Statistical multicriteria evaluation of asteroid deflection methods

Nicolas Thiry, Massimiliano Vasile

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution book

2 Citations (Scopus)
42 Downloads (Pure)


We assess in this paper 3 different deflection approaches for a wide range of virtual collision scenarios: the kinetic impactor is considered for the family of impulsive deflection methods whereas the family of slow-push methods is represented by the laser ablation and the ion beam shepherd techniques. A sample of 100 deflection scenarios was created from realistic distribution of PHA eccentricities, semi-major axis and inclination and, for each case, a virtual impactor scenario was formed by modifying the argument of perigee so that the virtual PHA crosses the ecliptic plane at a distance of 1AU. A fixed asteroid diameter of 156m and 212m are considered. A realistic model of each deflection method was integrated within a systematic approach to size the spacecraft and predict the achievable deflection for a given mission. The available mass to perform the deflection depends on the transfer strategy. For the case of the kinetic impactor, a direct injection using a multiple-revolution Lambert arc is considered. For the case of slow-push methods, a low-thrust transfer is retained in order to take advantage of the large electrical power available which would otherwise remain unused during the transfer phase. In all cases, the launch capability of Delta 4 Heavy - RS-68A upgrade version (10-tons at C3=0) is assumed. Finally, global optimization techniques are used to compare the methods with respect to 2 criteria: the minimum duration between the departure date and the time of virtual impact required to deflect the PHA by more than 2 Earth radii or the miss-distance achieved within a total duration of 10 years. Our results provide an interesting insight into the range of applicability of individual deflection methods and suggest the need to develop multiple methods in parallel for a global mitigation of possible threats.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication67th International Astronautical Congress
Place of PublicationParis
Publication statusPublished - 26 Sept 2016
Event67th International Astronautical Congress - Expo Guadalajara, Guadalajara, Mexico
Duration: 26 Sept 201630 Sept 2016
Conference number: 67

Publication series

NameProceedings of the International Astronautical Congress, IAC
PublisherInternational Astronautical Federation
ISSN (Print)0074-1795


Conference67th International Astronautical Congress
Abbreviated titleIAC
Internet address


  • deflection
  • virtual collision scenarios
  • kinetic impactor
  • multiple-revolution Lambert arc
  • optimisation
  • optimization


Dive into the research topics of 'Statistical multicriteria evaluation of asteroid deflection methods'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this