The foam geometry "paradox"

P S Grassia, J J Cilliers, S J Neethling

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Plateau's rule states that bubble lamellae in a foam meet at equal angles. Attempts to rationalize this rule via a naive "force along a tangent line" argument employing vertex variables are shown to fail, since they do not properly account for bubble volume constraints. Indeed Plateau's rule appears to make a foam system overdetermined, in the sense that there seem to be more constraints than available variables. The resolution of this paradox is that the angle constraints of Plateau's rule cannot be regarded as all independent. This is explained in detail for the two-bubble system in two dimensions. By exploiting just pressure-curvature relations and geometry, it is shown that the lamella joining the two bubbles is obliged to subtend precisely the angle needed to satisfy Plateau's rule and minimize energy. Speculations are offered for a many bubble foam.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1265-1281
Number of pages17
JournalCanadian Journal of Physics
Volume79
Issue number10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2001

Fingerprint

paradoxes
foams
Foams
bubbles
plateaus
Geometry
geometry
lamella
Joining
tangents
apexes
curvature
energy

Keywords

  • foam
  • geometry
  • bubble lamellae

Cite this

Grassia, P. S., Cilliers, J. J., & Neethling, S. J. (2001). The foam geometry "paradox". Canadian Journal of Physics, 79(10), 1265-1281. https://doi.org/10.1139/p01-114
Grassia, P S ; Cilliers, J J ; Neethling, S J. / The foam geometry "paradox". In: Canadian Journal of Physics. 2001 ; Vol. 79, No. 10. pp. 1265-1281.
@article{478d59ca0fd34047ac63f331645cc0c6,
title = "The foam geometry {"}paradox{"}",
abstract = "Plateau's rule states that bubble lamellae in a foam meet at equal angles. Attempts to rationalize this rule via a naive {"}force along a tangent line{"} argument employing vertex variables are shown to fail, since they do not properly account for bubble volume constraints. Indeed Plateau's rule appears to make a foam system overdetermined, in the sense that there seem to be more constraints than available variables. The resolution of this paradox is that the angle constraints of Plateau's rule cannot be regarded as all independent. This is explained in detail for the two-bubble system in two dimensions. By exploiting just pressure-curvature relations and geometry, it is shown that the lamella joining the two bubbles is obliged to subtend precisely the angle needed to satisfy Plateau's rule and minimize energy. Speculations are offered for a many bubble foam.",
keywords = "foam, geometry, bubble lamellae",
author = "Grassia, {P S} and Cilliers, {J J} and Neethling, {S J}",
year = "2001",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1139/p01-114",
language = "English",
volume = "79",
pages = "1265--1281",
journal = "Canadian Journal of Physics",
issn = "0008-4204",
number = "10",

}

Grassia, PS, Cilliers, JJ & Neethling, SJ 2001, 'The foam geometry "paradox"' Canadian Journal of Physics, vol. 79, no. 10, pp. 1265-1281. https://doi.org/10.1139/p01-114

The foam geometry "paradox". / Grassia, P S; Cilliers, J J; Neethling, S J.

In: Canadian Journal of Physics, Vol. 79, No. 10, 10.2001, p. 1265-1281.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The foam geometry "paradox"

AU - Grassia, P S

AU - Cilliers, J J

AU - Neethling, S J

PY - 2001/10

Y1 - 2001/10

N2 - Plateau's rule states that bubble lamellae in a foam meet at equal angles. Attempts to rationalize this rule via a naive "force along a tangent line" argument employing vertex variables are shown to fail, since they do not properly account for bubble volume constraints. Indeed Plateau's rule appears to make a foam system overdetermined, in the sense that there seem to be more constraints than available variables. The resolution of this paradox is that the angle constraints of Plateau's rule cannot be regarded as all independent. This is explained in detail for the two-bubble system in two dimensions. By exploiting just pressure-curvature relations and geometry, it is shown that the lamella joining the two bubbles is obliged to subtend precisely the angle needed to satisfy Plateau's rule and minimize energy. Speculations are offered for a many bubble foam.

AB - Plateau's rule states that bubble lamellae in a foam meet at equal angles. Attempts to rationalize this rule via a naive "force along a tangent line" argument employing vertex variables are shown to fail, since they do not properly account for bubble volume constraints. Indeed Plateau's rule appears to make a foam system overdetermined, in the sense that there seem to be more constraints than available variables. The resolution of this paradox is that the angle constraints of Plateau's rule cannot be regarded as all independent. This is explained in detail for the two-bubble system in two dimensions. By exploiting just pressure-curvature relations and geometry, it is shown that the lamella joining the two bubbles is obliged to subtend precisely the angle needed to satisfy Plateau's rule and minimize energy. Speculations are offered for a many bubble foam.

KW - foam

KW - geometry

KW - bubble lamellae

UR - http://www.nrcresearchpress.com/journal/cjp

U2 - 10.1139/p01-114

DO - 10.1139/p01-114

M3 - Article

VL - 79

SP - 1265

EP - 1281

JO - Canadian Journal of Physics

T2 - Canadian Journal of Physics

JF - Canadian Journal of Physics

SN - 0008-4204

IS - 10

ER -