Selective decisions: challenging orthodox analyses of the hiring process

Harvie Ramsay, Dora Scholarios

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Employee recruitment and selection decisions are increasingly framed in terms of explanatory variables and interactions that span multiple levels of analysis. This paper reviews the gradual transition in thinking from predominantly micro-level explanations, to frameworks more accepting of the importance of both micro- and macro-level explanations. The latter accommodate the influences of and interactions between, for example, the individual characteristics of candidates; the cognitive processes of key actors or decision-makers; organisational characteristics; collective processes; and wider environmental contextual factors which constrain and shape an organisation’s or manager’s decision alternatives. The result is more complex cross-level theorising about the hiring process. The paper also goes beyond cross-level interactions between multiple variables in considering selection as a social relational phenomenon. Meso-level theories present epistemological alternatives to the dominant micro-level research tradition in selection and potentially more parsimonious and powerful micro–macro bridging concepts than cross-level interactionist perspectives. It is argued that cross-disciplinary perspectives, although still problematic, are valuable additions to the individualistic paradigm which is conventionally used to understand employee recruitment and selection.
LanguageEnglish
Pages63-89
Number of pages27
JournalInternational Journal of Management Reviews
Volume1
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 1999

Fingerprint

Macros
Personnel
Managers
Interaction
Hiring
Employees
Recruitment and selection
Levels of analysis
Theorizing
Paradigm
Contextual factors
Organizational characteristics
Decision maker
Individual characteristics
Cognitive processes

Keywords

  • selection
  • hiring process
  • employee recruitment

Cite this

@article{017d7cf6aa6e400db53781318d5c02ed,
title = "Selective decisions: challenging orthodox analyses of the hiring process",
abstract = "Employee recruitment and selection decisions are increasingly framed in terms of explanatory variables and interactions that span multiple levels of analysis. This paper reviews the gradual transition in thinking from predominantly micro-level explanations, to frameworks more accepting of the importance of both micro- and macro-level explanations. The latter accommodate the influences of and interactions between, for example, the individual characteristics of candidates; the cognitive processes of key actors or decision-makers; organisational characteristics; collective processes; and wider environmental contextual factors which constrain and shape an organisation’s or manager’s decision alternatives. The result is more complex cross-level theorising about the hiring process. The paper also goes beyond cross-level interactions between multiple variables in considering selection as a social relational phenomenon. Meso-level theories present epistemological alternatives to the dominant micro-level research tradition in selection and potentially more parsimonious and powerful micro–macro bridging concepts than cross-level interactionist perspectives. It is argued that cross-disciplinary perspectives, although still problematic, are valuable additions to the individualistic paradigm which is conventionally used to understand employee recruitment and selection.",
keywords = "selection, hiring process, employee recruitment",
author = "Harvie Ramsay and Dora Scholarios",
year = "1999",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1111/1468-2370.00005",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "63--89",
journal = "International Journal of Management Reviews",
issn = "1460-8545",
number = "1",

}

Selective decisions : challenging orthodox analyses of the hiring process. / Ramsay, Harvie; Scholarios, Dora.

In: International Journal of Management Reviews, Vol. 1, No. 1, 03.1999, p. 63-89.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Selective decisions

T2 - International Journal of Management Reviews

AU - Ramsay, Harvie

AU - Scholarios, Dora

PY - 1999/3

Y1 - 1999/3

N2 - Employee recruitment and selection decisions are increasingly framed in terms of explanatory variables and interactions that span multiple levels of analysis. This paper reviews the gradual transition in thinking from predominantly micro-level explanations, to frameworks more accepting of the importance of both micro- and macro-level explanations. The latter accommodate the influences of and interactions between, for example, the individual characteristics of candidates; the cognitive processes of key actors or decision-makers; organisational characteristics; collective processes; and wider environmental contextual factors which constrain and shape an organisation’s or manager’s decision alternatives. The result is more complex cross-level theorising about the hiring process. The paper also goes beyond cross-level interactions between multiple variables in considering selection as a social relational phenomenon. Meso-level theories present epistemological alternatives to the dominant micro-level research tradition in selection and potentially more parsimonious and powerful micro–macro bridging concepts than cross-level interactionist perspectives. It is argued that cross-disciplinary perspectives, although still problematic, are valuable additions to the individualistic paradigm which is conventionally used to understand employee recruitment and selection.

AB - Employee recruitment and selection decisions are increasingly framed in terms of explanatory variables and interactions that span multiple levels of analysis. This paper reviews the gradual transition in thinking from predominantly micro-level explanations, to frameworks more accepting of the importance of both micro- and macro-level explanations. The latter accommodate the influences of and interactions between, for example, the individual characteristics of candidates; the cognitive processes of key actors or decision-makers; organisational characteristics; collective processes; and wider environmental contextual factors which constrain and shape an organisation’s or manager’s decision alternatives. The result is more complex cross-level theorising about the hiring process. The paper also goes beyond cross-level interactions between multiple variables in considering selection as a social relational phenomenon. Meso-level theories present epistemological alternatives to the dominant micro-level research tradition in selection and potentially more parsimonious and powerful micro–macro bridging concepts than cross-level interactionist perspectives. It is argued that cross-disciplinary perspectives, although still problematic, are valuable additions to the individualistic paradigm which is conventionally used to understand employee recruitment and selection.

KW - selection

KW - hiring process

KW - employee recruitment

U2 - 10.1111/1468-2370.00005

DO - 10.1111/1468-2370.00005

M3 - Article

VL - 1

SP - 63

EP - 89

JO - International Journal of Management Reviews

JF - International Journal of Management Reviews

SN - 1460-8545

IS - 1

ER -