Reassessing the Paris Commune of 1871: a response to Robert Tombs, 'How bloody was la semaine sanglante? a revision'

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

Abstract

In recent years, the Paris Commune of 1871 has transformed from being a hotly-contested subject of political significance to a comparatively neglected area of modern European history. Robert Tombs’ work in seeking to reassess a fundamental and deeply controversial aspect of this episode is therefore
very much to be welcomed. The repression of the Paris Commune became one of the central tropes for the left in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Yet as Tombs has highlighted, considerable uncertainty still surrounds the numbers of Communards killed by the Army of Versailles during the semaine sanglante of 21 to 28 May 1871 and the manner with which they met their deaths. Tombs has, with perhaps surprising ease, uncovered evidence that has led him to revise
his original calculations of the number killed from around 25,000 to perhaps 20,000 and now to between 6000 and 7500. Tombs now also suggests that around half of all the deaths occurred after the fighting as a result of court martials and that, therefore, organised mass killings were exceptional rather than widespread, as had previously been believed. To this end, Tombs has
gathered a good deal of convincing and seemingly precise documentary evidence that stands in stark contrast with the often vague estimates that can be found in many contemporary accounts and in some of the more recent scholarship on the subject.
LanguageEnglish
Pages20-25
Number of pages6
JournalH-France Salon
Volume3
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2011

Fingerprint

Tombs
Paris Commune
Fundamental
Versailles
European History
Killing
Uncertainty
Tropes
Army
Documentary Evidence

Keywords

  • Paris Commune
  • French history
  • European history
  • Army of Versailles
  • semaine sanglante

Cite this

@article{420deb90c650420185f11f4b7bad6891,
title = "Reassessing the Paris Commune of 1871: a response to Robert Tombs, 'How bloody was la semaine sanglante? a revision'",
abstract = "In recent years, the Paris Commune of 1871 has transformed from being a hotly-contested subject of political significance to a comparatively neglected area of modern European history. Robert Tombs’ work in seeking to reassess a fundamental and deeply controversial aspect of this episode is therefore very much to be welcomed. The repression of the Paris Commune became one of the central tropes for the left in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Yet as Tombs has highlighted, considerable uncertainty still surrounds the numbers of Communards killed by the Army of Versailles during the semaine sanglante of 21 to 28 May 1871 and the manner with which they met their deaths. Tombs has, with perhaps surprising ease, uncovered evidence that has led him to revise his original calculations of the number killed from around 25,000 to perhaps 20,000 and now to between 6000 and 7500. Tombs now also suggests that around half of all the deaths occurred after the fighting as a result of court martials and that, therefore, organised mass killings were exceptional rather than widespread, as had previously been believed. To this end, Tombs has gathered a good deal of convincing and seemingly precise documentary evidence that stands in stark contrast with the often vague estimates that can be found in many contemporary accounts and in some of the more recent scholarship on the subject.",
keywords = "Paris Commune, French history, European history, Army of Versailles, semaine sanglante",
author = "Karine Varley",
year = "2011",
month = "4",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "20--25",
journal = "H-France Salon",
issn = "2150-4870",
number = "1",

}

Reassessing the Paris Commune of 1871 : a response to Robert Tombs, 'How bloody was la semaine sanglante? a revision'. / Varley, Karine.

In: H-France Salon, Vol. 3, No. 1, 04.2011, p. 20-25.

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reassessing the Paris Commune of 1871

T2 - H-France Salon

AU - Varley, Karine

PY - 2011/4

Y1 - 2011/4

N2 - In recent years, the Paris Commune of 1871 has transformed from being a hotly-contested subject of political significance to a comparatively neglected area of modern European history. Robert Tombs’ work in seeking to reassess a fundamental and deeply controversial aspect of this episode is therefore very much to be welcomed. The repression of the Paris Commune became one of the central tropes for the left in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Yet as Tombs has highlighted, considerable uncertainty still surrounds the numbers of Communards killed by the Army of Versailles during the semaine sanglante of 21 to 28 May 1871 and the manner with which they met their deaths. Tombs has, with perhaps surprising ease, uncovered evidence that has led him to revise his original calculations of the number killed from around 25,000 to perhaps 20,000 and now to between 6000 and 7500. Tombs now also suggests that around half of all the deaths occurred after the fighting as a result of court martials and that, therefore, organised mass killings were exceptional rather than widespread, as had previously been believed. To this end, Tombs has gathered a good deal of convincing and seemingly precise documentary evidence that stands in stark contrast with the often vague estimates that can be found in many contemporary accounts and in some of the more recent scholarship on the subject.

AB - In recent years, the Paris Commune of 1871 has transformed from being a hotly-contested subject of political significance to a comparatively neglected area of modern European history. Robert Tombs’ work in seeking to reassess a fundamental and deeply controversial aspect of this episode is therefore very much to be welcomed. The repression of the Paris Commune became one of the central tropes for the left in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Yet as Tombs has highlighted, considerable uncertainty still surrounds the numbers of Communards killed by the Army of Versailles during the semaine sanglante of 21 to 28 May 1871 and the manner with which they met their deaths. Tombs has, with perhaps surprising ease, uncovered evidence that has led him to revise his original calculations of the number killed from around 25,000 to perhaps 20,000 and now to between 6000 and 7500. Tombs now also suggests that around half of all the deaths occurred after the fighting as a result of court martials and that, therefore, organised mass killings were exceptional rather than widespread, as had previously been believed. To this end, Tombs has gathered a good deal of convincing and seemingly precise documentary evidence that stands in stark contrast with the often vague estimates that can be found in many contemporary accounts and in some of the more recent scholarship on the subject.

KW - Paris Commune

KW - French history

KW - European history

KW - Army of Versailles

KW - semaine sanglante

UR - http://www.h-france.net/Salon/Salonvol3no3.pdf

M3 - Comment/debate

VL - 3

SP - 20

EP - 25

JO - H-France Salon

JF - H-France Salon

SN - 2150-4870

IS - 1

ER -