Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Abstract

    In 1986 John Veit-Wilson launched a fierce attack on what he regarded as the misrepresentation of Seebohm Rowntree’s original conception of the meaning of poverty. He argued that Rowntree’s critics had labelled him unfairly as the architect of an ‘absolute’ conception of poverty, and that Rowntree’s own conception of poverty was far more ‘relative’ than his critics allowed (Veit-Wilson 1986a). This view has rapidly assumed the status of a new orthodoxy. When David Englander and Rosemary O’Day reprinted Veit-Wilson’s essay in 1995, they explained that ‘Veit-Wilson’s contribution shows that Rowntree’s early views and methods have been widely misunderstood ... and ... necessitates a reconsideration of Rowntree’s position, which would show Townsend’s achievement as a paradigmatic shift ... from relativistic models based on standards prescribed by expert observers to relativistic models based on standards derived from the whole population by social surveys (Englander and O’Day 1995: 36).
    LanguageEnglish
    Title of host publicationGetting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree
    EditorsJonathan Bradshaw, Roy Sainsbury
    Place of PublicationFarnham
    Pages60-84
    Number of pages25
    Publication statusPublished - Oct 2000

    Publication series

    NameStudies in Cash & Care
    PublisherAshgate

    Fingerprint

    poverty
    critic
    architect
    expert

    Keywords

    • seebohm rowntree
    • measurement
    • poverty
    • 1899-1951

    Cite this

    Harris, B. (2000). Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951. In J. Bradshaw, & R. Sainsbury (Eds.), Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree (pp. 60-84). (Studies in Cash & Care). Farnham.
    Harris, Bernard. / Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951. Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree . editor / Jonathan Bradshaw ; Roy Sainsbury. Farnham, 2000. pp. 60-84 (Studies in Cash & Care).
    @inbook{06a75dac779e4c93aedcff46bf100cbf,
    title = "Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951",
    abstract = "In 1986 John Veit-Wilson launched a fierce attack on what he regarded as the misrepresentation of Seebohm Rowntree’s original conception of the meaning of poverty. He argued that Rowntree’s critics had labelled him unfairly as the architect of an ‘absolute’ conception of poverty, and that Rowntree’s own conception of poverty was far more ‘relative’ than his critics allowed (Veit-Wilson 1986a). This view has rapidly assumed the status of a new orthodoxy. When David Englander and Rosemary O’Day reprinted Veit-Wilson’s essay in 1995, they explained that ‘Veit-Wilson’s contribution shows that Rowntree’s early views and methods have been widely misunderstood ... and ... necessitates a reconsideration of Rowntree’s position, which would show Townsend’s achievement as a paradigmatic shift ... from relativistic models based on standards prescribed by expert observers to relativistic models based on standards derived from the whole population by social surveys (Englander and O’Day 1995: 36).",
    keywords = "seebohm rowntree, measurement, poverty, 1899-1951",
    author = "Bernard Harris",
    year = "2000",
    month = "10",
    language = "English",
    isbn = "9780754612896",
    series = "Studies in Cash & Care",
    publisher = "Ashgate",
    pages = "60--84",
    editor = "Bradshaw, {Jonathan } and Sainsbury, {Roy }",
    booktitle = "Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree",

    }

    Harris, B 2000, Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951. in J Bradshaw & R Sainsbury (eds), Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree . Studies in Cash & Care, Farnham, pp. 60-84.

    Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951. / Harris, Bernard.

    Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree . ed. / Jonathan Bradshaw; Roy Sainsbury. Farnham, 2000. p. 60-84 (Studies in Cash & Care).

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    TY - CHAP

    T1 - Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951

    AU - Harris, Bernard

    PY - 2000/10

    Y1 - 2000/10

    N2 - In 1986 John Veit-Wilson launched a fierce attack on what he regarded as the misrepresentation of Seebohm Rowntree’s original conception of the meaning of poverty. He argued that Rowntree’s critics had labelled him unfairly as the architect of an ‘absolute’ conception of poverty, and that Rowntree’s own conception of poverty was far more ‘relative’ than his critics allowed (Veit-Wilson 1986a). This view has rapidly assumed the status of a new orthodoxy. When David Englander and Rosemary O’Day reprinted Veit-Wilson’s essay in 1995, they explained that ‘Veit-Wilson’s contribution shows that Rowntree’s early views and methods have been widely misunderstood ... and ... necessitates a reconsideration of Rowntree’s position, which would show Townsend’s achievement as a paradigmatic shift ... from relativistic models based on standards prescribed by expert observers to relativistic models based on standards derived from the whole population by social surveys (Englander and O’Day 1995: 36).

    AB - In 1986 John Veit-Wilson launched a fierce attack on what he regarded as the misrepresentation of Seebohm Rowntree’s original conception of the meaning of poverty. He argued that Rowntree’s critics had labelled him unfairly as the architect of an ‘absolute’ conception of poverty, and that Rowntree’s own conception of poverty was far more ‘relative’ than his critics allowed (Veit-Wilson 1986a). This view has rapidly assumed the status of a new orthodoxy. When David Englander and Rosemary O’Day reprinted Veit-Wilson’s essay in 1995, they explained that ‘Veit-Wilson’s contribution shows that Rowntree’s early views and methods have been widely misunderstood ... and ... necessitates a reconsideration of Rowntree’s position, which would show Townsend’s achievement as a paradigmatic shift ... from relativistic models based on standards prescribed by expert observers to relativistic models based on standards derived from the whole population by social surveys (Englander and O’Day 1995: 36).

    KW - seebohm rowntree

    KW - measurement

    KW - poverty

    KW - 1899-1951

    UR - http://www.ashgate.com/isbn/9780754612896

    M3 - Chapter

    SN - 9780754612896

    T3 - Studies in Cash & Care

    SP - 60

    EP - 84

    BT - Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree

    A2 - Bradshaw, Jonathan

    A2 - Sainsbury, Roy

    CY - Farnham

    ER -

    Harris B. Seebohm Rowntree and the measurement of poverty, 1899-1951. In Bradshaw J, Sainsbury R, editors, Getting the Measure of Poverty: The Early Legacy of Seebohm Rowntree . Farnham. 2000. p. 60-84. (Studies in Cash & Care).