of the camp as a tragedy, attribute responsibility for the camp’s demise to co-campers and sometimes to themselves, and present the outcome of Occupy Glasgow as limited, and in some cases even traumatic. This raises serious questions about the culmination and outcomes of Occupy in Glasgow and more generally, and indicates the extent of the hard work remaining if future mobilisation against neoliberal austerity is to be more inclusive and sustainable. The article closes by considering the theoretical implications for the wider question of why movements come to an end.",
keywords = "occupy movement, Glasgow, mobilization, feminist critique, activist narratives",
author = "Catherine Eschle",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "17",
doi = "10.1080/14742837.2018.1495072",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "534--540",
journal = "Social Movement Studies",
issn = "1474-2837",
number = "5",

}

Troubling stories of the end of occupy : feminist narratives of betrayal at occupy Glasgow. / Eschle, Catherine.

In: Social Movement Studies, Vol. 17, No. 5, 17.08.2018, p. 534-540.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Troubling stories of the end of occupy

T2 - Social Movement Studies

AU - Eschle, Catherine

PY - 2018/8/17

Y1 - 2018/8/17

N2 - This article offers a feminist take on the question of why Occupy camps closed down, in the form of a narrative analysis of interviews from participants in Occupy Glasgow. In response to the emergence of an activist discourse emphasising the role of external forces in camp closure and the existence of a longer-term legacy in terms of individual and community politicisation, I build here on feminist interventions that point instead to serious internal problems within the camps and thus to a more limited legacy. Interrogating the plotting, characterisation and denouement of interviewee narratives, I show that feminist participants in Occupy Glasgow characterise the trajectory of the camp as a tragedy, attribute responsibility for the camp’s demise to co-campers and sometimes to themselves, and present the outcome of Occupy Glasgow as limited, and in some cases even traumatic. This raises serious questions about the culmination and outcomes of Occupy in Glasgow and more generally, and indicates the extent of the hard work remaining if future mobilisation against neoliberal austerity is to be more inclusive and sustainable. The article closes by considering the theoretical implications for the wider question of why movements come to an end.

AB - This article offers a feminist take on the question of why Occupy camps closed down, in the form of a narrative analysis of interviews from participants in Occupy Glasgow. In response to the emergence of an activist discourse emphasising the role of external forces in camp closure and the existence of a longer-term legacy in terms of individual and community politicisation, I build here on feminist interventions that point instead to serious internal problems within the camps and thus to a more limited legacy. Interrogating the plotting, characterisation and denouement of interviewee narratives, I show that feminist participants in Occupy Glasgow characterise the trajectory of the camp as a tragedy, attribute responsibility for the camp’s demise to co-campers and sometimes to themselves, and present the outcome of Occupy Glasgow as limited, and in some cases even traumatic. This raises serious questions about the culmination and outcomes of Occupy in Glasgow and more generally, and indicates the extent of the hard work remaining if future mobilisation against neoliberal austerity is to be more inclusive and sustainable. The article closes by considering the theoretical implications for the wider question of why movements come to an end.

KW - occupy movement

KW - Glasgow

KW - mobilization

KW - feminist critique

KW - activist narratives

UR - https://tandfonline.com/loi/csms20

UR - https://think.taylorandfrancis.com/britta-baumgarten-memorial-prize/

U2 - 10.1080/14742837.2018.1495072

DO - 10.1080/14742837.2018.1495072

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 534

EP - 540

JO - Social Movement Studies

JF - Social Movement Studies

SN - 1474-2837

IS - 5

ER -