Romantic horizons: antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Scotland’s tourist industry relies on the currency of essentialised, and highly marketable, vision of Scotland as a topography imbued with romance, whisky and shortbread. This paper seeks to historicise part of the construction of these stereotypes through the emergence of a new type of discursive formation in the nineteenth century: the modern guidebook. The series of guidebooks to Scotland produced by the publishing houses of A&C Black and John Murray, were amongst the first of the ongoing attempts to determine what a journey to Scotland would look like. They did not simply mediate the Scottish landscape for travellers, but contributed to the very limits of how Scotland would be realised in the imagination of travellers. The early guidebooks were dense in quotations from literary celebrities such as Robert Burns and Walter Scott (some of Scott’s descriptions of fictional scenes actually supplanted the description of real landscapes). However, as the guidebook developed, the quotation marks were erased and the literary vignettes were subsumed into the overarching authority of the guidebook. Scenes from literary fiction and real scenes, which contained their own historical and cultural specificity, were contained within the single discourse of the guidebook without discrepancy or distinction. The commercial and discursive pressures of the guidebook necessitated an essentialised series of images which could be branded as ‘Scottish’. While the paper discusses the fictional construction of ‘mythic’ Scotland, the conclusion considers the ongoing popularity of the guidebook and the need for cultural markers, co-ordinates, via which identity can be constructed. What kind of meaningful Scottish realities are generated by the guidebook?
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationRe-Inventing Scotland
Subtitle of host publicationNew readings of the Cultural Canon
EditorsLyndsay Lunan, Kirsty Macdonald, Carla Sassi
Publication statusPublished - 2008

Fingerprint

Modernity
Guidebooks
Scotland
Fiction
Travellers
Scottish Landscape
Literary Fiction
Discursive Formation
Journey
Vignettes
Discourse
Robert Burns
Stereotypes
Sir Walter Scott
Industry
Celebrity
Currency
John Murray
Whisky
Tourists

Keywords

  • Scottish tourism
  • Scottish guidebooks
  • Scottish fiction

Cite this

Mahn, C. (2008). Romantic horizons: antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland. In L. Lunan, K. Macdonald, & C. Sassi (Eds.), Re-Inventing Scotland: New readings of the Cultural Canon
Mahn, Churnjeet. / Romantic horizons : antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland. Re-Inventing Scotland: New readings of the Cultural Canon. editor / Lyndsay Lunan ; Kirsty Macdonald ; Carla Sassi. 2008.
@inbook{6801d438b76541cc9c1ab08aad4b6b76,
title = "Romantic horizons: antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland",
abstract = "Scotland’s tourist industry relies on the currency of essentialised, and highly marketable, vision of Scotland as a topography imbued with romance, whisky and shortbread. This paper seeks to historicise part of the construction of these stereotypes through the emergence of a new type of discursive formation in the nineteenth century: the modern guidebook. The series of guidebooks to Scotland produced by the publishing houses of A&C Black and John Murray, were amongst the first of the ongoing attempts to determine what a journey to Scotland would look like. They did not simply mediate the Scottish landscape for travellers, but contributed to the very limits of how Scotland would be realised in the imagination of travellers. The early guidebooks were dense in quotations from literary celebrities such as Robert Burns and Walter Scott (some of Scott’s descriptions of fictional scenes actually supplanted the description of real landscapes). However, as the guidebook developed, the quotation marks were erased and the literary vignettes were subsumed into the overarching authority of the guidebook. Scenes from literary fiction and real scenes, which contained their own historical and cultural specificity, were contained within the single discourse of the guidebook without discrepancy or distinction. The commercial and discursive pressures of the guidebook necessitated an essentialised series of images which could be branded as ‘Scottish’. While the paper discusses the fictional construction of ‘mythic’ Scotland, the conclusion considers the ongoing popularity of the guidebook and the need for cultural markers, co-ordinates, via which identity can be constructed. What kind of meaningful Scottish realities are generated by the guidebook?",
keywords = "Scottish tourism, Scottish guidebooks, Scottish fiction",
author = "Churnjeet Mahn",
year = "2008",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-3-631-55063-2",
editor = "Lyndsay Lunan and Macdonald, {Kirsty } and Sassi, {Carla }",
booktitle = "Re-Inventing Scotland",

}

Mahn, C 2008, Romantic horizons: antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland. in L Lunan, K Macdonald & C Sassi (eds), Re-Inventing Scotland: New readings of the Cultural Canon.

