The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland

Fraser of Allander Institute , Gioele Figus, Graeme Roy

Research output: Book/ReportCommissioned report

5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This report focusses on the long-term economic impact of Brexit, as well as the potential implications of the UK Government’s Withdrawal Agreement, and specifically the so called “Backstop” on Northern Ireland’s economy. The analysis is undertaken using a multisectoral dynamic macroeconomic model of Northern Ireland (NI). The model captures the domestic economy and key trade relationships between NI, the rest of the UK and the rest of the World (including the EU), and allows the analysis of a range of scenarios relative to a counterfactual position. We find that, based upon the assumptions and methodologies set out in this report, all Brexit options will negatively impact the NI economy with simulated reductions in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) ranging from 3.3% (hard Brexit) to 1.1% (soft Brexit). The scenarios examined that involve NI trade taking place within the context of the “Backstop” demonstrate simulated reductions in GDP ranging from 2.7% to 1.3%. These impacts are significantly smaller than those presented by the UK Government as part of its long term analysis published in November 2018. This research indicated that under a “no deal” scenario, the Northern Ireland economy could see a potential long term reduction in GVA of approximately 9%. Differences are partly driven by the fact that this report analyses the economic impact of Brexit in Northern Ireland using a single region model that considers the regional economy in isolation and only focuses on the impact of changes in trade. Results demonstrate the impact on the Northern Ireland economy of direct trade impacts only, and do not capture the economic consequences of Brexit on the UK economy as a whole. Therefore the potential knock-on effects of reduced economic activity in GB for the Northern Ireland economy are not captured. To provide a flavour of such effects we test the sensitivity of our results under the hard Brexit scenario to a potential 5% and 10% reduction in sales to GB1. This results in an overall reduction in GDP for a hard Brexit scenario of 4.0% and 4.6% respectively. Perhaps the more interesting finding – and what this analysis is designed to shed light upon – is the differences in the potential sectoral impacts of the various scenarios. The most affected industries across all the scenarios are the food and drink and agricultural sectors. There are also significant impacts for the manufacturing, financial services and wholesale and retail sectors. The impact on food and drink is significantly larger under the hard Brexit scenario due to the presence of both tariffs and non-tariff barriers. In the backstop scenarios, wholesale and retail is affected due to the presence of frictions in trade between GB and NI. The scenario where the backstop endures in part to NI and GB separately signs free trade agreement represents the most negative scenario after a hard Brexit.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationGlasgow
PublisherUniversity of Strathclyde
Commissioning bodyDepartment for the Economy in Northern Ireland
Number of pages22
Publication statusPublished - 31 Aug 2019

Fingerprint

Northern Ireland
Scenarios
Exit
Gross domestic product
Economic impact
Government
Food
Drinks
Financial services
Retail
Friction
Agricultural sector
Free trade agreements
Non-tariff barriers
Economic consequences
Retail sector
Methodology
Isolation
Industry
Macroeconomic models

Keywords

  • Brexit
  • UK Government's Withdrawal Agreement
  • Northern Ireland economy
  • trade relationships
  • Gross Domestic Product
  • GDP
  • manufacturing
  • financial services

