The constituency work of members of the Scottish Parliament and Assembly for Wales: approaches, relationships and rules

James Mitchell, J. Bradbury

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

27 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Scottish Parliament and National Assembly for Wales electoral systems created both constituency and list members. The article discusses hypotheses for exploring their behaviour and notes the particular context of regional party systems dominated to a greater or lesser extent by the Labour party. The authors find that constituency members of the Scottish Parliament and the National Assembly broadly conduct more constituency work than list members, although the extent of list member is still significant for a variety of reasons. The qualitative nature of list member constituency work is not systematically different from that of constituency members. Nevertheless, there are variations in list member approaches. Constituency and list member perceptions of list member work also differ and this has become a serious source of controversy. Relationships between constituency and list members, and between devolved representatives and MPs, are competitive or co-operative, predominantly in relation to partisan interest. In both Scotland and Wales predominantly Labour constituency members have critical views of the roles of list members and have contested the rules governing constituency work. This has been alleviated to some extent by commitments to political pluralism, though more in Scotland than in Wales.
LanguageEnglish
Pages117 - 145
Number of pages29
JournalRegional and Federal Studies
Volume17
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2007

Fingerprint

parliament
labor
electoral system
national assembly
regional party
Labour Party
party system
pluralism
commitment

Keywords

  • Welsh devolution
  • Scottish Parliament
  • home rule
  • constitutional change

Cite this

@article{28950d0b2fc24b7a812070e708bb9a6a,
title = "The constituency work of members of the Scottish Parliament and Assembly for Wales: approaches, relationships and rules",
abstract = "The Scottish Parliament and National Assembly for Wales electoral systems created both constituency and list members. The article discusses hypotheses for exploring their behaviour and notes the particular context of regional party systems dominated to a greater or lesser extent by the Labour party. The authors find that constituency members of the Scottish Parliament and the National Assembly broadly conduct more constituency work than list members, although the extent of list member is still significant for a variety of reasons. The qualitative nature of list member constituency work is not systematically different from that of constituency members. Nevertheless, there are variations in list member approaches. Constituency and list member perceptions of list member work also differ and this has become a serious source of controversy. Relationships between constituency and list members, and between devolved representatives and MPs, are competitive or co-operative, predominantly in relation to partisan interest. In both Scotland and Wales predominantly Labour constituency members have critical views of the roles of list members and have contested the rules governing constituency work. This has been alleviated to some extent by commitments to political pluralism, though more in Scotland than in Wales.",
keywords = "Welsh devolution, Scottish Parliament, home rule, constitutional change",
author = "James Mitchell and J. Bradbury",
year = "2007",
doi = "10.1080/13597560701189669",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "117 -- 145",
journal = "Regional and Federal Studies",
issn = "1359-7566",
number = "1",

}

The constituency work of members of the Scottish Parliament and Assembly for Wales : approaches, relationships and rules. / Mitchell, James; Bradbury, J.

In: Regional and Federal Studies, Vol. 17, No. 1, 2007, p. 117 - 145.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The constituency work of members of the Scottish Parliament and Assembly for Wales

T2 - Regional and Federal Studies

AU - Mitchell, James

AU - Bradbury, J.

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - The Scottish Parliament and National Assembly for Wales electoral systems created both constituency and list members. The article discusses hypotheses for exploring their behaviour and notes the particular context of regional party systems dominated to a greater or lesser extent by the Labour party. The authors find that constituency members of the Scottish Parliament and the National Assembly broadly conduct more constituency work than list members, although the extent of list member is still significant for a variety of reasons. The qualitative nature of list member constituency work is not systematically different from that of constituency members. Nevertheless, there are variations in list member approaches. Constituency and list member perceptions of list member work also differ and this has become a serious source of controversy. Relationships between constituency and list members, and between devolved representatives and MPs, are competitive or co-operative, predominantly in relation to partisan interest. In both Scotland and Wales predominantly Labour constituency members have critical views of the roles of list members and have contested the rules governing constituency work. This has been alleviated to some extent by commitments to political pluralism, though more in Scotland than in Wales.

AB - The Scottish Parliament and National Assembly for Wales electoral systems created both constituency and list members. The article discusses hypotheses for exploring their behaviour and notes the particular context of regional party systems dominated to a greater or lesser extent by the Labour party. The authors find that constituency members of the Scottish Parliament and the National Assembly broadly conduct more constituency work than list members, although the extent of list member is still significant for a variety of reasons. The qualitative nature of list member constituency work is not systematically different from that of constituency members. Nevertheless, there are variations in list member approaches. Constituency and list member perceptions of list member work also differ and this has become a serious source of controversy. Relationships between constituency and list members, and between devolved representatives and MPs, are competitive or co-operative, predominantly in relation to partisan interest. In both Scotland and Wales predominantly Labour constituency members have critical views of the roles of list members and have contested the rules governing constituency work. This has been alleviated to some extent by commitments to political pluralism, though more in Scotland than in Wales.

KW - Welsh devolution

KW - Scottish Parliament

KW - home rule

KW - constitutional change

U2 - 10.1080/13597560701189669

DO - 10.1080/13597560701189669

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 117

EP - 145

JO - Regional and Federal Studies

JF - Regional and Federal Studies

SN - 1359-7566

IS - 1

ER -