The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Using a sample of 1,385 firm year observations collected for UK nonfinancial listed firms on the LSE FTSE ALL SHARES index, this paper investigates the effect of geographic proximity between auditors and their clients, and auditor industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment over the period from 2006 – 2014. Results show a strongly significant positive relationship between geographic distance, measure by log of miles, and both the likelihood and magnitude of unexpected goodwill impairment. This indicates that the greater the distance between audit firm and the client headquarter, the greater information asymmetry and the less likely that auditors might control management from manipulating the impairment test and reporting more/less goodwill impairment than it should be. Interestingly, when the auditor is specialized, his expertise and knowledge helps to reduce the information asymmetry problems and become better able to challenge the management on the estimates and assumptions they have used, and thus constrain them from using goodwill impairment as a tool for managing their earnings. However, auditors’ specialization is moderating this relationship only when auditors are classified as being specialized on the regional level, demonstrating that knowledge and expertise are shared only between audit partners and offices located in the same region, and not expanded to others located outside that region.

Conference

ConferenceBritish Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityEdinburgh
Period10/04/1712/04/17
Internet address

Fingerprint

Goodwill
Impairment
Industry specialization
Auditors
Expertise
Information asymmetry
Audit firms
Proximity
Auditor specialization
Management control
Headquarters
Auditor industry specialization
Distance measure
Audit

Keywords

  • goodwill impairment
  • auditor specialization
  • geographic distance
  • board diversity

Cite this

Elmahgoub, M., & Smith, J. (2017). The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment. Paper presented at British Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Elmahgoub, Mohamed ; Smith, Julia. / The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment. Paper presented at British Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.31 p.
@conference{09e5598da86242fcad622ef9fe798942,
title = "The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment",
abstract = "Using a sample of 1,385 firm year observations collected for UK nonfinancial listed firms on the LSE FTSE ALL SHARES index, this paper investigates the effect of geographic proximity between auditors and their clients, and auditor industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment over the period from 2006 – 2014. Results show a strongly significant positive relationship between geographic distance, measure by log of miles, and both the likelihood and magnitude of unexpected goodwill impairment. This indicates that the greater the distance between audit firm and the client headquarter, the greater information asymmetry and the less likely that auditors might control management from manipulating the impairment test and reporting more/less goodwill impairment than it should be. Interestingly, when the auditor is specialized, his expertise and knowledge helps to reduce the information asymmetry problems and become better able to challenge the management on the estimates and assumptions they have used, and thus constrain them from using goodwill impairment as a tool for managing their earnings. However, auditors’ specialization is moderating this relationship only when auditors are classified as being specialized on the regional level, demonstrating that knowledge and expertise are shared only between audit partners and offices located in the same region, and not expanded to others located outside that region.",
keywords = "goodwill impairment, auditor specialization, geographic distance, board diversity",
author = "Mohamed Elmahgoub and Julia Smith",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "10",
language = "English",
note = "British Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017 ; Conference date: 10-04-2017 Through 12-04-2017",
url = "http://bafa.ac.uk/events/upcoming-events/annual-conference-2017.html",

}

Elmahgoub, M & Smith, J 2017, 'The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment' Paper presented at British Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 10/04/17 - 12/04/17, .

The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment. / Elmahgoub, Mohamed; Smith, Julia.

2017. Paper presented at British Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment

AU - Elmahgoub, Mohamed

AU - Smith, Julia

PY - 2017/4/10

Y1 - 2017/4/10

N2 - Using a sample of 1,385 firm year observations collected for UK nonfinancial listed firms on the LSE FTSE ALL SHARES index, this paper investigates the effect of geographic proximity between auditors and their clients, and auditor industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment over the period from 2006 – 2014. Results show a strongly significant positive relationship between geographic distance, measure by log of miles, and both the likelihood and magnitude of unexpected goodwill impairment. This indicates that the greater the distance between audit firm and the client headquarter, the greater information asymmetry and the less likely that auditors might control management from manipulating the impairment test and reporting more/less goodwill impairment than it should be. Interestingly, when the auditor is specialized, his expertise and knowledge helps to reduce the information asymmetry problems and become better able to challenge the management on the estimates and assumptions they have used, and thus constrain them from using goodwill impairment as a tool for managing their earnings. However, auditors’ specialization is moderating this relationship only when auditors are classified as being specialized on the regional level, demonstrating that knowledge and expertise are shared only between audit partners and offices located in the same region, and not expanded to others located outside that region.

AB - Using a sample of 1,385 firm year observations collected for UK nonfinancial listed firms on the LSE FTSE ALL SHARES index, this paper investigates the effect of geographic proximity between auditors and their clients, and auditor industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment over the period from 2006 – 2014. Results show a strongly significant positive relationship between geographic distance, measure by log of miles, and both the likelihood and magnitude of unexpected goodwill impairment. This indicates that the greater the distance between audit firm and the client headquarter, the greater information asymmetry and the less likely that auditors might control management from manipulating the impairment test and reporting more/less goodwill impairment than it should be. Interestingly, when the auditor is specialized, his expertise and knowledge helps to reduce the information asymmetry problems and become better able to challenge the management on the estimates and assumptions they have used, and thus constrain them from using goodwill impairment as a tool for managing their earnings. However, auditors’ specialization is moderating this relationship only when auditors are classified as being specialized on the regional level, demonstrating that knowledge and expertise are shared only between audit partners and offices located in the same region, and not expanded to others located outside that region.

KW - goodwill impairment

KW - auditor specialization

KW - geographic distance

KW - board diversity

UR - http://bafa.ac.uk/events/upcoming-events/annual-conference-2017.html

M3 - Paper

ER -

Elmahgoub M, Smith J. The effect of auditors' geographic distance and industry specialization on the reporting of goodwill impairment. 2017. Paper presented at British Accounting & Finance Association (BAFA) Annual Conference 2017, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.