Scotland: birthplace of passive revolution

Neil Davidson

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    8 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    As far as the bourgeois revolutions were concerned, Antonio Gramsci used the term ‘passive revolution’ to contrast the form taken by the Italian Risorgimento and comparable ‘revolutions from above’ with that of the French Revolution, where the main dynamic had come ‘from below’.1 The key era of passive revolution in this sense lies between 1859 and 1871. From the closing decades of the 17th century, however, a different set of circumstances had already led to a comparable revolution in Scotland which, although little known, is one of the decisive turning points for the transition in Western Europe. The context for this transformation was the global inter-systemic conflict between England and France, in which Scotland was one of the main battlefields. The process had four key moments: first, a subsistence crisis at home and imperial failure abroad, the combined effects of which sent Scottish capitalist development into reverse. Second, and in response to the first, was the Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707, which dissolved the Scottish state while leaving the feudal jurisdictions of the Scottish lords intact. Third, the failure of a French-backed attempt at counter-revolution in 1745—6, which led to the military suppression and juridical abolition of feudal social relations north of the border; and fourth, the imposition of capitalist social relations in the Scottish countryside by an alliance of former feudal landlords, ‘improving’ tenant farmers and Enlightenment intellectuals, who then theorised the entire process in their discussion of ‘civil society’
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages343-359
    Number of pages17
    JournalCapital and Class
    Volume34
    Issue number3
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Oct 2010

    Fingerprint

    Social Relations
    French revolution
    landlord
    suppression
    intellectual
    Western Europe
    jurisdiction
    civil society
    farmer
    Military
    France
    Revolution
    Scotland
    Place of Birth
    Social relations
    Counter-revolution
    Countryside
    Jurisdiction
    Antonio Gramsci
    Turning Point

    Keywords

    • revolution
    • Scotland
    • Antonio Gramsci
    • Marx
    • Engel
    • feudal self-transformation
    • scottish enlightenment
    • bourgeois revolution
    • agrarian reform

    Cite this

    Davidson, Neil. / Scotland : birthplace of passive revolution. In: Capital and Class. 2010 ; Vol. 34, No. 3. pp. 343-359.
    @article{1e81426a9208494aa9fd3d8616c2f395,
    title = "Scotland: birthplace of passive revolution",
    abstract = "As far as the bourgeois revolutions were concerned, Antonio Gramsci used the term ‘passive revolution’ to contrast the form taken by the Italian Risorgimento and comparable ‘revolutions from above’ with that of the French Revolution, where the main dynamic had come ‘from below’.1 The key era of passive revolution in this sense lies between 1859 and 1871. From the closing decades of the 17th century, however, a different set of circumstances had already led to a comparable revolution in Scotland which, although little known, is one of the decisive turning points for the transition in Western Europe. The context for this transformation was the global inter-systemic conflict between England and France, in which Scotland was one of the main battlefields. The process had four key moments: first, a subsistence crisis at home and imperial failure abroad, the combined effects of which sent Scottish capitalist development into reverse. Second, and in response to the first, was the Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707, which dissolved the Scottish state while leaving the feudal jurisdictions of the Scottish lords intact. Third, the failure of a French-backed attempt at counter-revolution in 1745—6, which led to the military suppression and juridical abolition of feudal social relations north of the border; and fourth, the imposition of capitalist social relations in the Scottish countryside by an alliance of former feudal landlords, ‘improving’ tenant farmers and Enlightenment intellectuals, who then theorised the entire process in their discussion of ‘civil society’",
    keywords = "revolution, Scotland, Antonio Gramsci, Marx, Engel, feudal self-transformation , scottish enlightenment, bourgeois revolution, agrarian reform",
    author = "Neil Davidson",
    year = "2010",
    month = "10",
    doi = "10.1177/0309816810378158",
    language = "English",
    volume = "34",
    pages = "343--359",
    journal = "Capital and Class",
    issn = "0309-8168",
    number = "3",

    }

    Scotland : birthplace of passive revolution. / Davidson, Neil.

    In: Capital and Class, Vol. 34, No. 3, 10.2010, p. 343-359.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Scotland

    T2 - Capital and Class

    AU - Davidson, Neil

    PY - 2010/10

    Y1 - 2010/10

    N2 - As far as the bourgeois revolutions were concerned, Antonio Gramsci used the term ‘passive revolution’ to contrast the form taken by the Italian Risorgimento and comparable ‘revolutions from above’ with that of the French Revolution, where the main dynamic had come ‘from below’.1 The key era of passive revolution in this sense lies between 1859 and 1871. From the closing decades of the 17th century, however, a different set of circumstances had already led to a comparable revolution in Scotland which, although little known, is one of the decisive turning points for the transition in Western Europe. The context for this transformation was the global inter-systemic conflict between England and France, in which Scotland was one of the main battlefields. The process had four key moments: first, a subsistence crisis at home and imperial failure abroad, the combined effects of which sent Scottish capitalist development into reverse. Second, and in response to the first, was the Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707, which dissolved the Scottish state while leaving the feudal jurisdictions of the Scottish lords intact. Third, the failure of a French-backed attempt at counter-revolution in 1745—6, which led to the military suppression and juridical abolition of feudal social relations north of the border; and fourth, the imposition of capitalist social relations in the Scottish countryside by an alliance of former feudal landlords, ‘improving’ tenant farmers and Enlightenment intellectuals, who then theorised the entire process in their discussion of ‘civil society’

    AB - As far as the bourgeois revolutions were concerned, Antonio Gramsci used the term ‘passive revolution’ to contrast the form taken by the Italian Risorgimento and comparable ‘revolutions from above’ with that of the French Revolution, where the main dynamic had come ‘from below’.1 The key era of passive revolution in this sense lies between 1859 and 1871. From the closing decades of the 17th century, however, a different set of circumstances had already led to a comparable revolution in Scotland which, although little known, is one of the decisive turning points for the transition in Western Europe. The context for this transformation was the global inter-systemic conflict between England and France, in which Scotland was one of the main battlefields. The process had four key moments: first, a subsistence crisis at home and imperial failure abroad, the combined effects of which sent Scottish capitalist development into reverse. Second, and in response to the first, was the Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707, which dissolved the Scottish state while leaving the feudal jurisdictions of the Scottish lords intact. Third, the failure of a French-backed attempt at counter-revolution in 1745—6, which led to the military suppression and juridical abolition of feudal social relations north of the border; and fourth, the imposition of capitalist social relations in the Scottish countryside by an alliance of former feudal landlords, ‘improving’ tenant farmers and Enlightenment intellectuals, who then theorised the entire process in their discussion of ‘civil society’

    KW - revolution

    KW - Scotland

    KW - Antonio Gramsci

    KW - Marx

    KW - Engel

    KW - feudal self-transformation

    KW - scottish enlightenment

    KW - bourgeois revolution

    KW - agrarian reform

    UR - http://www.cseweb.org.uk/index.html

    U2 - 10.1177/0309816810378158

    DO - 10.1177/0309816810378158

    M3 - Article

    VL - 34

    SP - 343

    EP - 359

    JO - Capital and Class

    JF - Capital and Class

    SN - 0309-8168

    IS - 3

    ER -