Romantic horizons : antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland. / Mahn, Churnjeet.

Re-Inventing Scotland: New readings of the Cultural Canon. ed. / Lyndsay Lunan; Kirsty Macdonald; Carla Sassi. 2008.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Romantic horizons

T2 - antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland

AU - Mahn, Churnjeet

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - Scotland’s tourist industry relies on the currency of essentialised, and highly marketable, vision of Scotland as a topography imbued with romance, whisky and shortbread. This paper seeks to historicise part of the construction of these stereotypes through the emergence of a new type of discursive formation in the nineteenth century: the modern guidebook. The series of guidebooks to Scotland produced by the publishing houses of A&C Black and John Murray, were amongst the first of the ongoing attempts to determine what a journey to Scotland would look like. They did not simply mediate the Scottish landscape for travellers, but contributed to the very limits of how Scotland would be realised in the imagination of travellers. The early guidebooks were dense in quotations from literary celebrities such as Robert Burns and Walter Scott (some of Scott’s descriptions of fictional scenes actually supplanted the description of real landscapes). However, as the guidebook developed, the quotation marks were erased and the literary vignettes were subsumed into the overarching authority of the guidebook. Scenes from literary fiction and real scenes, which contained their own historical and cultural specificity, were contained within the single discourse of the guidebook without discrepancy or distinction. The commercial and discursive pressures of the guidebook necessitated an essentialised series of images which could be branded as ‘Scottish’. While the paper discusses the fictional construction of ‘mythic’ Scotland, the conclusion considers the ongoing popularity of the guidebook and the need for cultural markers, co-ordinates, via which identity can be constructed. What kind of meaningful Scottish realities are generated by the guidebook?

AB - Scotland’s tourist industry relies on the currency of essentialised, and highly marketable, vision of Scotland as a topography imbued with romance, whisky and shortbread. This paper seeks to historicise part of the construction of these stereotypes through the emergence of a new type of discursive formation in the nineteenth century: the modern guidebook. The series of guidebooks to Scotland produced by the publishing houses of A&C Black and John Murray, were amongst the first of the ongoing attempts to determine what a journey to Scotland would look like. They did not simply mediate the Scottish landscape for travellers, but contributed to the very limits of how Scotland would be realised in the imagination of travellers. The early guidebooks were dense in quotations from literary celebrities such as Robert Burns and Walter Scott (some of Scott’s descriptions of fictional scenes actually supplanted the description of real landscapes). However, as the guidebook developed, the quotation marks were erased and the literary vignettes were subsumed into the overarching authority of the guidebook. Scenes from literary fiction and real scenes, which contained their own historical and cultural specificity, were contained within the single discourse of the guidebook without discrepancy or distinction. The commercial and discursive pressures of the guidebook necessitated an essentialised series of images which could be branded as ‘Scottish’. While the paper discusses the fictional construction of ‘mythic’ Scotland, the conclusion considers the ongoing popularity of the guidebook and the need for cultural markers, co-ordinates, via which identity can be constructed. What kind of meaningful Scottish realities are generated by the guidebook?

KW - Scottish tourism

KW - Scottish guidebooks

KW - Scottish fiction

UR - http://www.peterlang.com/download/datasheet/39054/datasheet_55063.pdf

M3 - Chapter

SN - 978-3-631-55063-2

BT - Re-Inventing Scotland

A2 - Lunan, Lyndsay

A2 - Macdonald, Kirsty

A2 - Sassi, Carla

ER -

Mahn C. Romantic horizons: antique modernity in the guidebook to Scotland. In Lunan L, Macdonald K, Sassi C, editors, Re-Inventing Scotland: New readings of the Cultural Canon. 2008