Success at a cost: the induction of new teachers in Scotland

Jim McNally

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

The chapter will firstly clarify different interpretations of what mentoring means in the Scottish context. The term is often used for a particular person in an organisation (e.g. the school) who is asked by management to take responsibility for looking after the beginner (e.g. the new teacher in school). The 'appointed' mentor tends to have a more formal responsibility for the induction of the new teacher. There is in most organisations, however, a more naturally occurring kind of mentoring (e.g. from fellow teachers in school) and so this alternative view will also be discussed. The origins of setting up a more systematic support for new teachers in Scottish schools came from the growing awareness within the policy community during the 1990s that too many new teachers were not receiving the stable foundation of teaching experience that they needed. At the same time there was a clear trend of a growing culture of accountability in the form of professional and occupational standards. In the early 2000s, the Scottish Teacher Induction Scheme was established and rolled out nationally, supported by fairly substantial government funding. The scheme has received international recognition but the reasons for its success, such as it is, are not that clear, some claiming it is due to the formal support from mentors and meetings, others from the restoration of stability. Moreover, there have been unfortunate (possibly unforeseen) consequences - a rise in new teacher unemployment and dramatic reductions in intake numbers for Teacher Education Institutions. In exploring what lessons are to be learned from the Scottish experience, the chapter will also draw on a series of research projects and publications by the author and others that will include reference to dimensions and indicators of early professional learning, and the nature of identity formation in new teachers.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationVeiledning av nye lærere
Subtitle of host publicationnasjonale og internasjonale perspektiver
EditorsKari Smith, Marit Ulvik
Place of PublicationOslo, Norway
Pages164-175
Number of pages12
Publication statusPublished - 10 Dec 2010

Fingerprint

induction
teacher
costs
mentoring
school
responsibility
international recognition
identity formation
restoration
unemployment
experience
research project
funding
interpretation
human being
trend
Teaching
management
learning
community

Keywords

  • teaching
  • new teachers
  • Scotland
  • induction
  • success

Cite this

McNally, J. (2010). Success at a cost: the induction of new teachers in Scotland. In K. Smith, & M. Ulvik (Eds.), Veiledning av nye lærere: nasjonale og internasjonale perspektiver (pp. 164-175). Oslo, Norway.
McNally, Jim. / Success at a cost : the induction of new teachers in Scotland. Veiledning av nye lærere: nasjonale og internasjonale perspektiver. editor / Kari Smith ; Marit Ulvik. Oslo, Norway, 2010. pp. 164-175
@inbook{95781d8b6505412a8bda0712b6ed5fa4,
title = "Success at a cost: the induction of new teachers in Scotland",
abstract = "The chapter will firstly clarify different interpretations of what mentoring means in the Scottish context. The term is often used for a particular person in an organisation (e.g. the school) who is asked by management to take responsibility for looking after the beginner (e.g. the new teacher in school). The 'appointed' mentor tends to have a more formal responsibility for the induction of the new teacher. There is in most organisations, however, a more naturally occurring kind of mentoring (e.g. from fellow teachers in school) and so this alternative view will also be discussed. The origins of setting up a more systematic support for new teachers in Scottish schools came from the growing awareness within the policy community during the 1990s that too many new teachers were not receiving the stable foundation of teaching experience that they needed. At the same time there was a clear trend of a growing culture of accountability in the form of professional and occupational standards. In the early 2000s, the Scottish Teacher Induction Scheme was established and rolled out nationally, supported by fairly substantial government funding. The scheme has received international recognition but the reasons for its success, such as it is, are not that clear, some claiming it is due to the formal support from mentors and meetings, others from the restoration of stability. Moreover, there have been unfortunate (possibly unforeseen) consequences - a rise in new teacher unemployment and dramatic reductions in intake numbers for Teacher Education Institutions. In exploring what lessons are to be learned from the Scottish experience, the chapter will also draw on a series of research projects and publications by the author and others that will include reference to dimensions and indicators of early professional learning, and the nature of identity formation in new teachers.",
keywords = "teaching, new teachers, Scotland, induction, success",
author = "Jim McNally",
note = "Translation of book title: Mentoring of new teachers: national and international perspectives",
year = "2010",
month = "12",
day = "10",
language = "English",
isbn = "9788215017099",
pages = "164--175",
editor = "Smith, {Kari } and Ulvik, {Marit }",
booktitle = "Veiledning av nye l{\ae}rere",

}

McNally, J 2010, Success at a cost: the induction of new teachers in Scotland. in K Smith & M Ulvik (eds), Veiledning av nye lærere: nasjonale og internasjonale perspektiver. Oslo, Norway, pp. 164-175.

