Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans

in, but not of Europe

Derek Bryce, Senija Causevic

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

143 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Normalising subjectivities of ‘Europeanness’ and ‘Westernness’ have effects on the interpretation and consumption of cultural heritage sites in non-Western contexts. Here we examine the liminal space of the ‘post-Ottoman’ West Balkans, a European region with a significant built heritage and contemporary social legacy reflecting the c.500 year rule of the Muslim Ottoman dynasty where large numbers of people converted voluntarily to Islam but in which a syncretic system for the legal toleration and recognition of Christianity and Judaism was also implemented. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH), Republic of Macedonia (Macedonia) and Albania are selected for contextual study in the West Balkans given that their social complexion is perhaps most obviously a representation of that syncretic legacy and because of their concentration of extant Ottoman heritage sites presentenced to the market. We note first that these countries’ heritage and tourism sectors anticipate and to some extent modify their interpretation to accommodate ‘Western’ consumers affectation of ‘surprise’ and ‘delight’ at the region’s religious diversity, constructing it in binary terms as a ‘remarkable’ crossroads between ‘West/East’ or ‘Christendom/Islam’. We then note occasional counter-discursive interventions by heritage practitioners to offer consumers an interpretive framework in which the syncretic legacy of the Ottoman period is an unremarkable consequence of contingent regional history. To understand why Ottoman heritage is often understood to be in but not of Europe, our analysis brings together and develops recent ‘Post-Saidian’ scholarship which interrogates ‘Europe’s’ discursive erasure of its Ottoman-Islamic-Oriental ‘self’ as well as recent work on the particularities of the syncretic Ottoman mode of social organisation in Europe and its legacy.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages23
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2015
EventUnsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus - University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
Duration: 24 Apr 201525 Apr 2015

Conference

ConferenceUnsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus
CountryCanada
CityEdmonton
Period24/04/1525/04/15

Fingerprint

Balkans
Heritage
Islam
Heritage Sites
Macedonia
Discursive
Albania
Surprise
Subjectivity
Muslims
European regions
Tourism sector
Interpretive
Cultural heritage
Social organization
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Judaism
Christianity
Tourism
Contextual

Keywords

  • heritage
  • Ottoman
  • Islam
  • Europe
  • heritage marketing

Cite this

Bryce, D., & Causevic, S. (2015). Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans: in, but not of Europe. Paper presented at Unsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus, Edmonton, Canada.
Bryce, Derek ; Causevic, Senija. / Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans : in, but not of Europe. Paper presented at Unsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus, Edmonton, Canada.23 p.
@conference{04869dfe35f44a0e98812fec55d7db98,
title = "Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans: in, but not of Europe",
abstract = "Normalising subjectivities of ‘Europeanness’ and ‘Westernness’ have effects on the interpretation and consumption of cultural heritage sites in non-Western contexts. Here we examine the liminal space of the ‘post-Ottoman’ West Balkans, a European region with a significant built heritage and contemporary social legacy reflecting the c.500 year rule of the Muslim Ottoman dynasty where large numbers of people converted voluntarily to Islam but in which a syncretic system for the legal toleration and recognition of Christianity and Judaism was also implemented. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH), Republic of Macedonia (Macedonia) and Albania are selected for contextual study in the West Balkans given that their social complexion is perhaps most obviously a representation of that syncretic legacy and because of their concentration of extant Ottoman heritage sites presentenced to the market. We note first that these countries’ heritage and tourism sectors anticipate and to some extent modify their interpretation to accommodate ‘Western’ consumers affectation of ‘surprise’ and ‘delight’ at the region’s religious diversity, constructing it in binary terms as a ‘remarkable’ crossroads between ‘West/East’ or ‘Christendom/Islam’. We then note occasional counter-discursive interventions by heritage practitioners to offer consumers an interpretive framework in which the syncretic legacy of the Ottoman period is an unremarkable consequence of contingent regional history. To understand why Ottoman heritage is often understood to be in but not of Europe, our analysis brings together and develops recent ‘Post-Saidian’ scholarship which interrogates ‘Europe’s’ discursive erasure of its Ottoman-Islamic-Oriental ‘self’ as well as recent work on the particularities of the syncretic Ottoman mode of social organisation in Europe and its legacy.",
keywords = "heritage, Ottoman, Islam, Europe, heritage marketing",
author = "Derek Bryce and Senija Causevic",
year = "2015",
month = "4",
day = "1",
language = "English",
note = "Unsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus ; Conference date: 24-04-2015 Through 25-04-2015",

}

Bryce, D & Causevic, S 2015, 'Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans: in, but not of Europe' Paper presented at Unsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus, Edmonton, Canada, 24/04/15 - 25/04/15, .

Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans : in, but not of Europe. / Bryce, Derek; Causevic, Senija.

2015. Paper presented at Unsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus, Edmonton, Canada.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans

T2 - in, but not of Europe

AU - Bryce, Derek

AU - Causevic, Senija

PY - 2015/4/1

Y1 - 2015/4/1

N2 - Normalising subjectivities of ‘Europeanness’ and ‘Westernness’ have effects on the interpretation and consumption of cultural heritage sites in non-Western contexts. Here we examine the liminal space of the ‘post-Ottoman’ West Balkans, a European region with a significant built heritage and contemporary social legacy reflecting the c.500 year rule of the Muslim Ottoman dynasty where large numbers of people converted voluntarily to Islam but in which a syncretic system for the legal toleration and recognition of Christianity and Judaism was also implemented. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH), Republic of Macedonia (Macedonia) and Albania are selected for contextual study in the West Balkans given that their social complexion is perhaps most obviously a representation of that syncretic legacy and because of their concentration of extant Ottoman heritage sites presentenced to the market. We note first that these countries’ heritage and tourism sectors anticipate and to some extent modify their interpretation to accommodate ‘Western’ consumers affectation of ‘surprise’ and ‘delight’ at the region’s religious diversity, constructing it in binary terms as a ‘remarkable’ crossroads between ‘West/East’ or ‘Christendom/Islam’. We then note occasional counter-discursive interventions by heritage practitioners to offer consumers an interpretive framework in which the syncretic legacy of the Ottoman period is an unremarkable consequence of contingent regional history. To understand why Ottoman heritage is often understood to be in but not of Europe, our analysis brings together and develops recent ‘Post-Saidian’ scholarship which interrogates ‘Europe’s’ discursive erasure of its Ottoman-Islamic-Oriental ‘self’ as well as recent work on the particularities of the syncretic Ottoman mode of social organisation in Europe and its legacy.

AB - Normalising subjectivities of ‘Europeanness’ and ‘Westernness’ have effects on the interpretation and consumption of cultural heritage sites in non-Western contexts. Here we examine the liminal space of the ‘post-Ottoman’ West Balkans, a European region with a significant built heritage and contemporary social legacy reflecting the c.500 year rule of the Muslim Ottoman dynasty where large numbers of people converted voluntarily to Islam but in which a syncretic system for the legal toleration and recognition of Christianity and Judaism was also implemented. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH), Republic of Macedonia (Macedonia) and Albania are selected for contextual study in the West Balkans given that their social complexion is perhaps most obviously a representation of that syncretic legacy and because of their concentration of extant Ottoman heritage sites presentenced to the market. We note first that these countries’ heritage and tourism sectors anticipate and to some extent modify their interpretation to accommodate ‘Western’ consumers affectation of ‘surprise’ and ‘delight’ at the region’s religious diversity, constructing it in binary terms as a ‘remarkable’ crossroads between ‘West/East’ or ‘Christendom/Islam’. We then note occasional counter-discursive interventions by heritage practitioners to offer consumers an interpretive framework in which the syncretic legacy of the Ottoman period is an unremarkable consequence of contingent regional history. To understand why Ottoman heritage is often understood to be in but not of Europe, our analysis brings together and develops recent ‘Post-Saidian’ scholarship which interrogates ‘Europe’s’ discursive erasure of its Ottoman-Islamic-Oriental ‘self’ as well as recent work on the particularities of the syncretic Ottoman mode of social organisation in Europe and its legacy.

KW - heritage

KW - Ottoman

KW - Islam

KW - Europe

KW - heritage marketing

UR - http://ucmconf.com/program/

M3 - Paper

ER -

Bryce D, Causevic S. Selling heritage in the post-Ottoman Balkans: in, but not of Europe. 2015. Paper presented at Unsettling Colonial Modernity: Islamicate contexts in focus, Edmonton, Canada.