The effectiveness of scoring and bipolar diathermy on ear carliage behavior: exvivo study

T.R. Qureshi, J.S. Hurren, T. Gourlay

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    5 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    A common unsatisfactory long-term outcome of otoplasty is undercorrection and residual deformity. Aggressive scoring with a scalpel blade can cause unattractive and painful ridging, especially in older patients with stiffer cartilage. We developed an ex vivo pig ear model to compare the effectiveness of bipolar diathermy with blade scoring for cartilage warping. Strips of cartilage harvested from Landrace pig ears were subjected to bipolar diathermy (group A), blade scoring (group B), and blade scoring combined with reverse-side bipolar diathermy (group C). The strip deflection and cartilage tension were measured for each group. No statistical difference (P <= 0.05) was detected between group A and group B for both outcomes. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy resulted in highly significant increases in both deflection (P <= 4.69-6) and tension (P <= 2.9-4). In conclusion, bipolar diathermy and scoring are equally effective in warping cartilage. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy is highly synergistic and produces more robust warping than scoring alone. This may help reduce both long- and short-term problems with undercorrection by allowing stronger conchal correction without producing the unattractive ridging that occurs with aggressive scoring.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages321-327
    Number of pages6
    JournalAnnals of Plastic Surgery
    Volume58
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2007

    Fingerprint

    Diathermy
    Ear
    Cartilage
    Swine

    Keywords

    • otoplasty
    • cartilage
    • bipolar diathermy
    • scoring
    • bioengineering

    Cite this

    @article{7df5f9d01cb1479bb807612a5d2901d3,
    title = "The effectiveness of scoring and bipolar diathermy on ear carliage behavior: exvivo study",
    abstract = "A common unsatisfactory long-term outcome of otoplasty is undercorrection and residual deformity. Aggressive scoring with a scalpel blade can cause unattractive and painful ridging, especially in older patients with stiffer cartilage. We developed an ex vivo pig ear model to compare the effectiveness of bipolar diathermy with blade scoring for cartilage warping. Strips of cartilage harvested from Landrace pig ears were subjected to bipolar diathermy (group A), blade scoring (group B), and blade scoring combined with reverse-side bipolar diathermy (group C). The strip deflection and cartilage tension were measured for each group. No statistical difference (P <= 0.05) was detected between group A and group B for both outcomes. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy resulted in highly significant increases in both deflection (P <= 4.69-6) and tension (P <= 2.9-4). In conclusion, bipolar diathermy and scoring are equally effective in warping cartilage. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy is highly synergistic and produces more robust warping than scoring alone. This may help reduce both long- and short-term problems with undercorrection by allowing stronger conchal correction without producing the unattractive ridging that occurs with aggressive scoring.",
    keywords = "otoplasty, cartilage, bipolar diathermy, scoring, bioengineering",
    author = "T.R. Qureshi and J.S. Hurren and T. Gourlay",
    year = "2007",
    doi = "10.1097/01.sap.0000237684.42771.10",
    language = "English",
    volume = "58",
    pages = "321--327",
    journal = "Annals of Plastic Surgery",
    issn = "0148-7043",
    publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",

    }

    The effectiveness of scoring and bipolar diathermy on ear carliage behavior: exvivo study. / Qureshi, T.R.; Hurren, J.S.; Gourlay, T.

    In: Annals of Plastic Surgery, Vol. 58, 2007, p. 321-327.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The effectiveness of scoring and bipolar diathermy on ear carliage behavior: exvivo study

    AU - Qureshi, T.R.

    AU - Hurren, J.S.

    AU - Gourlay, T.

    PY - 2007

    Y1 - 2007

    N2 - A common unsatisfactory long-term outcome of otoplasty is undercorrection and residual deformity. Aggressive scoring with a scalpel blade can cause unattractive and painful ridging, especially in older patients with stiffer cartilage. We developed an ex vivo pig ear model to compare the effectiveness of bipolar diathermy with blade scoring for cartilage warping. Strips of cartilage harvested from Landrace pig ears were subjected to bipolar diathermy (group A), blade scoring (group B), and blade scoring combined with reverse-side bipolar diathermy (group C). The strip deflection and cartilage tension were measured for each group. No statistical difference (P <= 0.05) was detected between group A and group B for both outcomes. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy resulted in highly significant increases in both deflection (P <= 4.69-6) and tension (P <= 2.9-4). In conclusion, bipolar diathermy and scoring are equally effective in warping cartilage. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy is highly synergistic and produces more robust warping than scoring alone. This may help reduce both long- and short-term problems with undercorrection by allowing stronger conchal correction without producing the unattractive ridging that occurs with aggressive scoring.

    AB - A common unsatisfactory long-term outcome of otoplasty is undercorrection and residual deformity. Aggressive scoring with a scalpel blade can cause unattractive and painful ridging, especially in older patients with stiffer cartilage. We developed an ex vivo pig ear model to compare the effectiveness of bipolar diathermy with blade scoring for cartilage warping. Strips of cartilage harvested from Landrace pig ears were subjected to bipolar diathermy (group A), blade scoring (group B), and blade scoring combined with reverse-side bipolar diathermy (group C). The strip deflection and cartilage tension were measured for each group. No statistical difference (P <= 0.05) was detected between group A and group B for both outcomes. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy resulted in highly significant increases in both deflection (P <= 4.69-6) and tension (P <= 2.9-4). In conclusion, bipolar diathermy and scoring are equally effective in warping cartilage. Scoring combined with bipolar diathermy is highly synergistic and produces more robust warping than scoring alone. This may help reduce both long- and short-term problems with undercorrection by allowing stronger conchal correction without producing the unattractive ridging that occurs with aggressive scoring.

    KW - otoplasty

    KW - cartilage

    KW - bipolar diathermy

    KW - scoring

    KW - bioengineering

    UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/01.sap.0000237684.42771.10

    U2 - 10.1097/01.sap.0000237684.42771.10

    DO - 10.1097/01.sap.0000237684.42771.10

    M3 - Article

    VL - 58

    SP - 321

    EP - 327

    JO - Annals of Plastic Surgery

    T2 - Annals of Plastic Surgery

    JF - Annals of Plastic Surgery

    SN - 0148-7043

    ER -