The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe

Jakob Edler, Martin Berger, Michael Dinges, Abdullah Gök

Research output: Working paper

Abstract

This paper characterises and analyses evaluation practice in national innovation policy across Europe. It is the first study that examines and interprets the characteristics, quality, usefulness, and consequences of evaluations in a systematic way. The analysis is based on the comprehensive INNO-Appraisal repository of 171 evaluation reports of national innovation policies of EU25 countries, conducted between 2002 and 2007. The paper seeks (1) to assess the state of the art of evaluation in innovation policy at national level, (2) to understand how different key dimensions of evaluation (timing, purpose, methods, tendering process, etc.) relate to each other, and (3) to explore types of evaluations. On that basis, we (4) draw lessons as to what constitutes good practice in evaluation, as the results of the survey have been exchanged and discussed with a number of policy makers of the sample responsible for the evaluation. The paper thus both contributes to the academic understanding of policy evaluation and supports use in policy practice.
LanguageEnglish
Place of PublicationManchester
Volume626
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Publication series

NameMIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series

Fingerprint

innovation policy
evaluation
best practice

Keywords

  • evaluation
  • survey
  • Europe
  • innovation policy

Cite this

Edler, J., Berger, M., Dinges, M., & Gök, A. (2011). The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe. (MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series). Manchester. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1980647
Edler, Jakob ; Berger, Martin ; Dinges, Michael ; Gök, Abdullah. / The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe. Manchester, 2011. (MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series).
@techreport{648359086d69433198d8aa2d9da8252c,
title = "The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe",
abstract = "This paper characterises and analyses evaluation practice in national innovation policy across Europe. It is the first study that examines and interprets the characteristics, quality, usefulness, and consequences of evaluations in a systematic way. The analysis is based on the comprehensive INNO-Appraisal repository of 171 evaluation reports of national innovation policies of EU25 countries, conducted between 2002 and 2007. The paper seeks (1) to assess the state of the art of evaluation in innovation policy at national level, (2) to understand how different key dimensions of evaluation (timing, purpose, methods, tendering process, etc.) relate to each other, and (3) to explore types of evaluations. On that basis, we (4) draw lessons as to what constitutes good practice in evaluation, as the results of the survey have been exchanged and discussed with a number of policy makers of the sample responsible for the evaluation. The paper thus both contributes to the academic understanding of policy evaluation and supports use in policy practice.",
keywords = "evaluation, survey, Europe, innovation policy",
author = "Jakob Edler and Martin Berger and Michael Dinges and Abdullah G{\"o}k",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.2139/ssrn.1980647",
language = "English",
volume = "626",
series = "MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series",
type = "WorkingPaper",

}

Edler, J, Berger, M, Dinges, M & Gök, A 2011 'The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe' MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series, Manchester. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1980647

The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe. / Edler, Jakob; Berger, Martin; Dinges, Michael; Gök, Abdullah.

Manchester, 2011. (MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series).

Research output: Working paper

TY - UNPB

T1 - The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe

AU - Edler, Jakob

AU - Berger, Martin

AU - Dinges, Michael

AU - Gök, Abdullah

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - This paper characterises and analyses evaluation practice in national innovation policy across Europe. It is the first study that examines and interprets the characteristics, quality, usefulness, and consequences of evaluations in a systematic way. The analysis is based on the comprehensive INNO-Appraisal repository of 171 evaluation reports of national innovation policies of EU25 countries, conducted between 2002 and 2007. The paper seeks (1) to assess the state of the art of evaluation in innovation policy at national level, (2) to understand how different key dimensions of evaluation (timing, purpose, methods, tendering process, etc.) relate to each other, and (3) to explore types of evaluations. On that basis, we (4) draw lessons as to what constitutes good practice in evaluation, as the results of the survey have been exchanged and discussed with a number of policy makers of the sample responsible for the evaluation. The paper thus both contributes to the academic understanding of policy evaluation and supports use in policy practice.

AB - This paper characterises and analyses evaluation practice in national innovation policy across Europe. It is the first study that examines and interprets the characteristics, quality, usefulness, and consequences of evaluations in a systematic way. The analysis is based on the comprehensive INNO-Appraisal repository of 171 evaluation reports of national innovation policies of EU25 countries, conducted between 2002 and 2007. The paper seeks (1) to assess the state of the art of evaluation in innovation policy at national level, (2) to understand how different key dimensions of evaluation (timing, purpose, methods, tendering process, etc.) relate to each other, and (3) to explore types of evaluations. On that basis, we (4) draw lessons as to what constitutes good practice in evaluation, as the results of the survey have been exchanged and discussed with a number of policy makers of the sample responsible for the evaluation. The paper thus both contributes to the academic understanding of policy evaluation and supports use in policy practice.

KW - evaluation

KW - survey

KW - Europe

KW - innovation policy

U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.1980647

DO - 10.2139/ssrn.1980647

M3 - Working paper

VL - 626

T3 - MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series

BT - The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe

CY - Manchester

ER -

Edler J, Berger M, Dinges M, Gök A. The practice of evaluation in innovation policy in Europe. Manchester. 2011. (MIoIR / MBS Working Paper Series). https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1980647