Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods.

Keith Torrance, Christine Switzer, Guillermo Rein, Rory Hadden, Belcher Claire, Ricky Carvel, Helen Keenan

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Coal mining was widespread in the central belt of Scotland from 1830 until the 1970’s and created a legacy of waste tips or ‘bings’ that still dot the landscape. High content of coal fines and carbonaceous shales, make bings very prone to self-heating and smoldering combustion. A 30 m high waste heap at Bogside, North Lanarkshire, Scotland, started to smoulder in 2009, approximately 80 years after the closure of the pit and waste dumping. Induced smouldering, a flameless combustion process, of soils contaminated with tar, PAHs, heavy oils and other organic compounds is a promising technology for the remediation of brown field sites, but has hitherto been conducted on an experimental scale of several hundred tonnes. But the large scale phenomena of burning bings provide a unique opportunity to study a ‘natural’ analogue for smouldering remediation.
Chemical, geotechnical and physical parameters of the Bogside Bing have been studied. A combustion front is moving from west to east along the axis of the tip at an approximate rate of 1m/month and three well-defined zones were identified and mapped using thermal imagery and temperature probes: the undisturbed zone, the preheating plus drying zone and the combustion zone. The subsurface fire is resulting in a detrimental effect to the vegetation and structural integrity of the heap. Spread of the combustion is accompanied by the development of vents ahead of the front and fissures that run parallel to the direction of heating and smaller landslips along the flanks. It is probable that changes to the soil mechanics’ of the tip induced by the smouldering front create a network of fissures, some running deep, that supply the front with enough air to sustain the process. Analysis of gas from the vents, show elevated CO2, CO, CH4 and SO2, and partially depleted in oxygen. All these are indicative of smouldering activity deep into the tip. The primary environmental concern is likely to be from SO2 release, although the stability of the structure may be compromised. Understanding the development of internal fissures and their role in sustaining the combustion process is crucial to utilizing smouldering as a remediation method for large areas of land contaminated by organic compounds. Bogside Bing continues to release products of combustion and represents an accidental source of fossil fuel burning.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 10 Oct 2011
EventGeological Society of America Annual Meeting - Minneapolis, United States
Duration: 9 Oct 201112 Oct 2011

Conference

ConferenceGeological Society of America Annual Meeting
CountryUnited States
CityMinneapolis
Period9/10/1112/10/11

Fingerprint

natural analog
remediation
combustion
coal
fissure
organic compound
heating
contaminated land
soil mechanics
tar
heavy oil
method
coal mining
fossil fuel
PAH
imagery
probe
oxygen
vegetation
air

Keywords

  • smoldering combustion
  • coal mining
  • coal waste

Cite this

Torrance, K., Switzer, C., Rein, G., Hadden, R., Claire, B., Carvel, R., & Keenan, H. (2011). Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods.. Paper presented at Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Minneapolis, United States.
Torrance, Keith ; Switzer, Christine ; Rein, Guillermo ; Hadden, Rory ; Claire, Belcher ; Carvel, Ricky ; Keenan, Helen. / Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods. Paper presented at Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Minneapolis, United States.
@conference{00df50168f074af98f5b8420e270e51a,
title = "Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods.",
abstract = "Coal mining was widespread in the central belt of Scotland from 1830 until the 1970’s and created a legacy of waste tips or ‘bings’ that still dot the landscape. High content of coal fines and carbonaceous shales, make bings very prone to self-heating and smoldering combustion. A 30 m high waste heap at Bogside, North Lanarkshire, Scotland, started to smoulder in 2009, approximately 80 years after the closure of the pit and waste dumping. Induced smouldering, a flameless combustion process, of soils contaminated with tar, PAHs, heavy oils and other organic compounds is a promising technology for the remediation of brown field sites, but has hitherto been conducted on an experimental scale of several hundred tonnes. But the large scale phenomena of burning bings provide a unique opportunity to study a ‘natural’ analogue for smouldering remediation.Chemical, geotechnical and physical parameters of the Bogside Bing have been studied. A combustion front is moving from west to east along the axis of the tip at an approximate rate of 1m/month and three well-defined zones were identified and mapped using thermal imagery and temperature probes: the undisturbed zone, the preheating plus drying zone and the combustion zone. The subsurface fire is resulting in a detrimental effect to the vegetation and structural integrity of the heap. Spread of the combustion is accompanied by the development of vents ahead of the front and fissures that run parallel to the direction of heating and smaller landslips along the flanks. It is probable that changes to the soil mechanics’ of the tip induced by the smouldering front create a network of fissures, some running deep, that supply the front with enough air to sustain the process. Analysis of gas from the vents, show elevated CO2, CO, CH4 and SO2, and partially depleted in oxygen. All these are indicative of smouldering activity deep into the tip. The primary environmental concern is likely to be from SO2 release, although the stability of the structure may be compromised. Understanding the development of internal fissures and their role in sustaining the combustion process is crucial to utilizing smouldering as a remediation method for large areas of land contaminated by organic compounds. Bogside Bing continues to release products of combustion and represents an accidental source of fossil fuel burning.",
keywords = "smoldering combustion, coal mining, coal waste",
author = "Keith Torrance and Christine Switzer and Guillermo Rein and Rory Hadden and Belcher Claire and Ricky Carvel and Helen Keenan",
year = "2011",
month = "10",
day = "10",
language = "English",
note = "Geological Society of America Annual Meeting ; Conference date: 09-10-2011 Through 12-10-2011",

}

Torrance, K, Switzer, C, Rein, G, Hadden, R, Claire, B, Carvel, R & Keenan, H 2011, 'Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods.' Paper presented at Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Minneapolis, United States, 9/10/11 - 12/10/11, .

Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods. / Torrance, Keith; Switzer, Christine; Rein, Guillermo; Hadden, Rory; Claire, Belcher; Carvel, Ricky; Keenan, Helen.

2011. Paper presented at Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Minneapolis, United States.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods.

AU - Torrance, Keith

AU - Switzer, Christine

AU - Rein, Guillermo

AU - Hadden, Rory

AU - Claire, Belcher

AU - Carvel, Ricky

AU - Keenan, Helen

PY - 2011/10/10

Y1 - 2011/10/10

N2 - Coal mining was widespread in the central belt of Scotland from 1830 until the 1970’s and created a legacy of waste tips or ‘bings’ that still dot the landscape. High content of coal fines and carbonaceous shales, make bings very prone to self-heating and smoldering combustion. A 30 m high waste heap at Bogside, North Lanarkshire, Scotland, started to smoulder in 2009, approximately 80 years after the closure of the pit and waste dumping. Induced smouldering, a flameless combustion process, of soils contaminated with tar, PAHs, heavy oils and other organic compounds is a promising technology for the remediation of brown field sites, but has hitherto been conducted on an experimental scale of several hundred tonnes. But the large scale phenomena of burning bings provide a unique opportunity to study a ‘natural’ analogue for smouldering remediation.Chemical, geotechnical and physical parameters of the Bogside Bing have been studied. A combustion front is moving from west to east along the axis of the tip at an approximate rate of 1m/month and three well-defined zones were identified and mapped using thermal imagery and temperature probes: the undisturbed zone, the preheating plus drying zone and the combustion zone. The subsurface fire is resulting in a detrimental effect to the vegetation and structural integrity of the heap. Spread of the combustion is accompanied by the development of vents ahead of the front and fissures that run parallel to the direction of heating and smaller landslips along the flanks. It is probable that changes to the soil mechanics’ of the tip induced by the smouldering front create a network of fissures, some running deep, that supply the front with enough air to sustain the process. Analysis of gas from the vents, show elevated CO2, CO, CH4 and SO2, and partially depleted in oxygen. All these are indicative of smouldering activity deep into the tip. The primary environmental concern is likely to be from SO2 release, although the stability of the structure may be compromised. Understanding the development of internal fissures and their role in sustaining the combustion process is crucial to utilizing smouldering as a remediation method for large areas of land contaminated by organic compounds. Bogside Bing continues to release products of combustion and represents an accidental source of fossil fuel burning.

AB - Coal mining was widespread in the central belt of Scotland from 1830 until the 1970’s and created a legacy of waste tips or ‘bings’ that still dot the landscape. High content of coal fines and carbonaceous shales, make bings very prone to self-heating and smoldering combustion. A 30 m high waste heap at Bogside, North Lanarkshire, Scotland, started to smoulder in 2009, approximately 80 years after the closure of the pit and waste dumping. Induced smouldering, a flameless combustion process, of soils contaminated with tar, PAHs, heavy oils and other organic compounds is a promising technology for the remediation of brown field sites, but has hitherto been conducted on an experimental scale of several hundred tonnes. But the large scale phenomena of burning bings provide a unique opportunity to study a ‘natural’ analogue for smouldering remediation.Chemical, geotechnical and physical parameters of the Bogside Bing have been studied. A combustion front is moving from west to east along the axis of the tip at an approximate rate of 1m/month and three well-defined zones were identified and mapped using thermal imagery and temperature probes: the undisturbed zone, the preheating plus drying zone and the combustion zone. The subsurface fire is resulting in a detrimental effect to the vegetation and structural integrity of the heap. Spread of the combustion is accompanied by the development of vents ahead of the front and fissures that run parallel to the direction of heating and smaller landslips along the flanks. It is probable that changes to the soil mechanics’ of the tip induced by the smouldering front create a network of fissures, some running deep, that supply the front with enough air to sustain the process. Analysis of gas from the vents, show elevated CO2, CO, CH4 and SO2, and partially depleted in oxygen. All these are indicative of smouldering activity deep into the tip. The primary environmental concern is likely to be from SO2 release, although the stability of the structure may be compromised. Understanding the development of internal fissures and their role in sustaining the combustion process is crucial to utilizing smouldering as a remediation method for large areas of land contaminated by organic compounds. Bogside Bing continues to release products of combustion and represents an accidental source of fossil fuel burning.

KW - smoldering combustion

KW - coal mining

KW - coal waste

UR - http://gsa.confex.com/data/handout/gsa/2011AM/Paper_195116_handout_278_0.pdf

M3 - Paper

ER -

Torrance K, Switzer C, Rein G, Hadden R, Claire B, Carvel R et al. Spontaneous combustion of coal waste tips as a natural analogue for smouldering remediation methods.. 2011. Paper presented at Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Minneapolis, United States.