Performance of models for radiocarbon dating of groundwater: an appraisal using selected irish aquifers

Desmond Robert Gallagher, EJ McGee, Robert Kalin, PI Mitchell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Appropriate management strategies are essential for the protection and maintenance of groundwater resources. It is therefore important that aquifers are understood in terms of hydraulics, recharge, and yield potential, and that the vulnerability of aquifers to surface pollution is evaluated. A range of aquifer types were examined in this study, and water samples were analyzed for the radiocarbon content of the total dissolved inorganic carbon (TDIC), stable isotopes, and a suite of chemical and physical parameters. The data were input to a selection of models for the estimation of the initial activity of the TDIC, and groundwater ages were calculated. Eight commonly used models were comparatively assessed in the study. The Tamers, Mook, and IAEA models gave anomalous ages, probably because of their inability to correct for solid phase isotopic exchange in aquifers. The Pearson, F&G, Evans, Eichinger, and Mass Balance models produced results in broad agreement. The study shows that contrary to popular belief, there are sources of ancient groundwater in Ireland. Of the 19 sampling stations, two boreholes yielded waters with age estimates of greater than 10,000 BP. Water samples from a further six sites returned ages of between around 800 and 4000 BP. In contrast to borehole samples,spring wells yielded water of consistently young ages, demonstrating rapid recharge and flow mechanisms. Samples from several spring wells produced negative ages, indicating the presence of anthropogenic C-14 The findings demonstrate the potential for contamination of springs by surface runoff, while sources of greater age generally offer a greater degree of protection from surface pollution.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)235-248
Number of pages14
JournalRadiocarbon
Volume42
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2000

Fingerprint

radiocarbon dating
Aquifers
Groundwater
aquifer
Springs (water)
groundwater
Water
Boreholes
Pollution
Carbon
Groundwater resources
dissolved inorganic carbon
Runoff
recharge
Isotopes
borehole
Contamination
Hydraulics
pollution
Sampling

Keywords

  • groundwater
  • radiocarbon dating
  • irish aquifers
  • aquifers

Cite this

Gallagher, Desmond Robert ; McGee, EJ ; Kalin, Robert ; Mitchell, PI. / Performance of models for radiocarbon dating of groundwater: an appraisal using selected irish aquifers. In: Radiocarbon. 2000 ; Vol. 42, No. 2. pp. 235-248.
@article{be08f998aa234777a47f73c8dca0fc0e,
title = "Performance of models for radiocarbon dating of groundwater: an appraisal using selected irish aquifers",
abstract = "Appropriate management strategies are essential for the protection and maintenance of groundwater resources. It is therefore important that aquifers are understood in terms of hydraulics, recharge, and yield potential, and that the vulnerability of aquifers to surface pollution is evaluated. A range of aquifer types were examined in this study, and water samples were analyzed for the radiocarbon content of the total dissolved inorganic carbon (TDIC), stable isotopes, and a suite of chemical and physical parameters. The data were input to a selection of models for the estimation of the initial activity of the TDIC, and groundwater ages were calculated. Eight commonly used models were comparatively assessed in the study. The Tamers, Mook, and IAEA models gave anomalous ages, probably because of their inability to correct for solid phase isotopic exchange in aquifers. The Pearson, F&G, Evans, Eichinger, and Mass Balance models produced results in broad agreement. The study shows that contrary to popular belief, there are sources of ancient groundwater in Ireland. Of the 19 sampling stations, two boreholes yielded waters with age estimates of greater than 10,000 BP. Water samples from a further six sites returned ages of between around 800 and 4000 BP. In contrast to borehole samples,spring wells yielded water of consistently young ages, demonstrating rapid recharge and flow mechanisms. Samples from several spring wells produced negative ages, indicating the presence of anthropogenic C-14 The findings demonstrate the potential for contamination of springs by surface runoff, while sources of greater age generally offer a greater degree of protection from surface pollution.",
keywords = "groundwater, radiocarbon dating , irish aquifers , aquifers",
author = "Gallagher, {Desmond Robert} and EJ McGee and Robert Kalin and PI Mitchell",
year = "2000",
language = "English",
volume = "42",
pages = "235--248",
journal = "Radiocarbon",
issn = "0033-8222",
number = "2",

}

Performance of models for radiocarbon dating of groundwater: an appraisal using selected irish aquifers. / Gallagher, Desmond Robert; McGee, EJ; Kalin, Robert; Mitchell, PI.

