Towards a shared ontology: a generic classification of cognitive processes in conceptual design

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Towards addressing ontological issues in design cognition research, this paper presents the first generic classification of cognitive processes investigated in protocol studies on conceptual design cognition. The classification is based on a systematic review of 47 studies published over the past 30 years. Three viewpoints on the nature of design cognition are outlined (search, exploration, and design activities), highlighting considerable differences in the concepts and terminology applied to describe cognition. To provide a more unified view of the cognitive processes fundamentally under study, we map specific descriptions of cognitive processes provided in protocol studies to more generic, established definitions in the cognitive psychology literature. This reveals a set of 6 categories of cognitive process that appear to be commonly studied and are therefore likely to be prevalent in conceptual design: (1) long term memory; (2) semantic processing; (3) visual perception; (4) mental imagery processing; (5) creative output production; and (6) executive functions. The categories and their constituent processes are formalised in the generic classification. The classification provides the basis for a generic, shared ontology of cognitive processes in design that is conceptually and terminologically consistent with the ontology of cognitive psychology and neuroscience. Additionally, the work highlights 6 key avenues for future empirical research: (1) the role of episodic and semantic memory; (2) consistent definitions of semantic processes; (3) the role of sketching from alternative theoretical perspectives on perception and mental imagery; (4) the role of working memory; (5) the meaning and nature of synthesis; and (6) unidentified cognitive processes implicated in conceptual design elsewhere in the literature.
LanguageEnglish
Article numbere7
Number of pages42
JournalDesign Science
Volume3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 22 May 2017

Fingerprint

Conceptual design
Cognition
Ontology
Semantics
Imagery (Psychotherapy)
Data storage equipment
Psychology
Network protocols
Visual Perception
Empirical Research
Episodic Memory
Long-Term Memory
Executive Function
Terminology
Processing
Short-Term Memory
Research Design

Keywords

  • conceptual design
  • design cognition
  • cognitive processes
  • psychology
  • protocol analysis

Cite this

@article{3d19b4258f634003a05aac91d9fc7107,
title = "Towards a shared ontology: a generic classification of cognitive processes in conceptual design",
abstract = "Towards addressing ontological issues in design cognition research, this paper presents the first generic classification of cognitive processes investigated in protocol studies on conceptual design cognition. The classification is based on a systematic review of 47 studies published over the past 30 years. Three viewpoints on the nature of design cognition are outlined (search, exploration, and design activities), highlighting considerable differences in the concepts and terminology applied to describe cognition. To provide a more unified view of the cognitive processes fundamentally under study, we map specific descriptions of cognitive processes provided in protocol studies to more generic, established definitions in the cognitive psychology literature. This reveals a set of 6 categories of cognitive process that appear to be commonly studied and are therefore likely to be prevalent in conceptual design: (1) long term memory; (2) semantic processing; (3) visual perception; (4) mental imagery processing; (5) creative output production; and (6) executive functions. The categories and their constituent processes are formalised in the generic classification. The classification provides the basis for a generic, shared ontology of cognitive processes in design that is conceptually and terminologically consistent with the ontology of cognitive psychology and neuroscience. Additionally, the work highlights 6 key avenues for future empirical research: (1) the role of episodic and semantic memory; (2) consistent definitions of semantic processes; (3) the role of sketching from alternative theoretical perspectives on perception and mental imagery; (4) the role of working memory; (5) the meaning and nature of synthesis; and (6) unidentified cognitive processes implicated in conceptual design elsewhere in the literature.",
keywords = "conceptual design, design cognition, cognitive processes, psychology, protocol analysis",
author = "Laura Hay and Duffy, {Alex H. B.} and Christopher McTeague and Pidgeon, {Laura M.} and Tijana Vuletic and Madeleine Grealy",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "22",
doi = "10.1017/dsj.2017.6",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
journal = "Design Science",
issn = "2053-4701",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Towards a shared ontology

T2 - Design Science

AU - Hay, Laura

AU - Duffy, Alex H. B.

AU - McTeague, Christopher

AU - Pidgeon, Laura M.

AU - Vuletic, Tijana

AU - Grealy, Madeleine

PY - 2017/5/22

Y1 - 2017/5/22

N2 - Towards addressing ontological issues in design cognition research, this paper presents the first generic classification of cognitive processes investigated in protocol studies on conceptual design cognition. The classification is based on a systematic review of 47 studies published over the past 30 years. Three viewpoints on the nature of design cognition are outlined (search, exploration, and design activities), highlighting considerable differences in the concepts and terminology applied to describe cognition. To provide a more unified view of the cognitive processes fundamentally under study, we map specific descriptions of cognitive processes provided in protocol studies to more generic, established definitions in the cognitive psychology literature. This reveals a set of 6 categories of cognitive process that appear to be commonly studied and are therefore likely to be prevalent in conceptual design: (1) long term memory; (2) semantic processing; (3) visual perception; (4) mental imagery processing; (5) creative output production; and (6) executive functions. The categories and their constituent processes are formalised in the generic classification. The classification provides the basis for a generic, shared ontology of cognitive processes in design that is conceptually and terminologically consistent with the ontology of cognitive psychology and neuroscience. Additionally, the work highlights 6 key avenues for future empirical research: (1) the role of episodic and semantic memory; (2) consistent definitions of semantic processes; (3) the role of sketching from alternative theoretical perspectives on perception and mental imagery; (4) the role of working memory; (5) the meaning and nature of synthesis; and (6) unidentified cognitive processes implicated in conceptual design elsewhere in the literature.

AB - Towards addressing ontological issues in design cognition research, this paper presents the first generic classification of cognitive processes investigated in protocol studies on conceptual design cognition. The classification is based on a systematic review of 47 studies published over the past 30 years. Three viewpoints on the nature of design cognition are outlined (search, exploration, and design activities), highlighting considerable differences in the concepts and terminology applied to describe cognition. To provide a more unified view of the cognitive processes fundamentally under study, we map specific descriptions of cognitive processes provided in protocol studies to more generic, established definitions in the cognitive psychology literature. This reveals a set of 6 categories of cognitive process that appear to be commonly studied and are therefore likely to be prevalent in conceptual design: (1) long term memory; (2) semantic processing; (3) visual perception; (4) mental imagery processing; (5) creative output production; and (6) executive functions. The categories and their constituent processes are formalised in the generic classification. The classification provides the basis for a generic, shared ontology of cognitive processes in design that is conceptually and terminologically consistent with the ontology of cognitive psychology and neuroscience. Additionally, the work highlights 6 key avenues for future empirical research: (1) the role of episodic and semantic memory; (2) consistent definitions of semantic processes; (3) the role of sketching from alternative theoretical perspectives on perception and mental imagery; (4) the role of working memory; (5) the meaning and nature of synthesis; and (6) unidentified cognitive processes implicated in conceptual design elsewhere in the literature.

KW - conceptual design

KW - design cognition

KW - cognitive processes

KW - psychology

KW - protocol analysis

UR - https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/design-science

U2 - 10.1017/dsj.2017.6

DO - 10.1017/dsj.2017.6

M3 - Article

VL - 3

JO - Design Science

JF - Design Science

SN - 2053-4701

M1 - e7

ER -