‘Sensible girls’ and ‘silly boys’

what do teachers need to know about gender?

Jae Major, Ninetta Santoro

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Much to the consternation of many feminist researchers, teacher education programs have become largely silent about gender and the influence of gender discourses on teaching and learning. Stereotypical views of males and females can dominate teachers’ views of boys and girls, and they can be seen as essentially different—as binary opposites. This has implications for identity construction of children as they take up or resist the identity positions made available to them by the teacher. In this paper, the intersection of gender with culture/ethnicity is examined in the context of identity construction. Classroom-based data are considered in relation to a ‘sensible girls/silly boys’ binary, and the teacher’s positioning of a Chinese heritage boy and Korean heritage girl in a New Zealand primary classroom. We suggest that the teacher’s discursive practices based on unexamined assumptions, limited the identity positions available to the children in relation to gender and culture. We argue that teacher education has an important role to play in preparing teachers with a critical orientation towards dominant gender discourses, and an understanding of the intersection of gender with other discourses, such as culture and ethnicity.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages14
JournalAustralian Educational Researcher
Early online date28 Aug 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

gender
teacher
discourse
ethnicity
classroom
education
New Zealand
Teaching
learning

Keywords

  • identity
  • gender
  • teacher education
  • primary education
  • diversity
  • sensible girls
  • silly boys
  • teachers

Cite this

@article{f150c30a72f34eb293c1d9f7ba688f0c,
title = "‘Sensible girls’ and ‘silly boys’: what do teachers need to know about gender?",
abstract = "Much to the consternation of many feminist researchers, teacher education programs have become largely silent about gender and the influence of gender discourses on teaching and learning. Stereotypical views of males and females can dominate teachers’ views of boys and girls, and they can be seen as essentially different—as binary opposites. This has implications for identity construction of children as they take up or resist the identity positions made available to them by the teacher. In this paper, the intersection of gender with culture/ethnicity is examined in the context of identity construction. Classroom-based data are considered in relation to a ‘sensible girls/silly boys’ binary, and the teacher’s positioning of a Chinese heritage boy and Korean heritage girl in a New Zealand primary classroom. We suggest that the teacher’s discursive practices based on unexamined assumptions, limited the identity positions available to the children in relation to gender and culture. We argue that teacher education has an important role to play in preparing teachers with a critical orientation towards dominant gender discourses, and an understanding of the intersection of gender with other discourses, such as culture and ethnicity.",
keywords = "identity, gender, teacher education, primary education, diversity, sensible girls, silly boys, teachers",
author = "Jae Major and Ninetta Santoro",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1007/s13384-013-0121-0",
language = "English",
journal = "Australian Educational Researcher",
issn = "0311-6999",

}

‘Sensible girls’ and ‘silly boys’ : what do teachers need to know about gender? / Major, Jae; Santoro, Ninetta.

In: Australian Educational Researcher, 2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - ‘Sensible girls’ and ‘silly boys’

T2 - what do teachers need to know about gender?

AU - Major, Jae

AU - Santoro, Ninetta

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Much to the consternation of many feminist researchers, teacher education programs have become largely silent about gender and the influence of gender discourses on teaching and learning. Stereotypical views of males and females can dominate teachers’ views of boys and girls, and they can be seen as essentially different—as binary opposites. This has implications for identity construction of children as they take up or resist the identity positions made available to them by the teacher. In this paper, the intersection of gender with culture/ethnicity is examined in the context of identity construction. Classroom-based data are considered in relation to a ‘sensible girls/silly boys’ binary, and the teacher’s positioning of a Chinese heritage boy and Korean heritage girl in a New Zealand primary classroom. We suggest that the teacher’s discursive practices based on unexamined assumptions, limited the identity positions available to the children in relation to gender and culture. We argue that teacher education has an important role to play in preparing teachers with a critical orientation towards dominant gender discourses, and an understanding of the intersection of gender with other discourses, such as culture and ethnicity.

AB - Much to the consternation of many feminist researchers, teacher education programs have become largely silent about gender and the influence of gender discourses on teaching and learning. Stereotypical views of males and females can dominate teachers’ views of boys and girls, and they can be seen as essentially different—as binary opposites. This has implications for identity construction of children as they take up or resist the identity positions made available to them by the teacher. In this paper, the intersection of gender with culture/ethnicity is examined in the context of identity construction. Classroom-based data are considered in relation to a ‘sensible girls/silly boys’ binary, and the teacher’s positioning of a Chinese heritage boy and Korean heritage girl in a New Zealand primary classroom. We suggest that the teacher’s discursive practices based on unexamined assumptions, limited the identity positions available to the children in relation to gender and culture. We argue that teacher education has an important role to play in preparing teachers with a critical orientation towards dominant gender discourses, and an understanding of the intersection of gender with other discourses, such as culture and ethnicity.

KW - identity

KW - gender

KW - teacher education

KW - primary education

KW - diversity

KW - sensible girls

KW - silly boys

KW - teachers

U2 - 10.1007/s13384-013-0121-0

DO - 10.1007/s13384-013-0121-0

M3 - Article

JO - Australian Educational Researcher

JF - Australian Educational Researcher

SN - 0311-6999

ER -