The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques

Ainsley J. Dominick, N. NicDaeid, Stephen M. Bleay, Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)
96 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This research investigates the recoverability of fingerprints which have been exposed to elevated temperatures in order to mimic the environment a piece of paper may be exposed to within an arson scene. Arson is an expensive crime, costing the UK economy, on average, £53.8 million each week [1]. Anything which may give rise to the identity of the fire setter should be analysed and as such, unburnt paper may be a potential source of fingerprints. While it is true that even a moderate fire will obscure and render partially useless some types of evidence, many items, including fingerprints, may still survive [2-4]. This research has shown that fingerprints are still retrievable from paper which has been subjected to the maximum testing conditions of 200˚C for 320min. In fact, some fingerprints naturally enhance themselves by the heating process. This investigation has also shown that the most effective enhancement technique was found to be 1,8-diazafluoren-9-one (DFO) for exposure temperatures upto 100˚C. Physical developer (PD) is the most effective enhancement technique for exposure temperatures from 100˚C to 200˚C. For porous surfaces, there are fingerprint development techniques which are effective at enhancing fingerprints exposed upto a temperature of 200˚C, irrespective of the firefighting extinguishing technique, as PD, in addition to developing fingerprints exposed to high temperatures, is one of the few processes which will enhance fingermarks on wetted surfaces.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)325-339
Number of pages14
JournalJournal of Forensic Identification
Volume59
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

Dermatoglyphics
Temperature
Firesetting Behavior
Crime
Research
Heating

Keywords

  • arson investigations
  • crime scene search
  • fingerprint image quality
  • scientific techniques

Cite this

Dominick, A. J., NicDaeid, N., Bleay, S. M., & Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK (2010). The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques. Journal of Forensic Identification, 59(3), 325-339.
Dominick, Ainsley J. ; NicDaeid, N. ; Bleay, Stephen M. ; Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK. / The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques. In: Journal of Forensic Identification. 2010 ; Vol. 59, No. 3. pp. 325-339.
@article{0b6e4c9402d947ac8ab00aa6ca0b755b,
title = "The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques",
abstract = "This research investigates the recoverability of fingerprints which have been exposed to elevated temperatures in order to mimic the environment a piece of paper may be exposed to within an arson scene. Arson is an expensive crime, costing the UK economy, on average, £53.8 million each week [1]. Anything which may give rise to the identity of the fire setter should be analysed and as such, unburnt paper may be a potential source of fingerprints. While it is true that even a moderate fire will obscure and render partially useless some types of evidence, many items, including fingerprints, may still survive [2-4]. This research has shown that fingerprints are still retrievable from paper which has been subjected to the maximum testing conditions of 200˚C for 320min. In fact, some fingerprints naturally enhance themselves by the heating process. This investigation has also shown that the most effective enhancement technique was found to be 1,8-diazafluoren-9-one (DFO) for exposure temperatures upto 100˚C. Physical developer (PD) is the most effective enhancement technique for exposure temperatures from 100˚C to 200˚C. For porous surfaces, there are fingerprint development techniques which are effective at enhancing fingerprints exposed upto a temperature of 200˚C, irrespective of the firefighting extinguishing technique, as PD, in addition to developing fingerprints exposed to high temperatures, is one of the few processes which will enhance fingermarks on wetted surfaces.",
keywords = "arson investigations, crime scene search, fingerprint image quality, scientific techniques",
author = "Dominick, {Ainsley J.} and N. NicDaeid and Bleay, {Stephen M.} and {Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK}",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
volume = "59",
pages = "325--339",
journal = "Journal of Forensic Identification",
issn = "0895-173X",
publisher = "International Association for Identification",
number = "3",

}

Dominick, AJ, NicDaeid, N, Bleay, SM & Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK 2010, 'The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques', Journal of Forensic Identification, vol. 59, no. 3, pp. 325-339.

The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques. / Dominick, Ainsley J.; NicDaeid, N.; Bleay, Stephen M.; Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK.

In: Journal of Forensic Identification, Vol. 59, No. 3, 2010, p. 325-339.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques

AU - Dominick, Ainsley J.

AU - NicDaeid, N.

AU - Bleay, Stephen M.

AU - Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - This research investigates the recoverability of fingerprints which have been exposed to elevated temperatures in order to mimic the environment a piece of paper may be exposed to within an arson scene. Arson is an expensive crime, costing the UK economy, on average, £53.8 million each week [1]. Anything which may give rise to the identity of the fire setter should be analysed and as such, unburnt paper may be a potential source of fingerprints. While it is true that even a moderate fire will obscure and render partially useless some types of evidence, many items, including fingerprints, may still survive [2-4]. This research has shown that fingerprints are still retrievable from paper which has been subjected to the maximum testing conditions of 200˚C for 320min. In fact, some fingerprints naturally enhance themselves by the heating process. This investigation has also shown that the most effective enhancement technique was found to be 1,8-diazafluoren-9-one (DFO) for exposure temperatures upto 100˚C. Physical developer (PD) is the most effective enhancement technique for exposure temperatures from 100˚C to 200˚C. For porous surfaces, there are fingerprint development techniques which are effective at enhancing fingerprints exposed upto a temperature of 200˚C, irrespective of the firefighting extinguishing technique, as PD, in addition to developing fingerprints exposed to high temperatures, is one of the few processes which will enhance fingermarks on wetted surfaces.

AB - This research investigates the recoverability of fingerprints which have been exposed to elevated temperatures in order to mimic the environment a piece of paper may be exposed to within an arson scene. Arson is an expensive crime, costing the UK economy, on average, £53.8 million each week [1]. Anything which may give rise to the identity of the fire setter should be analysed and as such, unburnt paper may be a potential source of fingerprints. While it is true that even a moderate fire will obscure and render partially useless some types of evidence, many items, including fingerprints, may still survive [2-4]. This research has shown that fingerprints are still retrievable from paper which has been subjected to the maximum testing conditions of 200˚C for 320min. In fact, some fingerprints naturally enhance themselves by the heating process. This investigation has also shown that the most effective enhancement technique was found to be 1,8-diazafluoren-9-one (DFO) for exposure temperatures upto 100˚C. Physical developer (PD) is the most effective enhancement technique for exposure temperatures from 100˚C to 200˚C. For porous surfaces, there are fingerprint development techniques which are effective at enhancing fingerprints exposed upto a temperature of 200˚C, irrespective of the firefighting extinguishing technique, as PD, in addition to developing fingerprints exposed to high temperatures, is one of the few processes which will enhance fingermarks on wetted surfaces.

KW - arson investigations

KW - crime scene search

KW - fingerprint image quality

KW - scientific techniques

UR - http://www.theiai.org

UR - http://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=249075

M3 - Article

VL - 59

SP - 325

EP - 339

JO - Journal of Forensic Identification

JF - Journal of Forensic Identification

SN - 0895-173X

IS - 3

ER -

Dominick AJ, NicDaeid N, Bleay SM, Home Office Scientific Development Branch, Sandridge, UK. The recoverability of fingerprints on paper exposed to elevated temperatures - Part 1: comparison of enhancement techniques. Journal of Forensic Identification. 2010;59(3):325-339.