The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime

Francesco Costamagna, Francesco Sindico

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

This paper aims to examine the relationship between two branches of international economic law and water-related issues. In particular, it analyses the impact of international investment law and international trade law on, respectively, State’s capacity in ensuring universal access to water services and fighting against water scarcity. The main objective of the paper is to define State’s rights in relation to water supply and how these rights can be protected and enforced within the international investment and/or WTO regime. First, the analysis focuses on certain features of the investment system that may affect the balance between State’s right to regulate for strengthening access to water and foreign investments’ protection. The dispute settlement mechanism, which allows private investors to challenge regulatory measures directly before an international arbitral tribunal, and the uncertain definition of basic substantive provisions are the elements considered in this regard. The second part of the paper examines whether and how the WTO regime may deal with water transfers. In particular, the goal is to assess the relationship between water exporting and water importing countries, which are not always balanced should a strict interpretation of WTO norms and exceptions be adopted. The paper concludes that the application of international economic rules to water-related issues requires the development of a flexible approach to strike a fair balance between the economic interests and the fundamental social needs at stake in this field.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationWater governance in motion
Subtitle of host publicationtowards socially and environmentally sustainable water laws
EditorsPhilippe Cullet, Alix Gowlland-Gualtieri, Roopa Madhav, Usha Ramanathan
Place of PublicationNew Delhi
Pages269-298
Number of pages29
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

WTO
regime
water
Law
international economics
international law
trade law
economic law
world trade
foreign investment
water management
investor
interpretation
economics

Keywords

  • water
  • trade
  • investment
  • linkages
  • access to water
  • water scarcity
  • international investment law
  • WTO regime

Cite this

Costamagna, F., & Sindico, F. (2010). The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime. In P. Cullet, A. Gowlland-Gualtieri, R. Madhav, & U. Ramanathan (Eds.), Water governance in motion: towards socially and environmentally sustainable water laws (pp. 269-298). New Delhi.
Costamagna, Francesco ; Sindico, Francesco. / The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime. Water governance in motion: towards socially and environmentally sustainable water laws. editor / Philippe Cullet ; Alix Gowlland-Gualtieri ; Roopa Madhav ; Usha Ramanathan. New Delhi, 2010. pp. 269-298
@inbook{934a0dc720824a76bd7ccdbc8128ad26,
title = "The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime",
abstract = "This paper aims to examine the relationship between two branches of international economic law and water-related issues. In particular, it analyses the impact of international investment law and international trade law on, respectively, State’s capacity in ensuring universal access to water services and fighting against water scarcity. The main objective of the paper is to define State’s rights in relation to water supply and how these rights can be protected and enforced within the international investment and/or WTO regime. First, the analysis focuses on certain features of the investment system that may affect the balance between State’s right to regulate for strengthening access to water and foreign investments’ protection. The dispute settlement mechanism, which allows private investors to challenge regulatory measures directly before an international arbitral tribunal, and the uncertain definition of basic substantive provisions are the elements considered in this regard. The second part of the paper examines whether and how the WTO regime may deal with water transfers. In particular, the goal is to assess the relationship between water exporting and water importing countries, which are not always balanced should a strict interpretation of WTO norms and exceptions be adopted. The paper concludes that the application of international economic rules to water-related issues requires the development of a flexible approach to strike a fair balance between the economic interests and the fundamental social needs at stake in this field.",
keywords = "water, trade, investment, linkages, access to water, water scarcity, international investment law , WTO regime",
author = "Francesco Costamagna and Francesco Sindico",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
isbn = "9788175966345",
pages = "269--298",
editor = "Philippe Cullet and Alix Gowlland-Gualtieri and Roopa Madhav and Usha Ramanathan",
booktitle = "Water governance in motion",

}

Costamagna, F & Sindico, F 2010, The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime. in P Cullet, A Gowlland-Gualtieri, R Madhav & U Ramanathan (eds), Water governance in motion: towards socially and environmentally sustainable water laws. New Delhi, pp. 269-298.

The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime. / Costamagna, Francesco ; Sindico, Francesco.

Water governance in motion: towards socially and environmentally sustainable water laws. ed. / Philippe Cullet; Alix Gowlland-Gualtieri; Roopa Madhav; Usha Ramanathan. New Delhi, 2010. p. 269-298.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime

AU - Costamagna, Francesco

AU - Sindico, Francesco

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - This paper aims to examine the relationship between two branches of international economic law and water-related issues. In particular, it analyses the impact of international investment law and international trade law on, respectively, State’s capacity in ensuring universal access to water services and fighting against water scarcity. The main objective of the paper is to define State’s rights in relation to water supply and how these rights can be protected and enforced within the international investment and/or WTO regime. First, the analysis focuses on certain features of the investment system that may affect the balance between State’s right to regulate for strengthening access to water and foreign investments’ protection. The dispute settlement mechanism, which allows private investors to challenge regulatory measures directly before an international arbitral tribunal, and the uncertain definition of basic substantive provisions are the elements considered in this regard. The second part of the paper examines whether and how the WTO regime may deal with water transfers. In particular, the goal is to assess the relationship between water exporting and water importing countries, which are not always balanced should a strict interpretation of WTO norms and exceptions be adopted. The paper concludes that the application of international economic rules to water-related issues requires the development of a flexible approach to strike a fair balance between the economic interests and the fundamental social needs at stake in this field.

AB - This paper aims to examine the relationship between two branches of international economic law and water-related issues. In particular, it analyses the impact of international investment law and international trade law on, respectively, State’s capacity in ensuring universal access to water services and fighting against water scarcity. The main objective of the paper is to define State’s rights in relation to water supply and how these rights can be protected and enforced within the international investment and/or WTO regime. First, the analysis focuses on certain features of the investment system that may affect the balance between State’s right to regulate for strengthening access to water and foreign investments’ protection. The dispute settlement mechanism, which allows private investors to challenge regulatory measures directly before an international arbitral tribunal, and the uncertain definition of basic substantive provisions are the elements considered in this regard. The second part of the paper examines whether and how the WTO regime may deal with water transfers. In particular, the goal is to assess the relationship between water exporting and water importing countries, which are not always balanced should a strict interpretation of WTO norms and exceptions be adopted. The paper concludes that the application of international economic rules to water-related issues requires the development of a flexible approach to strike a fair balance between the economic interests and the fundamental social needs at stake in this field.

KW - water

KW - trade

KW - investment

KW - linkages

KW - access to water

KW - water scarcity

KW - international investment law

KW - WTO regime

UR - http://www.cambridgeindia.org/newarrivals.asp?isbn=9788175966345

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

SN - 9788175966345

SP - 269

EP - 298

BT - Water governance in motion

A2 - Cullet, Philippe

A2 - Gowlland-Gualtieri, Alix

A2 - Madhav, Roopa

A2 - Ramanathan, Usha

CY - New Delhi

ER -

Costamagna F, Sindico F. The linkages between access to water and water scarcity with international investment law and the WTO regime. In Cullet P, Gowlland-Gualtieri A, Madhav R, Ramanathan U, editors, Water governance in motion: towards socially and environmentally sustainable water laws. New Delhi. 2010. p. 269-298