Success at a cost : the induction of new teachers in Scotland. / McNally, Jim.

Veiledning av nye lærere: nasjonale og internasjonale perspektiver. ed. / Kari Smith; Marit Ulvik. Oslo, Norway, 2010. p. 164-175.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Success at a cost

T2 - the induction of new teachers in Scotland

AU - McNally, Jim

N1 - Translation of book title: Mentoring of new teachers: national and international perspectives

PY - 2010/12/10

Y1 - 2010/12/10

N2 - The chapter will firstly clarify different interpretations of what mentoring means in the Scottish context. The term is often used for a particular person in an organisation (e.g. the school) who is asked by management to take responsibility for looking after the beginner (e.g. the new teacher in school). The 'appointed' mentor tends to have a more formal responsibility for the induction of the new teacher. There is in most organisations, however, a more naturally occurring kind of mentoring (e.g. from fellow teachers in school) and so this alternative view will also be discussed. The origins of setting up a more systematic support for new teachers in Scottish schools came from the growing awareness within the policy community during the 1990s that too many new teachers were not receiving the stable foundation of teaching experience that they needed. At the same time there was a clear trend of a growing culture of accountability in the form of professional and occupational standards. In the early 2000s, the Scottish Teacher Induction Scheme was established and rolled out nationally, supported by fairly substantial government funding. The scheme has received international recognition but the reasons for its success, such as it is, are not that clear, some claiming it is due to the formal support from mentors and meetings, others from the restoration of stability. Moreover, there have been unfortunate (possibly unforeseen) consequences - a rise in new teacher unemployment and dramatic reductions in intake numbers for Teacher Education Institutions. In exploring what lessons are to be learned from the Scottish experience, the chapter will also draw on a series of research projects and publications by the author and others that will include reference to dimensions and indicators of early professional learning, and the nature of identity formation in new teachers.

AB - The chapter will firstly clarify different interpretations of what mentoring means in the Scottish context. The term is often used for a particular person in an organisation (e.g. the school) who is asked by management to take responsibility for looking after the beginner (e.g. the new teacher in school). The 'appointed' mentor tends to have a more formal responsibility for the induction of the new teacher. There is in most organisations, however, a more naturally occurring kind of mentoring (e.g. from fellow teachers in school) and so this alternative view will also be discussed. The origins of setting up a more systematic support for new teachers in Scottish schools came from the growing awareness within the policy community during the 1990s that too many new teachers were not receiving the stable foundation of teaching experience that they needed. At the same time there was a clear trend of a growing culture of accountability in the form of professional and occupational standards. In the early 2000s, the Scottish Teacher Induction Scheme was established and rolled out nationally, supported by fairly substantial government funding. The scheme has received international recognition but the reasons for its success, such as it is, are not that clear, some claiming it is due to the formal support from mentors and meetings, others from the restoration of stability. Moreover, there have been unfortunate (possibly unforeseen) consequences - a rise in new teacher unemployment and dramatic reductions in intake numbers for Teacher Education Institutions. In exploring what lessons are to be learned from the Scottish experience, the chapter will also draw on a series of research projects and publications by the author and others that will include reference to dimensions and indicators of early professional learning, and the nature of identity formation in new teachers.

KW - teaching

KW - new teachers

KW - Scotland

KW - induction

KW - success

UR - http://www.universitetsforlaget.no/boker/pedagogikk/katalog?productId=41902022

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9788215017099

SP - 164

EP - 175

BT - Veiledning av nye lærere

A2 - Smith, Kari

A2 - Ulvik, Marit

CY - Oslo, Norway

ER -

McNally J. Success at a cost: the induction of new teachers in Scotland. In Smith K, Ulvik M, editors, Veiledning av nye lærere: nasjonale og internasjonale perspektiver. Oslo, Norway. 2010. p. 164-175