Pictures are necessary but not sufficient: using a range of visual methods to engage users about school design

Pamela Woolner, Jill Clark, Elaine Hall, Lucy Tiplady, Ulrike Thomas, Kate Wall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

42 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

It has been argued by both educationalists and social researchers that visual methods are particularly appropriate for the investigation of people's experiences of the school environment. The current and expected building work taking place in British schools provides an opportunity for exploration of methods, as well as a need to establish ways to achieve this involvement of a range of school users, including students. This article describes a consultation that was undertaken in a UK secondary school as part of a participatory design process centred on the rebuilding of the school. A range of visual methods, based on photographs and maps, was used to investigate the views of a diverse sample of school users, including students, teachers, technical and support staff and the wider community. Reported here is the experience of using these tools, considering the success of different visually-based methods in engaging a broad cross section of the school community and revealing useful information. Using a range of visual methods allows a complex, but coherent, understanding of the particular school environment to be constructed and developed. It is further argued that such a range of visual and spatial methods is needed to develop appropriate understanding. The study, therefore, contributes to knowledge about specific visual research methods, appreciation of the relationship between tools, and a general methodological understanding of visual methods' utility for developing understanding of the learning environment.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1-22
Number of pages22
JournalLearning Environments Research
Volume13
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Mar 2010

Fingerprint

Students
school
student teacher
community
research method
Workplace
secondary school
experience
learning environment
Referral and Consultation
staff
Research Personnel
Learning
Research
student

Keywords

  • map-based activities
  • participatory social research
  • school design
  • school environment
  • visual methods

Cite this

Woolner, Pamela ; Clark, Jill ; Hall, Elaine ; Tiplady, Lucy ; Thomas, Ulrike ; Wall, Kate. / Pictures are necessary but not sufficient : using a range of visual methods to engage users about school design. In: Learning Environments Research. 2010 ; Vol. 13, No. 1. pp. 1-22.
@article{e7659eabe9924becb8a33292ac4c8947,
title = "Pictures are necessary but not sufficient: using a range of visual methods to engage users about school design",
abstract = "It has been argued by both educationalists and social researchers that visual methods are particularly appropriate for the investigation of people's experiences of the school environment. The current and expected building work taking place in British schools provides an opportunity for exploration of methods, as well as a need to establish ways to achieve this involvement of a range of school users, including students. This article describes a consultation that was undertaken in a UK secondary school as part of a participatory design process centred on the rebuilding of the school. A range of visual methods, based on photographs and maps, was used to investigate the views of a diverse sample of school users, including students, teachers, technical and support staff and the wider community. Reported here is the experience of using these tools, considering the success of different visually-based methods in engaging a broad cross section of the school community and revealing useful information. Using a range of visual methods allows a complex, but coherent, understanding of the particular school environment to be constructed and developed. It is further argued that such a range of visual and spatial methods is needed to develop appropriate understanding. The study, therefore, contributes to knowledge about specific visual research methods, appreciation of the relationship between tools, and a general methodological understanding of visual methods' utility for developing understanding of the learning environment.",
keywords = "map-based activities, participatory social research, school design, school environment, visual methods",
author = "Pamela Woolner and Jill Clark and Elaine Hall and Lucy Tiplady and Ulrike Thomas and Kate Wall",
year = "2010",
month = "3",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1007/s10984-009-9067-6",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "1--22",
journal = "Learning Environments Research",
issn = "1387-1579",
number = "1",

}

Pictures are necessary but not sufficient : using a range of visual methods to engage users about school design. / Woolner, Pamela; Clark, Jill; Hall, Elaine; Tiplady, Lucy; Thomas, Ulrike; Wall, Kate.

In: Learning Environments Research, Vol. 13, No. 1, 31.03.2010, p. 1-22.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pictures are necessary but not sufficient

T2 - Learning Environments Research

AU - Woolner, Pamela

AU - Clark, Jill

AU - Hall, Elaine

AU - Tiplady, Lucy

AU - Thomas, Ulrike

AU - Wall, Kate

PY - 2010/3/31

Y1 - 2010/3/31

N2 - It has been argued by both educationalists and social researchers that visual methods are particularly appropriate for the investigation of people's experiences of the school environment. The current and expected building work taking place in British schools provides an opportunity for exploration of methods, as well as a need to establish ways to achieve this involvement of a range of school users, including students. This article describes a consultation that was undertaken in a UK secondary school as part of a participatory design process centred on the rebuilding of the school. A range of visual methods, based on photographs and maps, was used to investigate the views of a diverse sample of school users, including students, teachers, technical and support staff and the wider community. Reported here is the experience of using these tools, considering the success of different visually-based methods in engaging a broad cross section of the school community and revealing useful information. Using a range of visual methods allows a complex, but coherent, understanding of the particular school environment to be constructed and developed. It is further argued that such a range of visual and spatial methods is needed to develop appropriate understanding. The study, therefore, contributes to knowledge about specific visual research methods, appreciation of the relationship between tools, and a general methodological understanding of visual methods' utility for developing understanding of the learning environment.

AB - It has been argued by both educationalists and social researchers that visual methods are particularly appropriate for the investigation of people's experiences of the school environment. The current and expected building work taking place in British schools provides an opportunity for exploration of methods, as well as a need to establish ways to achieve this involvement of a range of school users, including students. This article describes a consultation that was undertaken in a UK secondary school as part of a participatory design process centred on the rebuilding of the school. A range of visual methods, based on photographs and maps, was used to investigate the views of a diverse sample of school users, including students, teachers, technical and support staff and the wider community. Reported here is the experience of using these tools, considering the success of different visually-based methods in engaging a broad cross section of the school community and revealing useful information. Using a range of visual methods allows a complex, but coherent, understanding of the particular school environment to be constructed and developed. It is further argued that such a range of visual and spatial methods is needed to develop appropriate understanding. The study, therefore, contributes to knowledge about specific visual research methods, appreciation of the relationship between tools, and a general methodological understanding of visual methods' utility for developing understanding of the learning environment.

KW - map-based activities

KW - participatory social research

KW - school design

KW - school environment

KW - visual methods

U2 - 10.1007/s10984-009-9067-6

DO - 10.1007/s10984-009-9067-6

M3 - Article

VL - 13

SP - 1

EP - 22

JO - Learning Environments Research

JF - Learning Environments Research

SN - 1387-1579

IS - 1

ER -