In: Radiocarbon, Vol. 42, No. 2, 2000, p. 235-248.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Performance of models for radiocarbon dating of groundwater: an appraisal using selected irish aquifers

AU - Gallagher, Desmond Robert

AU - McGee, EJ

AU - Kalin, Robert

AU - Mitchell, PI

PY - 2000

Y1 - 2000

N2 - Appropriate management strategies are essential for the protection and maintenance of groundwater resources. It is therefore important that aquifers are understood in terms of hydraulics, recharge, and yield potential, and that the vulnerability of aquifers to surface pollution is evaluated. A range of aquifer types were examined in this study, and water samples were analyzed for the radiocarbon content of the total dissolved inorganic carbon (TDIC), stable isotopes, and a suite of chemical and physical parameters. The data were input to a selection of models for the estimation of the initial activity of the TDIC, and groundwater ages were calculated. Eight commonly used models were comparatively assessed in the study. The Tamers, Mook, and IAEA models gave anomalous ages, probably because of their inability to correct for solid phase isotopic exchange in aquifers. The Pearson, F&G, Evans, Eichinger, and Mass Balance models produced results in broad agreement. The study shows that contrary to popular belief, there are sources of ancient groundwater in Ireland. Of the 19 sampling stations, two boreholes yielded waters with age estimates of greater than 10,000 BP. Water samples from a further six sites returned ages of between around 800 and 4000 BP. In contrast to borehole samples,spring wells yielded water of consistently young ages, demonstrating rapid recharge and flow mechanisms. Samples from several spring wells produced negative ages, indicating the presence of anthropogenic C-14 The findings demonstrate the potential for contamination of springs by surface runoff, while sources of greater age generally offer a greater degree of protection from surface pollution.

AB - Appropriate management strategies are essential for the protection and maintenance of groundwater resources. It is therefore important that aquifers are understood in terms of hydraulics, recharge, and yield potential, and that the vulnerability of aquifers to surface pollution is evaluated. A range of aquifer types were examined in this study, and water samples were analyzed for the radiocarbon content of the total dissolved inorganic carbon (TDIC), stable isotopes, and a suite of chemical and physical parameters. The data were input to a selection of models for the estimation of the initial activity of the TDIC, and groundwater ages were calculated. Eight commonly used models were comparatively assessed in the study. The Tamers, Mook, and IAEA models gave anomalous ages, probably because of their inability to correct for solid phase isotopic exchange in aquifers. The Pearson, F&G, Evans, Eichinger, and Mass Balance models produced results in broad agreement. The study shows that contrary to popular belief, there are sources of ancient groundwater in Ireland. Of the 19 sampling stations, two boreholes yielded waters with age estimates of greater than 10,000 BP. Water samples from a further six sites returned ages of between around 800 and 4000 BP. In contrast to borehole samples,spring wells yielded water of consistently young ages, demonstrating rapid recharge and flow mechanisms. Samples from several spring wells produced negative ages, indicating the presence of anthropogenic C-14 The findings demonstrate the potential for contamination of springs by surface runoff, while sources of greater age generally offer a greater degree of protection from surface pollution.

KW - groundwater

KW - radiocarbon dating

KW - irish aquifers

KW - aquifers

UR - https://journals.uair.arizona.edu/index.php/radiocarbon/article/view/3841/3266

UR - https://journals.uair.arizona.edu/index.php/radiocarbon/article/view/3841

M3 - Article

VL - 42

SP - 235

EP - 248

JO - Radiocarbon

JF - Radiocarbon

SN - 0033-8222

IS - 2

ER -