Reading race in small Island: discourse deviation, schemata and the textual encounter

Anouk Lang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article uses the work of Cook and Semino on discourse deviation to investigate the schemata – the existing cognitive frameworks – that readers bring to their encounters with texts. It aims to challenge the tendency within some strands of discourse analysis and literary theory to ignore empirical readers and to focus on the effects of texts on readers while neglecting the role played by readerly agency. The analysis centres on a discussion between Liverpool residents with various levels of involvement in Small Island Read 2007: a project encouraging residents of the city to read Andrea Levy’s novel Small Island as part of the commemoration of the 200th anniversary of the passing of the Slave Trade Abolition Bill. In this discussion, hedging around lexical items connected to ethnicity and slavery suggests that these readers came to Small Island with a marked reluctance to discuss these topics. When coupled with corroborating data from online questionnaire responses on the topic of ethnicity, this finding is a significant one for understanding the effect of Small Island on its readers, as it offers a degree of contextualization missing from extant claims that readers have been transformed in some way by the novel, and brings empirical depth to discussions which have so far been predominantly theoretical. As an exploratory study, the analysis also offers a model for other investigations into the effects of reading which, I argue, would be enhanced by considering what readers bring to – as well as take from – their textual encounters.

LanguageEnglish
Pages316-330
Number of pages15
JournalLanguage and Literature
Volume18
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2009

Fingerprint

discourse
ethnicity
resident
slave trade
slavery
anniversary
discourse analysis
questionnaire
Discourse
Small Islands
Deviation
Reader
Residents
Ethnic Groups

Keywords

  • discourse deviation
  • ethnicity
  • hedging
  • Levy, Andrea
  • postcolonial studies
  • racism
  • schema theory
  • Small Island

Cite this

@article{565a83c2542046faaeccc0268fc84f7c,
title = "Reading race in small Island: discourse deviation, schemata and the textual encounter",
abstract = "This article uses the work of Cook and Semino on discourse deviation to investigate the schemata – the existing cognitive frameworks – that readers bring to their encounters with texts. It aims to challenge the tendency within some strands of discourse analysis and literary theory to ignore empirical readers and to focus on the effects of texts on readers while neglecting the role played by readerly agency. The analysis centres on a discussion between Liverpool residents with various levels of involvement in Small Island Read 2007: a project encouraging residents of the city to read Andrea Levy’s novel Small Island as part of the commemoration of the 200th anniversary of the passing of the Slave Trade Abolition Bill. In this discussion, hedging around lexical items connected to ethnicity and slavery suggests that these readers came to Small Island with a marked reluctance to discuss these topics. When coupled with corroborating data from online questionnaire responses on the topic of ethnicity, this finding is a significant one for understanding the effect of Small Island on its readers, as it offers a degree of contextualization missing from extant claims that readers have been transformed in some way by the novel, and brings empirical depth to discussions which have so far been predominantly theoretical. As an exploratory study, the analysis also offers a model for other investigations into the effects of reading which, I argue, would be enhanced by considering what readers bring to – as well as take from – their textual encounters.",
keywords = "discourse deviation, ethnicity, hedging, Levy, Andrea, postcolonial studies, racism, schema theory, Small Island",
author = "Anouk Lang",
year = "2009",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1177/0963947009105856",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "316--330",
journal = "Language and Literature",
issn = "0963-9470",
number = "3",

}

Reading race in small Island : discourse deviation, schemata and the textual encounter. / Lang, Anouk.

In: Language and Literature, Vol. 18, No. 3, 08.2009, p. 316-330.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reading race in small Island

T2 - Language and Literature

AU - Lang, Anouk

PY - 2009/8

Y1 - 2009/8

N2 - This article uses the work of Cook and Semino on discourse deviation to investigate the schemata – the existing cognitive frameworks – that readers bring to their encounters with texts. It aims to challenge the tendency within some strands of discourse analysis and literary theory to ignore empirical readers and to focus on the effects of texts on readers while neglecting the role played by readerly agency. The analysis centres on a discussion between Liverpool residents with various levels of involvement in Small Island Read 2007: a project encouraging residents of the city to read Andrea Levy’s novel Small Island as part of the commemoration of the 200th anniversary of the passing of the Slave Trade Abolition Bill. In this discussion, hedging around lexical items connected to ethnicity and slavery suggests that these readers came to Small Island with a marked reluctance to discuss these topics. When coupled with corroborating data from online questionnaire responses on the topic of ethnicity, this finding is a significant one for understanding the effect of Small Island on its readers, as it offers a degree of contextualization missing from extant claims that readers have been transformed in some way by the novel, and brings empirical depth to discussions which have so far been predominantly theoretical. As an exploratory study, the analysis also offers a model for other investigations into the effects of reading which, I argue, would be enhanced by considering what readers bring to – as well as take from – their textual encounters.

AB - This article uses the work of Cook and Semino on discourse deviation to investigate the schemata – the existing cognitive frameworks – that readers bring to their encounters with texts. It aims to challenge the tendency within some strands of discourse analysis and literary theory to ignore empirical readers and to focus on the effects of texts on readers while neglecting the role played by readerly agency. The analysis centres on a discussion between Liverpool residents with various levels of involvement in Small Island Read 2007: a project encouraging residents of the city to read Andrea Levy’s novel Small Island as part of the commemoration of the 200th anniversary of the passing of the Slave Trade Abolition Bill. In this discussion, hedging around lexical items connected to ethnicity and slavery suggests that these readers came to Small Island with a marked reluctance to discuss these topics. When coupled with corroborating data from online questionnaire responses on the topic of ethnicity, this finding is a significant one for understanding the effect of Small Island on its readers, as it offers a degree of contextualization missing from extant claims that readers have been transformed in some way by the novel, and brings empirical depth to discussions which have so far been predominantly theoretical. As an exploratory study, the analysis also offers a model for other investigations into the effects of reading which, I argue, would be enhanced by considering what readers bring to – as well as take from – their textual encounters.

KW - discourse deviation

KW - ethnicity

KW - hedging

KW - Levy, Andrea

KW - postcolonial studies

KW - racism

KW - schema theory

KW - Small Island

U2 - 10.1177/0963947009105856

DO - 10.1177/0963947009105856

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 316

EP - 330

JO - Language and Literature

JF - Language and Literature

SN - 0963-9470

IS - 3

ER -