The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

This chapter addresses the relationship between the general principles of contract law and the more specific rules pertaining to the employment contract. The topic is not simply a matter of academic interest. It is important that we understand whether further evolution of the employment contract will be informed by those general principles or a self-contained body of rules. The dynamics of the rule creation process need to be fully understood. The subject is sometimes addressed on the basis that the paramount question is whether the law of the employment contract should be viewed as an instance of general contractual principles or would be better seen as a discrete body of law: `A central dilemma…is the extent to which [the]…law should, on the one hand, borrow from the general law of contract applicable to commercial and consumer contracts, and on the other, differentiate itself from those general rules in order to tailor a special law for the contract of employment.’ This `central dilemma’ is somewhat unhelpful as neither depiction is wholly explicatory. Many of the rules of the employment contract are certainly applications of general principles but, as is the case with all nominate contracts, instances exist of modifications or exceptions. No less significant is the manner in which such modifications and exceptions are likely to evolve and impact on other types of contract or indeed contract law as a whole.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Contract of Employment
EditorsMark Freedland, Alan Bogg, David Cabrelli, Hugh Collins, Nicola Countouris, A.C.L. Davies, Simon Deakin, Jeremias Prassl
Place of PublicationOxford
Chapter6
Pages124-144
Number of pages21
Publication statusPublished - 26 May 2016

Fingerprint

law of obligations
employment contract
common law
autonomy
Law

Keywords

  • contract of employment
  • employment law
  • policy

Cite this

Brodie, D. (2016). The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract. In M. Freedland, A. Bogg, D. Cabrelli, H. Collins, N. Countouris, A. C. L. Davies, S. Deakin, ... J. Prassl (Eds.), The Contract of Employment (pp. 124-144). Oxford.
Brodie, Douglas. / The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract. The Contract of Employment . editor / Mark Freedland ; Alan Bogg ; David Cabrelli ; Hugh Collins ; Nicola Countouris ; A.C.L. Davies ; Simon Deakin ; Jeremias Prassl. Oxford, 2016. pp. 124-144
@inbook{2726e4ca5ffb4097b1f09b786cee59dd,
title = "The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract",
abstract = "This chapter addresses the relationship between the general principles of contract law and the more specific rules pertaining to the employment contract. The topic is not simply a matter of academic interest. It is important that we understand whether further evolution of the employment contract will be informed by those general principles or a self-contained body of rules. The dynamics of the rule creation process need to be fully understood. The subject is sometimes addressed on the basis that the paramount question is whether the law of the employment contract should be viewed as an instance of general contractual principles or would be better seen as a discrete body of law: `A central dilemma…is the extent to which [the]…law should, on the one hand, borrow from the general law of contract applicable to commercial and consumer contracts, and on the other, differentiate itself from those general rules in order to tailor a special law for the contract of employment.’ This `central dilemma’ is somewhat unhelpful as neither depiction is wholly explicatory. Many of the rules of the employment contract are certainly applications of general principles but, as is the case with all nominate contracts, instances exist of modifications or exceptions. No less significant is the manner in which such modifications and exceptions are likely to evolve and impact on other types of contract or indeed contract law as a whole.",
keywords = "contract of employment, employment law, policy",
author = "Douglas Brodie",
year = "2016",
month = "5",
day = "26",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780198783169",
pages = "124--144",
editor = "Mark Freedland and Alan Bogg and David Cabrelli and Hugh Collins and Nicola Countouris and A.C.L. Davies and Simon Deakin and Jeremias Prassl",
booktitle = "The Contract of Employment",

}

Brodie, D 2016, The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract. in M Freedland, A Bogg, D Cabrelli, H Collins, N Countouris, ACL Davies, S Deakin & J Prassl (eds), The Contract of Employment . Oxford, pp. 124-144.

The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract. / Brodie, Douglas.

The Contract of Employment . ed. / Mark Freedland; Alan Bogg; David Cabrelli; Hugh Collins; Nicola Countouris; A.C.L. Davies; Simon Deakin; Jeremias Prassl. Oxford, 2016. p. 124-144.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract

AU - Brodie, Douglas

PY - 2016/5/26

Y1 - 2016/5/26

N2 - This chapter addresses the relationship between the general principles of contract law and the more specific rules pertaining to the employment contract. The topic is not simply a matter of academic interest. It is important that we understand whether further evolution of the employment contract will be informed by those general principles or a self-contained body of rules. The dynamics of the rule creation process need to be fully understood. The subject is sometimes addressed on the basis that the paramount question is whether the law of the employment contract should be viewed as an instance of general contractual principles or would be better seen as a discrete body of law: `A central dilemma…is the extent to which [the]…law should, on the one hand, borrow from the general law of contract applicable to commercial and consumer contracts, and on the other, differentiate itself from those general rules in order to tailor a special law for the contract of employment.’ This `central dilemma’ is somewhat unhelpful as neither depiction is wholly explicatory. Many of the rules of the employment contract are certainly applications of general principles but, as is the case with all nominate contracts, instances exist of modifications or exceptions. No less significant is the manner in which such modifications and exceptions are likely to evolve and impact on other types of contract or indeed contract law as a whole.

AB - This chapter addresses the relationship between the general principles of contract law and the more specific rules pertaining to the employment contract. The topic is not simply a matter of academic interest. It is important that we understand whether further evolution of the employment contract will be informed by those general principles or a self-contained body of rules. The dynamics of the rule creation process need to be fully understood. The subject is sometimes addressed on the basis that the paramount question is whether the law of the employment contract should be viewed as an instance of general contractual principles or would be better seen as a discrete body of law: `A central dilemma…is the extent to which [the]…law should, on the one hand, borrow from the general law of contract applicable to commercial and consumer contracts, and on the other, differentiate itself from those general rules in order to tailor a special law for the contract of employment.’ This `central dilemma’ is somewhat unhelpful as neither depiction is wholly explicatory. Many of the rules of the employment contract are certainly applications of general principles but, as is the case with all nominate contracts, instances exist of modifications or exceptions. No less significant is the manner in which such modifications and exceptions are likely to evolve and impact on other types of contract or indeed contract law as a whole.

KW - contract of employment

KW - employment law

KW - policy

UR - https://global.oup.com/academic/product/the-contract-of-employment-9780198783169?q=9780198783169&lang=en&cc=gb#

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780198783169

SP - 124

EP - 144

BT - The Contract of Employment

A2 - Freedland, Mark

A2 - Bogg, Alan

A2 - Cabrelli, David

A2 - Collins, Hugh

A2 - Countouris, Nicola

A2 - Davies, A.C.L.

A2 - Deakin, Simon

A2 - Prassl, Jeremias

CY - Oxford

ER -

Brodie D. The autonomy of the common law of the contract of employment from the general law of contract. In Freedland M, Bogg A, Cabrelli D, Collins H, Countouris N, Davies ACL, Deakin S, Prassl J, editors, The Contract of Employment . Oxford. 2016. p. 124-144