Social impact bonds: can private finance rescue public programs?

Christine Cooper, Cameron Graham, Brendan O’Dwyer

Research output: Contribution to conference › Paper

Abstract

This paper examines the recent phenomenon of social impact bonds as a means of financing public programmes, particularly the implications of this innovation for accounting and accountability. Social impact bonds are an attempt to recruit private sector funds to pay for social programmes. These funds are structured as a bond, with a return on investment paid for by the state, but conditional on the programme attaining certain specified performance goals. Typically, if these goals are not met, the state does not pay the bond interest and the amount invested is lost. This financial innovation carries with it numerous assumptions about the role of the state, and can be regarded as a new attempt to manage the roles of the state, the private sector, and the charitable sector under neoliberalism. The mechanism of social impact bonds explicitly relies on performance measurement and financial incentives to arrange and demonstrate accountability for social outcomes. As such, it is a potentially powerful and potentially problematic use of accounting to enact government policy. This paper examines a specific, early case in which St. Mungo’s, a London-based charitable foundation, has undertaken to alleviate homelessness in the United Kingdom. The case is interesting because the problem of homelessness is traditionally regarded as somewhat intransigent, so the success of the new financing initiative relies on the ability of private finance to increase the incentives for innovation within the charitable sector, and the ability of the charitable sector to demonstrate their performance through accounting measures.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages58
Publication statusPublished - 2013
EventAccounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions" - Galway, Ireland
Duration: 22 Sep 2013 → 25 Sep 2013

Conference

ConferenceAccounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions"
CountryIreland
City Galway
Period22/09/13 → 25/09/13

Fingerprint

Private finance
Role of the state
Innovation
Financing
Private sector
Homelessness
Accountability
Government policy
Performance measurement
Return on investment
Social programs
Incentives
Neoliberalism
Financial incentives
Financial innovation

Keywords

  • social impact bonds
  • homelessness
  • social programmes
  • public sector
  • not-for-profit sector
  • funding
  • finance

Cite this

Cooper, C., Graham, C., & O’Dwyer, B. (2013). Social impact bonds: can private finance rescue public programs?. Paper presented at Accounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions" , Galway, Ireland.
Cooper, Christine ; Graham, Cameron ; O’Dwyer, Brendan . / Social impact bonds : can private finance rescue public programs?. Paper presented at Accounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions" , Galway, Ireland.58 p.
@conference{a376dd3045f84b6ba440713a63130edc,
title = "Social impact bonds: can private finance rescue public programs?",
abstract = "This paper examines the recent phenomenon of social impact bonds as a means of financing public programmes, particularly the implications of this innovation for accounting and accountability. Social impact bonds are an attempt to recruit private sector funds to pay for social programmes. These funds are structured as a bond, with a return on investment paid for by the state, but conditional on the programme attaining certain specified performance goals. Typically, if these goals are not met, the state does not pay the bond interest and the amount invested is lost. This financial innovation carries with it numerous assumptions about the role of the state, and can be regarded as a new attempt to manage the roles of the state, the private sector, and the charitable sector under neoliberalism. The mechanism of social impact bonds explicitly relies on performance measurement and financial incentives to arrange and demonstrate accountability for social outcomes. As such, it is a potentially powerful and potentially problematic use of accounting to enact government policy. This paper examines a specific, early case in which St. Mungo’s, a London-based charitable foundation, has undertaken to alleviate homelessness in the United Kingdom. The case is interesting because the problem of homelessness is traditionally regarded as somewhat intransigent, so the success of the new financing initiative relies on the ability of private finance to increase the incentives for innovation within the charitable sector, and the ability of the charitable sector to demonstrate their performance through accounting measures.",
keywords = "social impact bonds, homelessness, social programmes, public sector, not-for-profit sector, funding, finance",
author = "Christine Cooper and Cameron Graham and Brendan O’Dwyer",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
note = "Accounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions{"} ; Conference date: 22-09-2013 Through 25-09-2013",

}

Cooper, C, Graham, C & O’Dwyer, B 2013, 'Social impact bonds: can private finance rescue public programs?' Paper presented at Accounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions" , Galway, Ireland, 22/09/13 - 25/09/13, .

Social impact bonds : can private finance rescue public programs? / Cooper, Christine; Graham, Cameron; O’Dwyer, Brendan .

2013. Paper presented at Accounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions" , Galway, Ireland.

Research output: Contribution to conference › Paper

TY - CONF

T1 - Social impact bonds

T2 - can private finance rescue public programs?

AU - Cooper, Christine

AU - Graham, Cameron

AU - O’Dwyer, Brendan

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This paper examines the recent phenomenon of social impact bonds as a means of financing public programmes, particularly the implications of this innovation for accounting and accountability. Social impact bonds are an attempt to recruit private sector funds to pay for social programmes. These funds are structured as a bond, with a return on investment paid for by the state, but conditional on the programme attaining certain specified performance goals. Typically, if these goals are not met, the state does not pay the bond interest and the amount invested is lost. This financial innovation carries with it numerous assumptions about the role of the state, and can be regarded as a new attempt to manage the roles of the state, the private sector, and the charitable sector under neoliberalism. The mechanism of social impact bonds explicitly relies on performance measurement and financial incentives to arrange and demonstrate accountability for social outcomes. As such, it is a potentially powerful and potentially problematic use of accounting to enact government policy. This paper examines a specific, early case in which St. Mungo’s, a London-based charitable foundation, has undertaken to alleviate homelessness in the United Kingdom. The case is interesting because the problem of homelessness is traditionally regarded as somewhat intransigent, so the success of the new financing initiative relies on the ability of private finance to increase the incentives for innovation within the charitable sector, and the ability of the charitable sector to demonstrate their performance through accounting measures.

AB - This paper examines the recent phenomenon of social impact bonds as a means of financing public programmes, particularly the implications of this innovation for accounting and accountability. Social impact bonds are an attempt to recruit private sector funds to pay for social programmes. These funds are structured as a bond, with a return on investment paid for by the state, but conditional on the programme attaining certain specified performance goals. Typically, if these goals are not met, the state does not pay the bond interest and the amount invested is lost. This financial innovation carries with it numerous assumptions about the role of the state, and can be regarded as a new attempt to manage the roles of the state, the private sector, and the charitable sector under neoliberalism. The mechanism of social impact bonds explicitly relies on performance measurement and financial incentives to arrange and demonstrate accountability for social outcomes. As such, it is a potentially powerful and potentially problematic use of accounting to enact government policy. This paper examines a specific, early case in which St. Mungo’s, a London-based charitable foundation, has undertaken to alleviate homelessness in the United Kingdom. The case is interesting because the problem of homelessness is traditionally regarded as somewhat intransigent, so the success of the new financing initiative relies on the ability of private finance to increase the incentives for innovation within the charitable sector, and the ability of the charitable sector to demonstrate their performance through accounting measures.

KW - social impact bonds

KW - homelessness

KW - social programmes

KW - public sector

KW - not-for-profit sector

KW - funding

KW - finance

M3 - Paper

ER -

Cooper C, Graham C, O’Dwyer B. Social impact bonds: can private finance rescue public programs?. 2013. Paper presented at Accounting, Organizations and Society Conference on “Performing Business and Social Innovation through Accounting Inscriptions" , Galway, Ireland.

Access to Document