Tackling environmental crime in the European Union: the case of the missing victim?

Paul James Cardwell, Duncan French, Matthew Hall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In 2008, the EU adopted Directive 2008/99/EC on the protection of the environment through the criminal law, to be implemented in Member States by December 2010. Although the enforcement of environmental legislation by means of the criminal law is by no means novel, it has often played a secondary role to administrative sanctions and civil penalties. This Directive is thus perhaps indicative of a hardening of attitudes over breaches of environmental law. Nevertheless, this article considers the extent to which the response so far to environmental crime (including, but not limited to, the new EU Directive) has neglected the impact of such crime on the victims of that crime. The study of victims has become a key element in modern-day criminology, seeking to ensure broad acknowledgement, and respect, for the rights of victims. But in the case of environmental crime, there remains a noticeable gap. Although there are undoubtedly procedural difficulties in involving environmental victims in the criminal justice system, these are not insurmountable. Indeed there are a number of positive examples of where this is beginning to occur. In addition to a substantive critique of the directive, this article brings together doctrinal legal scholarship and theoretical criminology to address themes that have existed in parallel but have rarely been considered synergistically.

LanguageEnglish
Pages113-121
Number of pages9
JournalEnvironmental Law and Management
Volume23
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2011

Fingerprint

environmental crime
European Union
criminology
crime
criminal law
EU
offense
environmental legislation
environmental law
hardening
European Community
sanction
penalty
respect
justice
legislation
directive

Keywords

  • green criminology
  • environmental legislation
  • law enforcement
  • theoretical study

Cite this

@article{27e7e42e1d674f4687792aa9acc3a9cb,
title = "Tackling environmental crime in the European Union: the case of the missing victim?",
abstract = "In 2008, the EU adopted Directive 2008/99/EC on the protection of the environment through the criminal law, to be implemented in Member States by December 2010. Although the enforcement of environmental legislation by means of the criminal law is by no means novel, it has often played a secondary role to administrative sanctions and civil penalties. This Directive is thus perhaps indicative of a hardening of attitudes over breaches of environmental law. Nevertheless, this article considers the extent to which the response so far to environmental crime (including, but not limited to, the new EU Directive) has neglected the impact of such crime on the victims of that crime. The study of victims has become a key element in modern-day criminology, seeking to ensure broad acknowledgement, and respect, for the rights of victims. But in the case of environmental crime, there remains a noticeable gap. Although there are undoubtedly procedural difficulties in involving environmental victims in the criminal justice system, these are not insurmountable. Indeed there are a number of positive examples of where this is beginning to occur. In addition to a substantive critique of the directive, this article brings together doctrinal legal scholarship and theoretical criminology to address themes that have existed in parallel but have rarely been considered synergistically.",
keywords = "green criminology, environmental legislation, law enforcement, theoretical study",
author = "Cardwell, {Paul James} and Duncan French and Matthew Hall",
year = "2011",
month = "5",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "113--121",
journal = "Environmental Law and Management",
issn = "1067-6058",
number = "3",

}

Tackling environmental crime in the European Union : the case of the missing victim? / Cardwell, Paul James; French, Duncan; Hall, Matthew.

In: Environmental Law and Management, Vol. 23, No. 3, 01.05.2011, p. 113-121.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tackling environmental crime in the European Union

T2 - Environmental Law and Management

AU - Cardwell, Paul James

AU - French, Duncan

AU - Hall, Matthew

PY - 2011/5/1

Y1 - 2011/5/1

N2 - In 2008, the EU adopted Directive 2008/99/EC on the protection of the environment through the criminal law, to be implemented in Member States by December 2010. Although the enforcement of environmental legislation by means of the criminal law is by no means novel, it has often played a secondary role to administrative sanctions and civil penalties. This Directive is thus perhaps indicative of a hardening of attitudes over breaches of environmental law. Nevertheless, this article considers the extent to which the response so far to environmental crime (including, but not limited to, the new EU Directive) has neglected the impact of such crime on the victims of that crime. The study of victims has become a key element in modern-day criminology, seeking to ensure broad acknowledgement, and respect, for the rights of victims. But in the case of environmental crime, there remains a noticeable gap. Although there are undoubtedly procedural difficulties in involving environmental victims in the criminal justice system, these are not insurmountable. Indeed there are a number of positive examples of where this is beginning to occur. In addition to a substantive critique of the directive, this article brings together doctrinal legal scholarship and theoretical criminology to address themes that have existed in parallel but have rarely been considered synergistically.

AB - In 2008, the EU adopted Directive 2008/99/EC on the protection of the environment through the criminal law, to be implemented in Member States by December 2010. Although the enforcement of environmental legislation by means of the criminal law is by no means novel, it has often played a secondary role to administrative sanctions and civil penalties. This Directive is thus perhaps indicative of a hardening of attitudes over breaches of environmental law. Nevertheless, this article considers the extent to which the response so far to environmental crime (including, but not limited to, the new EU Directive) has neglected the impact of such crime on the victims of that crime. The study of victims has become a key element in modern-day criminology, seeking to ensure broad acknowledgement, and respect, for the rights of victims. But in the case of environmental crime, there remains a noticeable gap. Although there are undoubtedly procedural difficulties in involving environmental victims in the criminal justice system, these are not insurmountable. Indeed there are a number of positive examples of where this is beginning to occur. In addition to a substantive critique of the directive, this article brings together doctrinal legal scholarship and theoretical criminology to address themes that have existed in parallel but have rarely been considered synergistically.

KW - green criminology

KW - environmental legislation

KW - law enforcement

KW - theoretical study

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=80053114361&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 113

EP - 121

JO - Environmental Law and Management

JF - Environmental Law and Management

SN - 1067-6058

IS - 3

ER -