The limitations of automating OSINT: understanding the question, not the answer

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Answering key questions on matters of fact, such as whether a particular individual was employed by a named organization at a specific point in time, is easy if one has access to relevant data, for example, company financial records, income tax returns, or details of bank account transactions. For good reasons, such data are not widely accessible without authorization. In contrast, open source information may be unrestricted and free to access by interested parties. Whether such readily accessible data will prove helpful in determining an answer to such questions of fact as our aforementioned employment query is far from certain. The availability of relevant data is not assured. The desired information may simply be unavailable. If it is available, there is no assurance that the enquirer can successfully negotiate the required technology, adequately specify the desired information, and retrieve the data. In this chapter, the limitations of open source intelligence (OSINT) are described and outlined with reference to the risks around interpreting results from automated algorithms.

LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationAutomating Open Source Intelligence
Subtitle of host publicationAlgorithms for OSINT
EditorsRobert Layton, Paul A. Watters
Place of PublicationWaltham, MA.
Pages159-169
Number of pages11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 Dec 2015

Fingerprint

Taxation
Availability
Industry

Keywords

  • corroboration
  • credibility
  • provenance

Cite this

Weir, G. R. S. (2015). The limitations of automating OSINT: understanding the question, not the answer. In R. Layton, & P. A. Watters (Eds.), Automating Open Source Intelligence: Algorithms for OSINT (pp. 159-169). Waltham, MA.. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-802916-9.00009-9
Weir, George R.S. / The limitations of automating OSINT : understanding the question, not the answer. Automating Open Source Intelligence: Algorithms for OSINT. editor / Robert Layton ; Paul A. Watters. Waltham, MA., 2015. pp. 159-169
@inbook{e04bd32f14cd40b1a7bc2e910fee76b8,
title = "The limitations of automating OSINT: understanding the question, not the answer",
abstract = "Answering key questions on matters of fact, such as whether a particular individual was employed by a named organization at a specific point in time, is easy if one has access to relevant data, for example, company financial records, income tax returns, or details of bank account transactions. For good reasons, such data are not widely accessible without authorization. In contrast, open source information may be unrestricted and free to access by interested parties. Whether such readily accessible data will prove helpful in determining an answer to such questions of fact as our aforementioned employment query is far from certain. The availability of relevant data is not assured. The desired information may simply be unavailable. If it is available, there is no assurance that the enquirer can successfully negotiate the required technology, adequately specify the desired information, and retrieve the data. In this chapter, the limitations of open source intelligence (OSINT) are described and outlined with reference to the risks around interpreting results from automated algorithms.",
keywords = "corroboration, credibility, provenance",
author = "Weir, {George R.S.}",
year = "2015",
month = "12",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1016/B978-0-12-802916-9.00009-9",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780128029169",
pages = "159--169",
editor = "Robert Layton and Watters, {Paul A.}",
booktitle = "Automating Open Source Intelligence",

}

Weir, GRS 2015, The limitations of automating OSINT: understanding the question, not the answer. in R Layton & PA Watters (eds), Automating Open Source Intelligence: Algorithms for OSINT. Waltham, MA., pp. 159-169. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-802916-9.00009-9

The limitations of automating OSINT : understanding the question, not the answer. / Weir, George R.S.

Automating Open Source Intelligence: Algorithms for OSINT. ed. / Robert Layton; Paul A. Watters. Waltham, MA., 2015. p. 159-169.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - The limitations of automating OSINT

T2 - understanding the question, not the answer

AU - Weir, George R.S.

PY - 2015/12/3

Y1 - 2015/12/3

N2 - Answering key questions on matters of fact, such as whether a particular individual was employed by a named organization at a specific point in time, is easy if one has access to relevant data, for example, company financial records, income tax returns, or details of bank account transactions. For good reasons, such data are not widely accessible without authorization. In contrast, open source information may be unrestricted and free to access by interested parties. Whether such readily accessible data will prove helpful in determining an answer to such questions of fact as our aforementioned employment query is far from certain. The availability of relevant data is not assured. The desired information may simply be unavailable. If it is available, there is no assurance that the enquirer can successfully negotiate the required technology, adequately specify the desired information, and retrieve the data. In this chapter, the limitations of open source intelligence (OSINT) are described and outlined with reference to the risks around interpreting results from automated algorithms.

AB - Answering key questions on matters of fact, such as whether a particular individual was employed by a named organization at a specific point in time, is easy if one has access to relevant data, for example, company financial records, income tax returns, or details of bank account transactions. For good reasons, such data are not widely accessible without authorization. In contrast, open source information may be unrestricted and free to access by interested parties. Whether such readily accessible data will prove helpful in determining an answer to such questions of fact as our aforementioned employment query is far from certain. The availability of relevant data is not assured. The desired information may simply be unavailable. If it is available, there is no assurance that the enquirer can successfully negotiate the required technology, adequately specify the desired information, and retrieve the data. In this chapter, the limitations of open source intelligence (OSINT) are described and outlined with reference to the risks around interpreting results from automated algorithms.

KW - corroboration

KW - credibility

KW - provenance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84967316074&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/book/9780128029169

U2 - 10.1016/B978-0-12-802916-9.00009-9

DO - 10.1016/B978-0-12-802916-9.00009-9

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780128029169

SP - 159

EP - 169

BT - Automating Open Source Intelligence

A2 - Layton, Robert

A2 - Watters, Paul A.

CY - Waltham, MA.

ER -

Weir GRS. The limitations of automating OSINT: understanding the question, not the answer. In Layton R, Watters PA, editors, Automating Open Source Intelligence: Algorithms for OSINT. Waltham, MA. 2015. p. 159-169 https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-802916-9.00009-9