Remembering probation in Scotland

F. McNeill

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    21 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Set within the contexts of probation’s upcoming centenary in Scotland (in 2005) and the current debate about the future of criminal justice social work in Scotland (and probation in England and Wales), this article provides an account of the early history of probation in Scotland, focussing on the rarely discussed period between 1905 and 1968. Following Nellis’s (2001) injunction to develop a ‘historically tutored memory’ as a defence against the narrowing of our visions for the future, and drawing on Vanstone’s (2004) recent work on the history of the service in England and Wales, the article pieces together and seeks to understand a significant change in Scottish probation’s core identity and purpose from providing supervision as an alternative to punishment to providing ‘treatment’ as a means of reforming offenders. In the concluding discussion, the article briefly summarises the subsequent move towards a welfare-oriented approach after 1968 and, more recently the drift towards public protection as an overarching purpose (Robinson and McNeill, 2004). The article concludes that the current debate in Scotland should shift from ‘second order’ questions around organizational arrangements to ‘first order’ questions around which aspects of these various purposes and identities should endure in the 21st century.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages25-40
    Number of pages16
    JournalProbation Journal
    Volume52
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Mar 2005

    Fingerprint

    probation
    history
    supervision
    offender
    penalty
    social work
    welfare
    justice

    Keywords

    • Glasgow
    • probation history
    • Scotland
    • social work history

    Cite this

    McNeill, F. / Remembering probation in Scotland. In: Probation Journal. 2005 ; Vol. 52, No. 1. pp. 25-40.
    @article{43c94341e3304836a851b9674165b4e3,
    title = "Remembering probation in Scotland",
    abstract = "Set within the contexts of probation’s upcoming centenary in Scotland (in 2005) and the current debate about the future of criminal justice social work in Scotland (and probation in England and Wales), this article provides an account of the early history of probation in Scotland, focussing on the rarely discussed period between 1905 and 1968. Following Nellis’s (2001) injunction to develop a ‘historically tutored memory’ as a defence against the narrowing of our visions for the future, and drawing on Vanstone’s (2004) recent work on the history of the service in England and Wales, the article pieces together and seeks to understand a significant change in Scottish probation’s core identity and purpose from providing supervision as an alternative to punishment to providing ‘treatment’ as a means of reforming offenders. In the concluding discussion, the article briefly summarises the subsequent move towards a welfare-oriented approach after 1968 and, more recently the drift towards public protection as an overarching purpose (Robinson and McNeill, 2004). The article concludes that the current debate in Scotland should shift from ‘second order’ questions around organizational arrangements to ‘first order’ questions around which aspects of these various purposes and identities should endure in the 21st century.",
    keywords = "Glasgow, probation history, Scotland, social work history",
    author = "F. McNeill",
    year = "2005",
    month = "3",
    doi = "10.1177/0264550505050624",
    language = "English",
    volume = "52",
    pages = "25--40",
    journal = "Probation Journal",
    issn = "0264-5505",
    number = "1",

    }

    Remembering probation in Scotland. / McNeill, F.

    In: Probation Journal, Vol. 52, No. 1, 03.2005, p. 25-40.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Remembering probation in Scotland

    AU - McNeill, F.

    PY - 2005/3

    Y1 - 2005/3

    N2 - Set within the contexts of probation’s upcoming centenary in Scotland (in 2005) and the current debate about the future of criminal justice social work in Scotland (and probation in England and Wales), this article provides an account of the early history of probation in Scotland, focussing on the rarely discussed period between 1905 and 1968. Following Nellis’s (2001) injunction to develop a ‘historically tutored memory’ as a defence against the narrowing of our visions for the future, and drawing on Vanstone’s (2004) recent work on the history of the service in England and Wales, the article pieces together and seeks to understand a significant change in Scottish probation’s core identity and purpose from providing supervision as an alternative to punishment to providing ‘treatment’ as a means of reforming offenders. In the concluding discussion, the article briefly summarises the subsequent move towards a welfare-oriented approach after 1968 and, more recently the drift towards public protection as an overarching purpose (Robinson and McNeill, 2004). The article concludes that the current debate in Scotland should shift from ‘second order’ questions around organizational arrangements to ‘first order’ questions around which aspects of these various purposes and identities should endure in the 21st century.

    AB - Set within the contexts of probation’s upcoming centenary in Scotland (in 2005) and the current debate about the future of criminal justice social work in Scotland (and probation in England and Wales), this article provides an account of the early history of probation in Scotland, focussing on the rarely discussed period between 1905 and 1968. Following Nellis’s (2001) injunction to develop a ‘historically tutored memory’ as a defence against the narrowing of our visions for the future, and drawing on Vanstone’s (2004) recent work on the history of the service in England and Wales, the article pieces together and seeks to understand a significant change in Scottish probation’s core identity and purpose from providing supervision as an alternative to punishment to providing ‘treatment’ as a means of reforming offenders. In the concluding discussion, the article briefly summarises the subsequent move towards a welfare-oriented approach after 1968 and, more recently the drift towards public protection as an overarching purpose (Robinson and McNeill, 2004). The article concludes that the current debate in Scotland should shift from ‘second order’ questions around organizational arrangements to ‘first order’ questions around which aspects of these various purposes and identities should endure in the 21st century.

    KW - Glasgow

    KW - probation history

    KW - Scotland

    KW - social work history

    U2 - 10.1177/0264550505050624

    DO - 10.1177/0264550505050624

    M3 - Article

    VL - 52

    SP - 25

    EP - 40

    JO - Probation Journal

    T2 - Probation Journal

    JF - Probation Journal

    SN - 0264-5505

    IS - 1

    ER -