Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions: An evaluation of the additive risk model

J. Booth, J. Boyle, S. Kelly

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

25 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Reading difficulties affect 10-15% of school children and are often found to be comorbid with other developmental difficulties. For example, the comorbidity with ADHD is reported as 15-45% and approximately 50% for Specific Language Impairment. In some cases however, children have more than one comorbid condition. Executive function difficulties have been identified in each of these areas of difficulty however it is not known to what extent having a number of comorbid conditions increases severity. The present study explores whether comorbidity influences the severity of a child’s reading difficulty employing an additive risk model and whether this extends to executive function task performance. 213 children with reading difficulties were evaluated for ADHD symptoms and oral language difficulties and also completed tasks assess working memory and inhibition. While almost 52% were found to have RD and one other comorbid condition, 30% had difficulties across all three areas. Results found that the number of comorbid conditions significantly predicted the severity of children’s reading difficulty. A similar pattern emerged for executive function task performance, although this was not uniform across all aspects assessed. The results are discussed in relation to implications for service provision and intervention strategies.

Conference

ConferenceBritish Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityNewcastle upon Tyne
Period7/09/119/09/11

Fingerprint

Executive Function
Reading
ADHD
comorbidity
evaluation
Task Performance and Analysis
Comorbidity
Language
intervention strategy
language
schoolchild
performance
Short-Term Memory

Keywords

  • reading difficulties
  • school children
  • developmental difficulties
  • ADHD
  • specific language impairment
  • comorbid conditions
  • executive functions
  • intervention strategies

Cite this

Booth, J., Boyle, J., & Kelly, S. (2011). Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions: An evaluation of the additive risk model. 50. Paper presented at British Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Booth, J. ; Boyle, J. ; Kelly, S. / Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions : An evaluation of the additive risk model. Paper presented at British Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.1 p.
@conference{3cc023237b054bbd9c68ec9fa40e8343,
title = "Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions: An evaluation of the additive risk model",
abstract = "Reading difficulties affect 10-15{\%} of school children and are often found to be comorbid with other developmental difficulties. For example, the comorbidity with ADHD is reported as 15-45{\%} and approximately 50{\%} for Specific Language Impairment. In some cases however, children have more than one comorbid condition. Executive function difficulties have been identified in each of these areas of difficulty however it is not known to what extent having a number of comorbid conditions increases severity. The present study explores whether comorbidity influences the severity of a child’s reading difficulty employing an additive risk model and whether this extends to executive function task performance. 213 children with reading difficulties were evaluated for ADHD symptoms and oral language difficulties and also completed tasks assess working memory and inhibition. While almost 52{\%} were found to have RD and one other comorbid condition, 30{\%} had difficulties across all three areas. Results found that the number of comorbid conditions significantly predicted the severity of children’s reading difficulty. A similar pattern emerged for executive function task performance, although this was not uniform across all aspects assessed. The results are discussed in relation to implications for service provision and intervention strategies.",
keywords = "reading difficulties, school children, developmental difficulties, ADHD, specific language impairment, comorbid conditions, executive functions, intervention strategies",
author = "J. Booth and J. Boyle and S. Kelly",
year = "2011",
month = "9",
day = "7",
language = "English",
pages = "50",
note = "British Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011 ; Conference date: 07-09-2011 Through 09-09-2011",

}

Booth, J, Boyle, J & Kelly, S 2011, 'Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions: An evaluation of the additive risk model' Paper presented at British Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom, 7/09/11 - 9/09/11, pp. 50.

Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions : An evaluation of the additive risk model. / Booth, J.; Boyle, J.; Kelly, S.

2011. 50 Paper presented at British Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions

T2 - An evaluation of the additive risk model

AU - Booth, J.

AU - Boyle, J.

AU - Kelly, S.

PY - 2011/9/7

Y1 - 2011/9/7

N2 - Reading difficulties affect 10-15% of school children and are often found to be comorbid with other developmental difficulties. For example, the comorbidity with ADHD is reported as 15-45% and approximately 50% for Specific Language Impairment. In some cases however, children have more than one comorbid condition. Executive function difficulties have been identified in each of these areas of difficulty however it is not known to what extent having a number of comorbid conditions increases severity. The present study explores whether comorbidity influences the severity of a child’s reading difficulty employing an additive risk model and whether this extends to executive function task performance. 213 children with reading difficulties were evaluated for ADHD symptoms and oral language difficulties and also completed tasks assess working memory and inhibition. While almost 52% were found to have RD and one other comorbid condition, 30% had difficulties across all three areas. Results found that the number of comorbid conditions significantly predicted the severity of children’s reading difficulty. A similar pattern emerged for executive function task performance, although this was not uniform across all aspects assessed. The results are discussed in relation to implications for service provision and intervention strategies.

AB - Reading difficulties affect 10-15% of school children and are often found to be comorbid with other developmental difficulties. For example, the comorbidity with ADHD is reported as 15-45% and approximately 50% for Specific Language Impairment. In some cases however, children have more than one comorbid condition. Executive function difficulties have been identified in each of these areas of difficulty however it is not known to what extent having a number of comorbid conditions increases severity. The present study explores whether comorbidity influences the severity of a child’s reading difficulty employing an additive risk model and whether this extends to executive function task performance. 213 children with reading difficulties were evaluated for ADHD symptoms and oral language difficulties and also completed tasks assess working memory and inhibition. While almost 52% were found to have RD and one other comorbid condition, 30% had difficulties across all three areas. Results found that the number of comorbid conditions significantly predicted the severity of children’s reading difficulty. A similar pattern emerged for executive function task performance, although this was not uniform across all aspects assessed. The results are discussed in relation to implications for service provision and intervention strategies.

KW - reading difficulties

KW - school children

KW - developmental difficulties

KW - ADHD

KW - specific language impairment

KW - comorbid conditions

KW - executive functions

KW - intervention strategies

UR - http://www.bps.org.uk/networks-and-communities/member-microsite/developmental-psychology-section/previous-conferences

UR - http://www.bps.org.uk/sites/default/files/images/dev_2011_collated_final_program_220811_sml.pdf

M3 - Paper

SP - 50

ER -

Booth J, Boyle J, Kelly S. Reading difficulties, comorbid conditions and executive functions: An evaluation of the additive risk model. 2011. Paper presented at British Psychological Society Developmental Psychology Section Annual Conference 2011, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.