Survey on studies about model uncertainties in small body explorations

Jinglang Feng, Xiyun Hou, Roberto Armellin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Currently, the explorations of small solar system bodies (asteroids and comets) have become more and more popular. Due to the limited measurement capability and irregular shape and diverse spin status of the small body, uncertainties on the parameters of the system and s/c executions are a practical and troublesome problem for mission design and operations. The sample-based Monte Carlo simulation is primarily used to propagate and analyze the effects of these uncertainties on the surrounding orbital motion. However, it is generally time-consuming because of large samples required by the highly nonlinear dynamics. New methods need to be applied for balancing computational efficiency and accuracy. To motivate this research area and facilitate the mission design process, this review firstly discusses the dynamical models and the different methods of modeling the mostly related gravitational and non-gravitational forces. Then the main uncertainties in these force models are classified and analyzed, including approaching, orbiting and landing. Then the linear and nonlinear uncertainty propagation methods are described, together with their advantages and drawbacks. Typical mission examples and the associated uncertainty analysis, in terms of methods and outcomes, are summarized. Future research efforts are emphasized in terms of complete modelling, new mission scenarios, and application of (semi-) analytical methods in small body explorations.
Original languageEnglish
Article number100549
Number of pages12
JournalProgress in Aerospace Sciences
Volume110
Early online date6 Jun 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Oct 2019

Fingerprint

Asteroids
Uncertainty analysis
Solar system
Computational efficiency
Landing
Uncertainty
Monte Carlo simulation

Keywords

  • small body explorations
  • uncertainty analysis
  • Monte Carlo simulation
  • semi-analytical methods
  • micro-probe

Cite this

@article{dbfe4d2c37174851865ab10ddde9d6f9,
title = "Survey on studies about model uncertainties in small body explorations",
abstract = "Currently, the explorations of small solar system bodies (asteroids and comets) have become more and more popular. Due to the limited measurement capability and irregular shape and diverse spin status of the small body, uncertainties on the parameters of the system and s/c executions are a practical and troublesome problem for mission design and operations. The sample-based Monte Carlo simulation is primarily used to propagate and analyze the effects of these uncertainties on the surrounding orbital motion. However, it is generally time-consuming because of large samples required by the highly nonlinear dynamics. New methods need to be applied for balancing computational efficiency and accuracy. To motivate this research area and facilitate the mission design process, this review firstly discusses the dynamical models and the different methods of modeling the mostly related gravitational and non-gravitational forces. Then the main uncertainties in these force models are classified and analyzed, including approaching, orbiting and landing. Then the linear and nonlinear uncertainty propagation methods are described, together with their advantages and drawbacks. Typical mission examples and the associated uncertainty analysis, in terms of methods and outcomes, are summarized. Future research efforts are emphasized in terms of complete modelling, new mission scenarios, and application of (semi-) analytical methods in small body explorations.",
keywords = "small body explorations, uncertainty analysis, Monte Carlo simulation, semi-analytical methods, micro-probe",
author = "Jinglang Feng and Xiyun Hou and Roberto Armellin",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1016/j.paerosci.2019.05.009",
language = "English",
volume = "110",
journal = "Progress in Aerospace Sciences",
issn = "0376-0421",

}

Survey on studies about model uncertainties in small body explorations. / Feng, Jinglang; Hou, Xiyun ; Armellin, Roberto.

In: Progress in Aerospace Sciences, Vol. 110, 100549, 31.10.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Survey on studies about model uncertainties in small body explorations

AU - Feng, Jinglang

AU - Hou, Xiyun

AU - Armellin, Roberto

PY - 2019/10/31

Y1 - 2019/10/31

N2 - Currently, the explorations of small solar system bodies (asteroids and comets) have become more and more popular. Due to the limited measurement capability and irregular shape and diverse spin status of the small body, uncertainties on the parameters of the system and s/c executions are a practical and troublesome problem for mission design and operations. The sample-based Monte Carlo simulation is primarily used to propagate and analyze the effects of these uncertainties on the surrounding orbital motion. However, it is generally time-consuming because of large samples required by the highly nonlinear dynamics. New methods need to be applied for balancing computational efficiency and accuracy. To motivate this research area and facilitate the mission design process, this review firstly discusses the dynamical models and the different methods of modeling the mostly related gravitational and non-gravitational forces. Then the main uncertainties in these force models are classified and analyzed, including approaching, orbiting and landing. Then the linear and nonlinear uncertainty propagation methods are described, together with their advantages and drawbacks. Typical mission examples and the associated uncertainty analysis, in terms of methods and outcomes, are summarized. Future research efforts are emphasized in terms of complete modelling, new mission scenarios, and application of (semi-) analytical methods in small body explorations.

AB - Currently, the explorations of small solar system bodies (asteroids and comets) have become more and more popular. Due to the limited measurement capability and irregular shape and diverse spin status of the small body, uncertainties on the parameters of the system and s/c executions are a practical and troublesome problem for mission design and operations. The sample-based Monte Carlo simulation is primarily used to propagate and analyze the effects of these uncertainties on the surrounding orbital motion. However, it is generally time-consuming because of large samples required by the highly nonlinear dynamics. New methods need to be applied for balancing computational efficiency and accuracy. To motivate this research area and facilitate the mission design process, this review firstly discusses the dynamical models and the different methods of modeling the mostly related gravitational and non-gravitational forces. Then the main uncertainties in these force models are classified and analyzed, including approaching, orbiting and landing. Then the linear and nonlinear uncertainty propagation methods are described, together with their advantages and drawbacks. Typical mission examples and the associated uncertainty analysis, in terms of methods and outcomes, are summarized. Future research efforts are emphasized in terms of complete modelling, new mission scenarios, and application of (semi-) analytical methods in small body explorations.

KW - small body explorations

KW - uncertainty analysis

KW - Monte Carlo simulation

KW - semi-analytical methods

KW - micro-probe

UR - http://epubs.surrey.ac.uk/851949/

U2 - 10.1016/j.paerosci.2019.05.009

DO - 10.1016/j.paerosci.2019.05.009

M3 - Article

VL - 110

JO - Progress in Aerospace Sciences

JF - Progress in Aerospace Sciences

SN - 0376-0421

M1 - 100549

ER -