Quantification of rhythm problems in disordered speech: a re-evaluation

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Disordered speech can present with rhythmic problems, impacting on an individual’s ability to communicate. Effective treatment relies on the availability of sensitive methods to characterise the problem. Rhythm metrics based on segmental durations originally designed for crosslinguistic research have the potential to provide such information. However, these measures may be associated with problems that impact on their clinical usefulness. This paper aims to address the perceptual validity of crosslinguistic metrics as indicators of rhythmic disorder. Speakers with dysarthria and matched healthy participants performed a range of tasks, including syllable and sentence repetition tasks and a spontaneous monologue. A range of rhythm metrics as well as clinical measures were applied. Results showed that none of the metrics could differentiate disordered from healthy speakers, despite clear perceptual differences, suggesting that factors beyond segment duration impacted on rhythm perception. The investigation also highlighted a number of areas where caution needs to be exercised in the application of rhythm metrics to disordered speech. The paper concludes that the underlying speech impairment leading to the perceptual and acoustic characterisation of rhythmic problems needs to be established through detailed analysis of speech characteristics in order to construct effective treatment plans for individuals with speech disorders.
LanguageEnglish
Article number20130404
Number of pages12
JournalPhilosophical Transactions B: Biological Sciences
Volume369
Issue number1658
Early online date10 Nov 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2014

Fingerprint

Speech Disorders
Dysarthria
Aptitude
Acoustics
duration
Healthy Volunteers
acoustics
Availability
Therapeutics
Research
methodology

Keywords

  • rhythm metrics
  • dysarthria
  • acoustic analysis
  • ataxia
  • Parkinson's Disease

Cite this

@article{d4a6028c342841ebbd1c7634520e1c95,
title = "Quantification of rhythm problems in disordered speech: a re-evaluation",
abstract = "Disordered speech can present with rhythmic problems, impacting on an individual’s ability to communicate. Effective treatment relies on the availability of sensitive methods to characterise the problem. Rhythm metrics based on segmental durations originally designed for crosslinguistic research have the potential to provide such information. However, these measures may be associated with problems that impact on their clinical usefulness. This paper aims to address the perceptual validity of crosslinguistic metrics as indicators of rhythmic disorder. Speakers with dysarthria and matched healthy participants performed a range of tasks, including syllable and sentence repetition tasks and a spontaneous monologue. A range of rhythm metrics as well as clinical measures were applied. Results showed that none of the metrics could differentiate disordered from healthy speakers, despite clear perceptual differences, suggesting that factors beyond segment duration impacted on rhythm perception. The investigation also highlighted a number of areas where caution needs to be exercised in the application of rhythm metrics to disordered speech. The paper concludes that the underlying speech impairment leading to the perceptual and acoustic characterisation of rhythmic problems needs to be established through detailed analysis of speech characteristics in order to construct effective treatment plans for individuals with speech disorders.",
keywords = "rhythm metrics, dysarthria, acoustic analysis, ataxia, Parkinson's Disease",
author = "Anja Lowit",
year = "2014",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1098/rstb.2013.0404",
language = "English",
volume = "369",
journal = "Philosophical Transactions B: Biological Sciences",
issn = "0962-8436",
number = "1658",

}

Quantification of rhythm problems in disordered speech : a re-evaluation. / Lowit, Anja.

In: Philosophical Transactions B: Biological Sciences , Vol. 369, No. 1658, 20130404, 12.2014.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Quantification of rhythm problems in disordered speech

T2 - Philosophical Transactions B: Biological Sciences

AU - Lowit, Anja

PY - 2014/12

Y1 - 2014/12

N2 - Disordered speech can present with rhythmic problems, impacting on an individual’s ability to communicate. Effective treatment relies on the availability of sensitive methods to characterise the problem. Rhythm metrics based on segmental durations originally designed for crosslinguistic research have the potential to provide such information. However, these measures may be associated with problems that impact on their clinical usefulness. This paper aims to address the perceptual validity of crosslinguistic metrics as indicators of rhythmic disorder. Speakers with dysarthria and matched healthy participants performed a range of tasks, including syllable and sentence repetition tasks and a spontaneous monologue. A range of rhythm metrics as well as clinical measures were applied. Results showed that none of the metrics could differentiate disordered from healthy speakers, despite clear perceptual differences, suggesting that factors beyond segment duration impacted on rhythm perception. The investigation also highlighted a number of areas where caution needs to be exercised in the application of rhythm metrics to disordered speech. The paper concludes that the underlying speech impairment leading to the perceptual and acoustic characterisation of rhythmic problems needs to be established through detailed analysis of speech characteristics in order to construct effective treatment plans for individuals with speech disorders.

AB - Disordered speech can present with rhythmic problems, impacting on an individual’s ability to communicate. Effective treatment relies on the availability of sensitive methods to characterise the problem. Rhythm metrics based on segmental durations originally designed for crosslinguistic research have the potential to provide such information. However, these measures may be associated with problems that impact on their clinical usefulness. This paper aims to address the perceptual validity of crosslinguistic metrics as indicators of rhythmic disorder. Speakers with dysarthria and matched healthy participants performed a range of tasks, including syllable and sentence repetition tasks and a spontaneous monologue. A range of rhythm metrics as well as clinical measures were applied. Results showed that none of the metrics could differentiate disordered from healthy speakers, despite clear perceptual differences, suggesting that factors beyond segment duration impacted on rhythm perception. The investigation also highlighted a number of areas where caution needs to be exercised in the application of rhythm metrics to disordered speech. The paper concludes that the underlying speech impairment leading to the perceptual and acoustic characterisation of rhythmic problems needs to be established through detailed analysis of speech characteristics in order to construct effective treatment plans for individuals with speech disorders.

KW - rhythm metrics

KW - dysarthria

KW - acoustic analysis

KW - ataxia

KW - Parkinson's Disease

UR - http://rstb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/by/year

U2 - 10.1098/rstb.2013.0404

DO - 10.1098/rstb.2013.0404

M3 - Article

VL - 369

JO - Philosophical Transactions B: Biological Sciences

JF - Philosophical Transactions B: Biological Sciences

SN - 0962-8436

IS - 1658

M1 - 20130404

ER -