Resonance tropes in corporate philanthropy discourse

C. Spence, Ian Thomson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper explores corporate charitable giving disclosures in order to question the extent to which corporations can claim that their philanthropy activities are charitable at all. Exploration of these issues is carried out by means of a tropological analysis which focuses on the different linguistic tropes within the philanthropy disclosures of fifty-two companies, namely metaphor and synecdoche. The results reveal a number of complex and contradictory things. Primarily, the master-metaphor of 'altruism' projected by the corporate disclosures is ideologically at odds with the more business case oriented discourse that shapes the disclosures. This contradiction is put into starker contrast by the existence of a root-metaphor whereby the recipients of corporate philanthropy are presented as the 'deserving poor'. Synecdochal devices are present within the corporate disclosures whereby employee initiatives that are independent of corporate strategies are used to confer attributes onto the disclosures which bolster the master metaphor of 'altruism'. As such, corporate philanthropy is presented by the paper as a structurally incoherent discourse yet one that has implications for both extracting greater value from various societal groups and in defining, on behalf of civil society, what is a worthy cause.
LanguageEnglish
Pages372-388
Number of pages17
JournalBusiness Ethics: A European Review
Volume18
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2009

Fingerprint

Disclosure
Metaphor
Altruism
Linguistics
Corporate philanthropy
Discourse
Equipment and Supplies
Philanthropy
Corporate disclosure

Keywords

  • resonance tropes
  • philanthropy activities
  • altruism
  • corporate disclosures

Cite this

Spence, C. ; Thomson, Ian. / Resonance tropes in corporate philanthropy discourse. In: Business Ethics: A European Review. 2009 ; Vol. 18, No. 4. pp. 372-388.
@article{9ae640959193461492b531354357a9ed,
title = "Resonance tropes in corporate philanthropy discourse",
abstract = "This paper explores corporate charitable giving disclosures in order to question the extent to which corporations can claim that their philanthropy activities are charitable at all. Exploration of these issues is carried out by means of a tropological analysis which focuses on the different linguistic tropes within the philanthropy disclosures of fifty-two companies, namely metaphor and synecdoche. The results reveal a number of complex and contradictory things. Primarily, the master-metaphor of 'altruism' projected by the corporate disclosures is ideologically at odds with the more business case oriented discourse that shapes the disclosures. This contradiction is put into starker contrast by the existence of a root-metaphor whereby the recipients of corporate philanthropy are presented as the 'deserving poor'. Synecdochal devices are present within the corporate disclosures whereby employee initiatives that are independent of corporate strategies are used to confer attributes onto the disclosures which bolster the master metaphor of 'altruism'. As such, corporate philanthropy is presented by the paper as a structurally incoherent discourse yet one that has implications for both extracting greater value from various societal groups and in defining, on behalf of civil society, what is a worthy cause.",
keywords = "resonance tropes, philanthropy activities, altruism, corporate disclosures",
author = "C. Spence and Ian Thomson",
year = "2009",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1111/j.1467-8608.2009.01570.x",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "372--388",
journal = "Business Ethics: A European Review",
issn = "0962-8770",
number = "4",

}

Resonance tropes in corporate philanthropy discourse. / Spence, C.; Thomson, Ian.

In: Business Ethics: A European Review, Vol. 18, No. 4, 10.2009, p. 372-388.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Resonance tropes in corporate philanthropy discourse

AU - Spence, C.

AU - Thomson, Ian

PY - 2009/10

Y1 - 2009/10

N2 - This paper explores corporate charitable giving disclosures in order to question the extent to which corporations can claim that their philanthropy activities are charitable at all. Exploration of these issues is carried out by means of a tropological analysis which focuses on the different linguistic tropes within the philanthropy disclosures of fifty-two companies, namely metaphor and synecdoche. The results reveal a number of complex and contradictory things. Primarily, the master-metaphor of 'altruism' projected by the corporate disclosures is ideologically at odds with the more business case oriented discourse that shapes the disclosures. This contradiction is put into starker contrast by the existence of a root-metaphor whereby the recipients of corporate philanthropy are presented as the 'deserving poor'. Synecdochal devices are present within the corporate disclosures whereby employee initiatives that are independent of corporate strategies are used to confer attributes onto the disclosures which bolster the master metaphor of 'altruism'. As such, corporate philanthropy is presented by the paper as a structurally incoherent discourse yet one that has implications for both extracting greater value from various societal groups and in defining, on behalf of civil society, what is a worthy cause.

AB - This paper explores corporate charitable giving disclosures in order to question the extent to which corporations can claim that their philanthropy activities are charitable at all. Exploration of these issues is carried out by means of a tropological analysis which focuses on the different linguistic tropes within the philanthropy disclosures of fifty-two companies, namely metaphor and synecdoche. The results reveal a number of complex and contradictory things. Primarily, the master-metaphor of 'altruism' projected by the corporate disclosures is ideologically at odds with the more business case oriented discourse that shapes the disclosures. This contradiction is put into starker contrast by the existence of a root-metaphor whereby the recipients of corporate philanthropy are presented as the 'deserving poor'. Synecdochal devices are present within the corporate disclosures whereby employee initiatives that are independent of corporate strategies are used to confer attributes onto the disclosures which bolster the master metaphor of 'altruism'. As such, corporate philanthropy is presented by the paper as a structurally incoherent discourse yet one that has implications for both extracting greater value from various societal groups and in defining, on behalf of civil society, what is a worthy cause.

KW - resonance tropes

KW - philanthropy activities

KW - altruism

KW - corporate disclosures

UR - http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1484019

U2 - 10.1111/j.1467-8608.2009.01570.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1467-8608.2009.01570.x

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 372

EP - 388

JO - Business Ethics: A European Review

T2 - Business Ethics: A European Review

JF - Business Ethics: A European Review

SN - 0962-8770

IS - 4

ER -