Cite this

Fraser of Allander Institute , Figus, G., & Roy, G. (2019). The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland. Glasgow: University of Strathclyde.
Fraser of Allander Institute ; Figus, Gioele ; Roy, Graeme. / The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland. Glasgow : University of Strathclyde, 2019. 22 p.
@book{7a4e9151833b449e8388e9602e16bbcf,
title = "The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland",
abstract = "This report focusses on the long-term economic impact of Brexit, as well as the potential implications of the UK Government’s Withdrawal Agreement, and specifically the so called “Backstop” on Northern Ireland’s economy. The analysis is undertaken using a multisectoral dynamic macroeconomic model of Northern Ireland (NI). The model captures the domestic economy and key trade relationships between NI, the rest of the UK and the rest of the World (including the EU), and allows the analysis of a range of scenarios relative to a counterfactual position. We find that, based upon the assumptions and methodologies set out in this report, all Brexit options will negatively impact the NI economy with simulated reductions in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) ranging from 3.3{\%} (hard Brexit) to 1.1{\%} (soft Brexit). The scenarios examined that involve NI trade taking place within the context of the “Backstop” demonstrate simulated reductions in GDP ranging from 2.7{\%} to 1.3{\%}. These impacts are significantly smaller than those presented by the UK Government as part of its long term analysis published in November 2018. This research indicated that under a “no deal” scenario, the Northern Ireland economy could see a potential long term reduction in GVA of approximately 9{\%}. Differences are partly driven by the fact that this report analyses the economic impact of Brexit in Northern Ireland using a single region model that considers the regional economy in isolation and only focuses on the impact of changes in trade. Results demonstrate the impact on the Northern Ireland economy of direct trade impacts only, and do not capture the economic consequences of Brexit on the UK economy as a whole. Therefore the potential knock-on effects of reduced economic activity in GB for the Northern Ireland economy are not captured. To provide a flavour of such effects we test the sensitivity of our results under the hard Brexit scenario to a potential 5{\%} and 10{\%} reduction in sales to GB1. This results in an overall reduction in GDP for a hard Brexit scenario of 4.0{\%} and 4.6{\%} respectively. Perhaps the more interesting finding – and what this analysis is designed to shed light upon – is the differences in the potential sectoral impacts of the various scenarios. The most affected industries across all the scenarios are the food and drink and agricultural sectors. There are also significant impacts for the manufacturing, financial services and wholesale and retail sectors. The impact on food and drink is significantly larger under the hard Brexit scenario due to the presence of both tariffs and non-tariff barriers. In the backstop scenarios, wholesale and retail is affected due to the presence of frictions in trade between GB and NI. The scenario where the backstop endures in part to NI and GB separately signs free trade agreement represents the most negative scenario after a hard Brexit.",
keywords = "Brexit, UK Government's Withdrawal Agreement, Northern Ireland economy, trade relationships, Gross Domestic Product, GDP, manufacturing, financial services",
author = "{Fraser of Allander Institute} and Gioele Figus and Graeme Roy",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
day = "31",
language = "English",
publisher = "University of Strathclyde",

}

Fraser of Allander Institute , Figus, G & Roy, G 2019, The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland. University of Strathclyde, Glasgow.

The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland. / Fraser of Allander Institute ; Figus, Gioele; Roy, Graeme.

Glasgow : University of Strathclyde, 2019. 22 p.

Research output: Book/ReportCommissioned report

TY - BOOK

T1 - The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland

AU - Fraser of Allander Institute

AU - Figus, Gioele

AU - Roy, Graeme

PY - 2019/8/31

Y1 - 2019/8/31

N2 - This report focusses on the long-term economic impact of Brexit, as well as the potential implications of the UK Government’s Withdrawal Agreement, and specifically the so called “Backstop” on Northern Ireland’s economy. The analysis is undertaken using a multisectoral dynamic macroeconomic model of Northern Ireland (NI). The model captures the domestic economy and key trade relationships between NI, the rest of the UK and the rest of the World (including the EU), and allows the analysis of a range of scenarios relative to a counterfactual position. We find that, based upon the assumptions and methodologies set out in this report, all Brexit options will negatively impact the NI economy with simulated reductions in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) ranging from 3.3% (hard Brexit) to 1.1% (soft Brexit). The scenarios examined that involve NI trade taking place within the context of the “Backstop” demonstrate simulated reductions in GDP ranging from 2.7% to 1.3%. These impacts are significantly smaller than those presented by the UK Government as part of its long term analysis published in November 2018. This research indicated that under a “no deal” scenario, the Northern Ireland economy could see a potential long term reduction in GVA of approximately 9%. Differences are partly driven by the fact that this report analyses the economic impact of Brexit in Northern Ireland using a single region model that considers the regional economy in isolation and only focuses on the impact of changes in trade. Results demonstrate the impact on the Northern Ireland economy of direct trade impacts only, and do not capture the economic consequences of Brexit on the UK economy as a whole. Therefore the potential knock-on effects of reduced economic activity in GB for the Northern Ireland economy are not captured. To provide a flavour of such effects we test the sensitivity of our results under the hard Brexit scenario to a potential 5% and 10% reduction in sales to GB1. This results in an overall reduction in GDP for a hard Brexit scenario of 4.0% and 4.6% respectively. Perhaps the more interesting finding – and what this analysis is designed to shed light upon – is the differences in the potential sectoral impacts of the various scenarios. The most affected industries across all the scenarios are the food and drink and agricultural sectors. There are also significant impacts for the manufacturing, financial services and wholesale and retail sectors. The impact on food and drink is significantly larger under the hard Brexit scenario due to the presence of both tariffs and non-tariff barriers. In the backstop scenarios, wholesale and retail is affected due to the presence of frictions in trade between GB and NI. The scenario where the backstop endures in part to NI and GB separately signs free trade agreement represents the most negative scenario after a hard Brexit.

