South Africa's Civil Union Act 2006: a Scottish perspective

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Considers the implications of the ambiguity in the South African Civil Union Act 2006 concerning: (1) whether the form of "marriage" that it introduces, which is available to both opposite and same sex couples, is the same as the common law or the customary law marriage institutions; and (2) the substantive nature of the distinction between its "marriage" and "civil partnership" institutions. Suggests that the real distinction is between same and opposite sex civil unions, and compares the reasoning behind the decision to create a unique same sex "marriage" and the UK approach of establishing a "civil partnership" institution that is analogous to marriage.
LanguageEnglish
Pages21-41
Number of pages21
JournalJuridical Review
Volume21
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

South Africa
Marriage

Keywords

  • civil partnerships
  • South Africa
  • Scotland
  • same sex partners
  • marriage
  • comparative law

Cite this

@article{af0511c8493e4f1e830bac2d96dcc437,
title = "South Africa's Civil Union Act 2006: a Scottish perspective",
abstract = "Considers the implications of the ambiguity in the South African Civil Union Act 2006 concerning: (1) whether the form of {"}marriage{"} that it introduces, which is available to both opposite and same sex couples, is the same as the common law or the customary law marriage institutions; and (2) the substantive nature of the distinction between its {"}marriage{"} and {"}civil partnership{"} institutions. Suggests that the real distinction is between same and opposite sex civil unions, and compares the reasoning behind the decision to create a unique same sex {"}marriage{"} and the UK approach of establishing a {"}civil partnership{"} institution that is analogous to marriage.",
keywords = "civil partnerships, South Africa, Scotland, same sex partners, marriage, comparative law",
author = "Kenneth Norrie",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "21--41",
journal = "Juridical Review",
issn = "0022-6785",
number = "1",

}

South Africa's Civil Union Act 2006 : a Scottish perspective. / Norrie, Kenneth.

In: Juridical Review, Vol. 21, No. 1, 2010, p. 21-41.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - South Africa's Civil Union Act 2006

T2 - Juridical Review

AU - Norrie, Kenneth

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - Considers the implications of the ambiguity in the South African Civil Union Act 2006 concerning: (1) whether the form of "marriage" that it introduces, which is available to both opposite and same sex couples, is the same as the common law or the customary law marriage institutions; and (2) the substantive nature of the distinction between its "marriage" and "civil partnership" institutions. Suggests that the real distinction is between same and opposite sex civil unions, and compares the reasoning behind the decision to create a unique same sex "marriage" and the UK approach of establishing a "civil partnership" institution that is analogous to marriage.

AB - Considers the implications of the ambiguity in the South African Civil Union Act 2006 concerning: (1) whether the form of "marriage" that it introduces, which is available to both opposite and same sex couples, is the same as the common law or the customary law marriage institutions; and (2) the substantive nature of the distinction between its "marriage" and "civil partnership" institutions. Suggests that the real distinction is between same and opposite sex civil unions, and compares the reasoning behind the decision to create a unique same sex "marriage" and the UK approach of establishing a "civil partnership" institution that is analogous to marriage.

KW - civil partnerships

KW - South Africa

KW - Scotland

KW - same sex partners

KW - marriage

KW - comparative law

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 21

EP - 41

JO - Juridical Review

JF - Juridical Review

SN - 0022-6785

IS - 1

ER -