The perforated borders of labour migration and the formal state: meta-state and para-state regulation

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to explore the variation in migrant labour market regimes and what these reveal about variant patterns of state and extra state regulation in two contemporary political economies.
Design/methodology/approach
Research based upon a participatory action research agenda in Mexico and the north of Ireland. Migrant workers and their families where involved in the project and its development. This included participation in the research design, its focus and purpose.
Findings
Migrant workers experiences of labour market subordination are part of wider processes of subordination and exclusion involving both the state, but also wider, often meta- and para-state, agents. In different locations, states and contexts, the precarity experienced by migrant workers and their families highlights the porosity of the formal rational legal state and moreover, in the current economic context, the compatibility of illegality and state sponsored neoliberal economic policies.
Research limitations/implications
It is important to extend this study to other geographic and political economy spaces.
Practical implications
The study challenges the limits of state agency suggesting the need for extra state, i.e. civil society, participation to support and defend migrant workers.
Originality/value
Notwithstanding the two very different socio-economic contexts, the paper reveals that the interaction, dependence and restructuring of migrant labour markets can be understood within the context of meta- and para-state activities that link neoliberal employment insecurities. Migrants' experiences illustrate the extent to which even formal legal employment relations can also be sustained by para- and meta- (illegal and alegal) actions and institutions.
LanguageEnglish
Pages391-407
Number of pages17
JournalEmployee Relations
Volume39
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 May 2017

Fingerprint

State regulation
Labour migration
Labour market
Migrant workers
Subordination
Migrant labor
Participation
Political economy
Ireland
Employment relations
Socio-economics
Participatory action research
Economics
Workers
Design methodology
Interaction
Civil society
Compatibility
Research design
Mexico

Keywords

  • migrant workers
  • illegal labour market control and criminality
  • meta- and para-state agents of migrant employment and social control
  • Mexico and North of Ireland
  • state and employment regulation

Cite this

@article{c8f56e96fa6c4d33ba1d65884fe7db36,
title = "The perforated borders of labour migration and the formal state: meta-state and para-state regulation",
abstract = "PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to explore the variation in migrant labour market regimes and what these reveal about variant patterns of state and extra state regulation in two contemporary political economies.Design/methodology/approachResearch based upon a participatory action research agenda in Mexico and the north of Ireland. Migrant workers and their families where involved in the project and its development. This included participation in the research design, its focus and purpose.FindingsMigrant workers experiences of labour market subordination are part of wider processes of subordination and exclusion involving both the state, but also wider, often meta- and para-state, agents. In different locations, states and contexts, the precarity experienced by migrant workers and their families highlights the porosity of the formal rational legal state and moreover, in the current economic context, the compatibility of illegality and state sponsored neoliberal economic policies.Research limitations/implicationsIt is important to extend this study to other geographic and political economy spaces.Practical implicationsThe study challenges the limits of state agency suggesting the need for extra state, i.e. civil society, participation to support and defend migrant workers.Originality/valueNotwithstanding the two very different socio-economic contexts, the paper reveals that the interaction, dependence and restructuring of migrant labour markets can be understood within the context of meta- and para-state activities that link neoliberal employment insecurities. Migrants' experiences illustrate the extent to which even formal legal employment relations can also be sustained by para- and meta- (illegal and alegal) actions and institutions.",
keywords = "migrant workers, illegal labour market control and criminality, meta- and para-state agents of migrant employment and social control, Mexico and North of Ireland, state and employment regulation",
author = "Virginio, {Francis Vinicius Portes} and Brian Garvey and Paul Stewart",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1108/ER-03-2016-0061",
language = "English",
volume = "39",
pages = "391--407",
journal = "Employee Relations",
issn = "0142-5455",
publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
number = "3",

}

The perforated borders of labour migration and the formal state : meta-state and para-state regulation. / Virginio, Francis Vinicius Portes; Garvey, Brian; Stewart, Paul.

In: Employee Relations, Vol. 39, No. 3, 03.05.2017, p. 391-407.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The perforated borders of labour migration and the formal state

T2 - Employee Relations

AU - Virginio, Francis Vinicius Portes

AU - Garvey, Brian

AU - Stewart, Paul

PY - 2017/5/3

Y1 - 2017/5/3

N2 - PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to explore the variation in migrant labour market regimes and what these reveal about variant patterns of state and extra state regulation in two contemporary political economies.Design/methodology/approachResearch based upon a participatory action research agenda in Mexico and the north of Ireland. Migrant workers and their families where involved in the project and its development. This included participation in the research design, its focus and purpose.FindingsMigrant workers experiences of labour market subordination are part of wider processes of subordination and exclusion involving both the state, but also wider, often meta- and para-state, agents. In different locations, states and contexts, the precarity experienced by migrant workers and their families highlights the porosity of the formal rational legal state and moreover, in the current economic context, the compatibility of illegality and state sponsored neoliberal economic policies.Research limitations/implicationsIt is important to extend this study to other geographic and political economy spaces.Practical implicationsThe study challenges the limits of state agency suggesting the need for extra state, i.e. civil society, participation to support and defend migrant workers.Originality/valueNotwithstanding the two very different socio-economic contexts, the paper reveals that the interaction, dependence and restructuring of migrant labour markets can be understood within the context of meta- and para-state activities that link neoliberal employment insecurities. Migrants' experiences illustrate the extent to which even formal legal employment relations can also be sustained by para- and meta- (illegal and alegal) actions and institutions.

AB - PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to explore the variation in migrant labour market regimes and what these reveal about variant patterns of state and extra state regulation in two contemporary political economies.Design/methodology/approachResearch based upon a participatory action research agenda in Mexico and the north of Ireland. Migrant workers and their families where involved in the project and its development. This included participation in the research design, its focus and purpose.FindingsMigrant workers experiences of labour market subordination are part of wider processes of subordination and exclusion involving both the state, but also wider, often meta- and para-state, agents. In different locations, states and contexts, the precarity experienced by migrant workers and their families highlights the porosity of the formal rational legal state and moreover, in the current economic context, the compatibility of illegality and state sponsored neoliberal economic policies.Research limitations/implicationsIt is important to extend this study to other geographic and political economy spaces.Practical implicationsThe study challenges the limits of state agency suggesting the need for extra state, i.e. civil society, participation to support and defend migrant workers.Originality/valueNotwithstanding the two very different socio-economic contexts, the paper reveals that the interaction, dependence and restructuring of migrant labour markets can be understood within the context of meta- and para-state activities that link neoliberal employment insecurities. Migrants' experiences illustrate the extent to which even formal legal employment relations can also be sustained by para- and meta- (illegal and alegal) actions and institutions.

KW - migrant workers

KW - illegal labour market control and criminality

KW - meta- and para-state agents of migrant employment and social control

KW - Mexico and North of Ireland

KW - state and employment regulation

UR - http://www.emeraldinsight.com/loi/er

U2 - 10.1108/ER-03-2016-0061

DO - 10.1108/ER-03-2016-0061

M3 - Article

VL - 39

SP - 391

EP - 407

JO - Employee Relations

JF - Employee Relations

SN - 0142-5455

IS - 3

ER -