Personal space: bring on the physics revolution

John B. Davies

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Some years ago a student submitted a practical assignment in which he wrote something along these lines: I collected the data on Sauchiehall Street on Friday afternoon. I asked any young-looking males (who didnt look too scary!) to fill in the questionnaire. It started to rain about four oclock so I went in Costa Coffee, and when I came out there werent so many people about, so I finished it off on Saturday morning. Colleagues felt this was inappropriate in a practical essay on a scientific subject. They objected to the use of the word I, which by definition made it a subjective account; and they suggested that a phrase such as Data were collected from a random sample of young males would have been more suitable. But I disagreed strongly, arguing that the student account was more informative, more scientific, more honest, and there was no attempt to hide behind scientific rhetoric. And obviously, the sample could not be called random.
LanguageEnglish
Pages692-693
Number of pages1
JournalThe Psychologist
Volume17
Issue number12
Publication statusPublished - 2004

Fingerprint

Personal Space
Physics
Students
Rain
Coffee

Keywords

  • physics
  • numerical mathematics

Cite this

Davies, J. B. (2004). Personal space: bring on the physics revolution. The Psychologist, 17(12), 692-693.
Davies, John B. / Personal space : bring on the physics revolution. In: The Psychologist. 2004 ; Vol. 17, No. 12. pp. 692-693.
@article{469f640562a94c0492942950855bce92,
title = "Personal space: bring on the physics revolution",
abstract = "Some years ago a student submitted a practical assignment in which he wrote something along these lines: I collected the data on Sauchiehall Street on Friday afternoon. I asked any young-looking males (who didnt look too scary!) to fill in the questionnaire. It started to rain about four oclock so I went in Costa Coffee, and when I came out there werent so many people about, so I finished it off on Saturday morning. Colleagues felt this was inappropriate in a practical essay on a scientific subject. They objected to the use of the word I, which by definition made it a subjective account; and they suggested that a phrase such as Data were collected from a random sample of young males would have been more suitable. But I disagreed strongly, arguing that the student account was more informative, more scientific, more honest, and there was no attempt to hide behind scientific rhetoric. And obviously, the sample could not be called random.",
keywords = "physics, numerical mathematics",
author = "Davies, {John B.}",
year = "2004",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "692--693",
journal = "The Psychologist",
issn = "0952-8229",
publisher = "British Psychological Society",
number = "12",

}

Davies, JB 2004, 'Personal space: bring on the physics revolution' The Psychologist, vol. 17, no. 12, pp. 692-693.

Personal space : bring on the physics revolution. / Davies, John B.

In: The Psychologist, Vol. 17, No. 12, 2004, p. 692-693.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Personal space

T2 - The Psychologist

AU - Davies, John B.

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - Some years ago a student submitted a practical assignment in which he wrote something along these lines: I collected the data on Sauchiehall Street on Friday afternoon. I asked any young-looking males (who didnt look too scary!) to fill in the questionnaire. It started to rain about four oclock so I went in Costa Coffee, and when I came out there werent so many people about, so I finished it off on Saturday morning. Colleagues felt this was inappropriate in a practical essay on a scientific subject. They objected to the use of the word I, which by definition made it a subjective account; and they suggested that a phrase such as Data were collected from a random sample of young males would have been more suitable. But I disagreed strongly, arguing that the student account was more informative, more scientific, more honest, and there was no attempt to hide behind scientific rhetoric. And obviously, the sample could not be called random.

AB - Some years ago a student submitted a practical assignment in which he wrote something along these lines: I collected the data on Sauchiehall Street on Friday afternoon. I asked any young-looking males (who didnt look too scary!) to fill in the questionnaire. It started to rain about four oclock so I went in Costa Coffee, and when I came out there werent so many people about, so I finished it off on Saturday morning. Colleagues felt this was inappropriate in a practical essay on a scientific subject. They objected to the use of the word I, which by definition made it a subjective account; and they suggested that a phrase such as Data were collected from a random sample of young males would have been more suitable. But I disagreed strongly, arguing that the student account was more informative, more scientific, more honest, and there was no attempt to hide behind scientific rhetoric. And obviously, the sample could not be called random.

KW - physics

KW - numerical mathematics

UR - http://www.bps.org.uk/

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 692

EP - 693

JO - The Psychologist

JF - The Psychologist

SN - 0952-8229

IS - 12

ER -