Risk-targeted seismic design maps for mainland France

John Douglas, Thomas Ulrich, Caterina Negulescu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

40 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In this article, the recently proposed approach known as 'risk targeting' for the development of national seismic design maps is investigated for mainland France. Risk targeting leads to ground-motion maps that, if used for design purposes, would lead to a uniform level of risk nationally. The Eurocode 8 design loads currently in force for France are used as the basis of this study. Because risk targeting requires various choices on, for example, the level of acceptable risk to be made a priori and these choices are not solely engineering decisions but involve input from decision makers we undertake sensitivity tests to study their influence. It is found that, in contrast to applications of this methodology for US cities, risk targeting does not lead to large modifications with respect to the national seismic hazard map nor to changes in the relative ranking of cities with respect to their design ground motions. This is because the hazard curves for French cities are almost parallel. In addition, we find that using a target annual collapse probability of about 10-5 for seismically designed buildings and a probability of collapse when subjected to the design PGA of 10-5 leads to reasonable results. This is again in contrast to US studies that have adopted much higher values for both these probabilities.

LanguageEnglish
Pages1999-2013
Number of pages15
JournalNatural Hazards
Volume65
Issue number3
Early online date25 Oct 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2013

Fingerprint

seismic design
targeting
ground motion
seismic hazard
ranking
hazard
engineering
methodology
city

Keywords

  • acceptable risk
  • collapse rate
  • earthquake risk
  • fragility curves
  • France
  • probabilistic seismic hazard assessment
  • risk targeting
  • seismic hazard maps

Cite this

Douglas, John ; Ulrich, Thomas ; Negulescu, Caterina. / Risk-targeted seismic design maps for mainland France. In: Natural Hazards. 2013 ; Vol. 65, No. 3. pp. 1999-2013.
@article{5c55055fc8454198bf82d0f76ed8f764,
title = "Risk-targeted seismic design maps for mainland France",
abstract = "In this article, the recently proposed approach known as 'risk targeting' for the development of national seismic design maps is investigated for mainland France. Risk targeting leads to ground-motion maps that, if used for design purposes, would lead to a uniform level of risk nationally. The Eurocode 8 design loads currently in force for France are used as the basis of this study. Because risk targeting requires various choices on, for example, the level of acceptable risk to be made a priori and these choices are not solely engineering decisions but involve input from decision makers we undertake sensitivity tests to study their influence. It is found that, in contrast to applications of this methodology for US cities, risk targeting does not lead to large modifications with respect to the national seismic hazard map nor to changes in the relative ranking of cities with respect to their design ground motions. This is because the hazard curves for French cities are almost parallel. In addition, we find that using a target annual collapse probability of about 10-5 for seismically designed buildings and a probability of collapse when subjected to the design PGA of 10-5 leads to reasonable results. This is again in contrast to US studies that have adopted much higher values for both these probabilities.",
keywords = "acceptable risk, collapse rate, earthquake risk, fragility curves, France, probabilistic seismic hazard assessment, risk targeting, seismic hazard maps",
author = "John Douglas and Thomas Ulrich and Caterina Negulescu",
year = "2013",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1007/s11069-012-0460-6",
language = "English",
volume = "65",
pages = "1999--2013",
journal = "Natural Hazards",
issn = "0921-030X",
number = "3",

}

Risk-targeted seismic design maps for mainland France. / Douglas, John; Ulrich, Thomas; Negulescu, Caterina.

In: Natural Hazards, Vol. 65, No. 3, 02.2013, p. 1999-2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Risk-targeted seismic design maps for mainland France

AU - Douglas, John

AU - Ulrich, Thomas

AU - Negulescu, Caterina

PY - 2013/2

Y1 - 2013/2

N2 - In this article, the recently proposed approach known as 'risk targeting' for the development of national seismic design maps is investigated for mainland France. Risk targeting leads to ground-motion maps that, if used for design purposes, would lead to a uniform level of risk nationally. The Eurocode 8 design loads currently in force for France are used as the basis of this study. Because risk targeting requires various choices on, for example, the level of acceptable risk to be made a priori and these choices are not solely engineering decisions but involve input from decision makers we undertake sensitivity tests to study their influence. It is found that, in contrast to applications of this methodology for US cities, risk targeting does not lead to large modifications with respect to the national seismic hazard map nor to changes in the relative ranking of cities with respect to their design ground motions. This is because the hazard curves for French cities are almost parallel. In addition, we find that using a target annual collapse probability of about 10-5 for seismically designed buildings and a probability of collapse when subjected to the design PGA of 10-5 leads to reasonable results. This is again in contrast to US studies that have adopted much higher values for both these probabilities.

AB - In this article, the recently proposed approach known as 'risk targeting' for the development of national seismic design maps is investigated for mainland France. Risk targeting leads to ground-motion maps that, if used for design purposes, would lead to a uniform level of risk nationally. The Eurocode 8 design loads currently in force for France are used as the basis of this study. Because risk targeting requires various choices on, for example, the level of acceptable risk to be made a priori and these choices are not solely engineering decisions but involve input from decision makers we undertake sensitivity tests to study their influence. It is found that, in contrast to applications of this methodology for US cities, risk targeting does not lead to large modifications with respect to the national seismic hazard map nor to changes in the relative ranking of cities with respect to their design ground motions. This is because the hazard curves for French cities are almost parallel. In addition, we find that using a target annual collapse probability of about 10-5 for seismically designed buildings and a probability of collapse when subjected to the design PGA of 10-5 leads to reasonable results. This is again in contrast to US studies that have adopted much higher values for both these probabilities.

KW - acceptable risk

KW - collapse rate

KW - earthquake risk

KW - fragility curves

KW - France

KW - probabilistic seismic hazard assessment

KW - risk targeting

KW - seismic hazard maps

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84871935082&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11069-012-0460-6

DO - 10.1007/s11069-012-0460-6

M3 - Article

VL - 65

SP - 1999

EP - 2013

JO - Natural Hazards

T2 - Natural Hazards

JF - Natural Hazards

SN - 0921-030X

IS - 3

ER -