Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery

George Macgregor, Emma McCulloch

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

Abstract

Although services offering collaborative tagging provide rich interactive experiences that exemplify a sense of community among disparate user groups, their raison d'être ultimately remains similar to traditional information retrieval systems. In this paper we will explore potential conflict between user requirements for PIM and CIM, and the theme of popularity over relevance by revisiting basic information retrieval principles within the context of collaborative tagging. The long-term implications of these factors for the efficacy of collaborative tagging in general resource discovery will also be examined. The theoretical analysis presented suggests that PIM requirements conflict with the wider requirements of resource discovery by invoking a series of extra relevance variables and that emphasis on popularly used tags and the subsequent effect on ‘collective behavior’ potentially compromises the effectiveness of system performance. Hypotheses are proposed for testing and further research areas are suggested.
LanguageEnglish
Place of PublicationGlasgow
PublisherUniversity of Strathclyde
Pages1-5
Number of pages5
Publication statusUnpublished - 19 Dec 2005

Fingerprint

Information retrieval systems
Information retrieval
Testing

Keywords

  • collaborative tagging
  • resource discovery
  • information retrieval
  • knowledge organization
  • controlled vocabularies
  • PIM noise
  • personal information management tools

Cite this

Macgregor, G., & McCulloch, E. (2005). Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery. (pp. 1-5). Glasgow: University of Strathclyde.
Macgregor, George ; McCulloch, Emma. / Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery. Glasgow : University of Strathclyde, 2005. pp. 1-5
@techreport{9bbee47b2d0546599aea47db335909c9,
title = "Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery",
abstract = "Although services offering collaborative tagging provide rich interactive experiences that exemplify a sense of community among disparate user groups, their raison d'{\^e}tre ultimately remains similar to traditional information retrieval systems. In this paper we will explore potential conflict between user requirements for PIM and CIM, and the theme of popularity over relevance by revisiting basic information retrieval principles within the context of collaborative tagging. The long-term implications of these factors for the efficacy of collaborative tagging in general resource discovery will also be examined. The theoretical analysis presented suggests that PIM requirements conflict with the wider requirements of resource discovery by invoking a series of extra relevance variables and that emphasis on popularly used tags and the subsequent effect on ‘collective behavior’ potentially compromises the effectiveness of system performance. Hypotheses are proposed for testing and further research areas are suggested.",
keywords = "collaborative tagging, resource discovery, information retrieval, knowledge organization, controlled vocabularies, PIM noise, personal information management tools",
author = "George Macgregor and Emma McCulloch",
note = "Unpublished discussion paper.",
year = "2005",
month = "12",
day = "19",
language = "English",
pages = "1--5",
publisher = "University of Strathclyde",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "University of Strathclyde",

}

Macgregor, G & McCulloch, E 2005 'Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery' University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, pp. 1-5.

Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery. / Macgregor, George; McCulloch, Emma.

Glasgow : University of Strathclyde, 2005. p. 1-5.

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

TY - UNPB

T1 - Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery

AU - Macgregor, George

AU - McCulloch, Emma

N1 - Unpublished discussion paper.

PY - 2005/12/19

Y1 - 2005/12/19

N2 - Although services offering collaborative tagging provide rich interactive experiences that exemplify a sense of community among disparate user groups, their raison d'être ultimately remains similar to traditional information retrieval systems. In this paper we will explore potential conflict between user requirements for PIM and CIM, and the theme of popularity over relevance by revisiting basic information retrieval principles within the context of collaborative tagging. The long-term implications of these factors for the efficacy of collaborative tagging in general resource discovery will also be examined. The theoretical analysis presented suggests that PIM requirements conflict with the wider requirements of resource discovery by invoking a series of extra relevance variables and that emphasis on popularly used tags and the subsequent effect on ‘collective behavior’ potentially compromises the effectiveness of system performance. Hypotheses are proposed for testing and further research areas are suggested.

AB - Although services offering collaborative tagging provide rich interactive experiences that exemplify a sense of community among disparate user groups, their raison d'être ultimately remains similar to traditional information retrieval systems. In this paper we will explore potential conflict between user requirements for PIM and CIM, and the theme of popularity over relevance by revisiting basic information retrieval principles within the context of collaborative tagging. The long-term implications of these factors for the efficacy of collaborative tagging in general resource discovery will also be examined. The theoretical analysis presented suggests that PIM requirements conflict with the wider requirements of resource discovery by invoking a series of extra relevance variables and that emphasis on popularly used tags and the subsequent effect on ‘collective behavior’ potentially compromises the effectiveness of system performance. Hypotheses are proposed for testing and further research areas are suggested.

KW - collaborative tagging

KW - resource discovery

KW - information retrieval

KW - knowledge organization

KW - controlled vocabularies

KW - PIM noise

KW - personal information management tools

M3 - Discussion paper

SP - 1

EP - 5

BT - Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery

PB - University of Strathclyde

CY - Glasgow

ER -

Macgregor G, McCulloch E. Popularity over Relevance in Collaborative Tagging Systems for General Resource Discovery. Glasgow: University of Strathclyde. 2005 Dec 19, p. 1-5.