AB - This report focusses on the long-term economic impact of Brexit, as well as the potential implications of the UK Government’s Withdrawal Agreement, and specifically the so called “Backstop” on Northern Ireland’s economy. The analysis is undertaken using a multisectoral dynamic macroeconomic model of Northern Ireland (NI). The model captures the domestic economy and key trade relationships between NI, the rest of the UK and the rest of the World (including the EU), and allows the analysis of a range of scenarios relative to a counterfactual position. We find that, based upon the assumptions and methodologies set out in this report, all Brexit options will negatively impact the NI economy with simulated reductions in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) ranging from 3.3% (hard Brexit) to 1.1% (soft Brexit). The scenarios examined that involve NI trade taking place within the context of the “Backstop” demonstrate simulated reductions in GDP ranging from 2.7% to 1.3%. These impacts are significantly smaller than those presented by the UK Government as part of its long term analysis published in November 2018. This research indicated that under a “no deal” scenario, the Northern Ireland economy could see a potential long term reduction in GVA of approximately 9%. Differences are partly driven by the fact that this report analyses the economic impact of Brexit in Northern Ireland using a single region model that considers the regional economy in isolation and only focuses on the impact of changes in trade. Results demonstrate the impact on the Northern Ireland economy of direct trade impacts only, and do not capture the economic consequences of Brexit on the UK economy as a whole. Therefore the potential knock-on effects of reduced economic activity in GB for the Northern Ireland economy are not captured. To provide a flavour of such effects we test the sensitivity of our results under the hard Brexit scenario to a potential 5% and 10% reduction in sales to GB1. This results in an overall reduction in GDP for a hard Brexit scenario of 4.0% and 4.6% respectively. Perhaps the more interesting finding – and what this analysis is designed to shed light upon – is the differences in the potential sectoral impacts of the various scenarios. The most affected industries across all the scenarios are the food and drink and agricultural sectors. There are also significant impacts for the manufacturing, financial services and wholesale and retail sectors. The impact on food and drink is significantly larger under the hard Brexit scenario due to the presence of both tariffs and non-tariff barriers. In the backstop scenarios, wholesale and retail is affected due to the presence of frictions in trade between GB and NI. The scenario where the backstop endures in part to NI and GB separately signs free trade agreement represents the most negative scenario after a hard Brexit.

KW - Brexit

KW - UK Government's Withdrawal Agreement

KW - Northern Ireland economy

KW - trade relationships

KW - Gross Domestic Product

KW - GDP

KW - manufacturing

KW - financial services

UR - https://www.strath.ac.uk/business/economics/fraserofallanderinstitute/

M3 - Commissioned report

BT - The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland

PB - University of Strathclyde

CY - Glasgow

ER -

Fraser of Allander Institute , Figus G, Roy G. The Direct Long-term Trade Impacts of EU Exit Scenarios on Northern Ireland. Glasgow: University of Strathclyde, 2019. 22 p.