Reading Peter Hopkins’ The Issue of Masculine Identities for British Muslims After 9/11: A Social Analysis

Robina Mohammad

    Research output: Contribution to journalBook/Film/Article review

    Abstract

    Very soon after the World Trade Center attacks on September
    11th 2001, political geography underwent something of a terror
    turn e a significant refocusing of attention on the war on terror that
    led to some important work on geopolitics, terrorism and securitisation. Every disciplinary turn has its emphases and omissions,
    and perhaps inevitably this turn has constructed the events it
    studies in unintended ways. In particular, there have been many
    assertions about the impacts of the war on terror on everyday life,
    yet relatively little attention to empirical evidence. The World Trade
    Center attacks were rapidly heralded as marking a sea-change for
    global politics and for local social, political and spatial relations,
    although recent interventions have emphasised continuities as well
    as breaks with the past (Gregory & Pred, 2007; Hopkins & Smith,
    2008). Further, the flurry of work has been dominated by analyses that centre on ‘big’ politics and the global as the most pressing
    issue and scale of analysis. As political geographers, we have not
    always paused to reflect on what is taking place at other scales, as
    a part of, or despite, the ‘big’ processes. I have written elsewhere
    (Pain, 2009, 2010) about the dangers of ascribing fear as a taken for
    granted effect of the war on terror and securitisation; it has been
    a consistent theme in political geography since 2001. Hopkins’ text
    is one of the first in a growing group of studies to question some of
    these assumptions and reorient our attention.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages339-348
    Number of pages10
    JournalPolitical Geography
    Volume30
    Issue number6
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Aug 2011

    Fingerprint

    terrorism
    Muslim
    political geography
    politics
    World Trade Center
    geopolitics
    geography
    world trade
    everyday life
    pain
    continuity
    anxiety
    social analysis
    September 11 Attacks
    British Muslims
    Masculine
    Social Analysis
    event
    evidence
    War on Terror

    Keywords

    • political geography
    • muslims
    • identity

    Cite this

    @article{6cf04c183f864dd7b5c199d29cf1b85a,
    title = "Reading Peter Hopkins’ The Issue of Masculine Identities for British Muslims After 9/11: A Social Analysis",
    abstract = "Very soon after the World Trade Center attacks on September11th 2001, political geography underwent something of a terrorturn e a significant refocusing of attention on the war on terror thatled to some important work on geopolitics, terrorism and securitisation. Every disciplinary turn has its emphases and omissions,and perhaps inevitably this turn has constructed the events itstudies in unintended ways. In particular, there have been manyassertions about the impacts of the war on terror on everyday life,yet relatively little attention to empirical evidence. The World TradeCenter attacks were rapidly heralded as marking a sea-change forglobal politics and for local social, political and spatial relations,although recent interventions have emphasised continuities as wellas breaks with the past (Gregory & Pred, 2007; Hopkins & Smith,2008). Further, the flurry of work has been dominated by analyses that centre on ‘big’ politics and the global as the most pressingissue and scale of analysis. As political geographers, we have notalways paused to reflect on what is taking place at other scales, asa part of, or despite, the ‘big’ processes. I have written elsewhere(Pain, 2009, 2010) about the dangers of ascribing fear as a taken forgranted effect of the war on terror and securitisation; it has beena consistent theme in political geography since 2001. Hopkins’ textis one of the first in a growing group of studies to question some ofthese assumptions and reorient our attention.",
    keywords = "political geography, muslims, identity",
    author = "Robina Mohammad",
    year = "2011",
    month = "8",
    doi = "10.1016/j.polgeo.2011.07.002",
    language = "English",
    volume = "30",
    pages = "339--348",
    journal = "Political Geography",
    issn = "0962-6298",
    number = "6",

    }

    Reading Peter Hopkins’ The Issue of Masculine Identities for British Muslims After 9/11: A Social Analysis. / Mohammad, Robina.

    In: Political Geography, Vol. 30, No. 6, 08.2011, p. 339-348.

    Research output: Contribution to journalBook/Film/Article review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Reading Peter Hopkins’ The Issue of Masculine Identities for British Muslims After 9/11: A Social Analysis

    AU - Mohammad, Robina

    PY - 2011/8

    Y1 - 2011/8

    N2 - Very soon after the World Trade Center attacks on September11th 2001, political geography underwent something of a terrorturn e a significant refocusing of attention on the war on terror thatled to some important work on geopolitics, terrorism and securitisation. Every disciplinary turn has its emphases and omissions,and perhaps inevitably this turn has constructed the events itstudies in unintended ways. In particular, there have been manyassertions about the impacts of the war on terror on everyday life,yet relatively little attention to empirical evidence. The World TradeCenter attacks were rapidly heralded as marking a sea-change forglobal politics and for local social, political and spatial relations,although recent interventions have emphasised continuities as wellas breaks with the past (Gregory & Pred, 2007; Hopkins & Smith,2008). Further, the flurry of work has been dominated by analyses that centre on ‘big’ politics and the global as the most pressingissue and scale of analysis. As political geographers, we have notalways paused to reflect on what is taking place at other scales, asa part of, or despite, the ‘big’ processes. I have written elsewhere(Pain, 2009, 2010) about the dangers of ascribing fear as a taken forgranted effect of the war on terror and securitisation; it has beena consistent theme in political geography since 2001. Hopkins’ textis one of the first in a growing group of studies to question some ofthese assumptions and reorient our attention.

    AB - Very soon after the World Trade Center attacks on September11th 2001, political geography underwent something of a terrorturn e a significant refocusing of attention on the war on terror thatled to some important work on geopolitics, terrorism and securitisation. Every disciplinary turn has its emphases and omissions,and perhaps inevitably this turn has constructed the events itstudies in unintended ways. In particular, there have been manyassertions about the impacts of the war on terror on everyday life,yet relatively little attention to empirical evidence. The World TradeCenter attacks were rapidly heralded as marking a sea-change forglobal politics and for local social, political and spatial relations,although recent interventions have emphasised continuities as wellas breaks with the past (Gregory & Pred, 2007; Hopkins & Smith,2008). Further, the flurry of work has been dominated by analyses that centre on ‘big’ politics and the global as the most pressingissue and scale of analysis. As political geographers, we have notalways paused to reflect on what is taking place at other scales, asa part of, or despite, the ‘big’ processes. I have written elsewhere(Pain, 2009, 2010) about the dangers of ascribing fear as a taken forgranted effect of the war on terror and securitisation; it has beena consistent theme in political geography since 2001. Hopkins’ textis one of the first in a growing group of studies to question some ofthese assumptions and reorient our attention.

    KW - political geography

    KW - muslims

    KW - identity

    U2 - 10.1016/j.polgeo.2011.07.002

    DO - 10.1016/j.polgeo.2011.07.002

    M3 - Book/Film/Article review

    VL - 30

    SP - 339

    EP - 348

    JO - Political Geography

    T2 - Political Geography

    JF - Political Geography

    SN - 0962-6298

    IS - 6

    ER -