Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context

Natasha Nabi, Kate Tweats, Karen Logan, Stacey Moore, Amy McMurdo, Shivani Vani, Nicola Cogan, Leanne Fleming

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

While previous studies have investigated sleep issues in chronic illness and the effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I), this has not been examined within palliative care. High rates of sleep difficulties have been found in patients receiving palliative care. We aimed to explore the practical feasibility of implementing CBT-I among palliative patients using techniques such as stimulus control therapy, progressive muscle relaxation and guided imagery/thought blocking. However, issues such as the intervention protocols being relatively labor intensive and time consuming for participants that were receiving palliative care, involving completion of daily diaries and quantitative outcome measures, led to high non-completion rates among participants. Consequently, a shift in methodology was required and a qualitative approach was adopted to explore participants’ experiences of sleep disturbance within palliative care. The aim was to gain an in-depth understanding of the specific issues and challenges within palliative care that impacted on sleep. Focus groups were conducted with patients, informal carers and hospice staff who all described how they experienced sleep difficulties. This provided a broader understanding of insomnia from multiple perspectives within palliative care. Furthermore, it helped inform how we will go about designing future studies in CBT-I in palliative care; having illuminated the appropriate adaptions required to current protocols. This case study will discuss the complexities and ethical issues we faced at each stage of the research process and how adopting both quantitative and qualitative approaches helped provide useful insights that will inform future research.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages22
JournalSAGE Research Methods Cases
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 1 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

Vulnerable Populations
Palliative Care
Sleep Initiation and Maintenance Disorders
Sleep
Cognitive Therapy
Autogenic Training
Hospices
Imagery (Psychotherapy)
Focus Groups
Ethics
Caregivers
Chronic Disease
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Research

Keywords

  • palliative care
  • insomnia
  • CBT
  • focus groups
  • qualitative
  • vulnerable groups

Cite this

Nabi, N., Tweats, K., Logan, K., Moore, S., McMurdo, A., Vani, S., ... Fleming, L. (Accepted/In press). Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context. SAGE Research Methods Cases.
Nabi, Natasha ; Tweats, Kate ; Logan, Karen ; Moore, Stacey ; McMurdo, Amy ; Vani, Shivani ; Cogan, Nicola ; Fleming, Leanne. / Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context. In: SAGE Research Methods Cases. 2019.
@article{d57d56862951413e82c94d5b6e7cc76d,
title = "Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context",
abstract = "While previous studies have investigated sleep issues in chronic illness and the effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I), this has not been examined within palliative care. High rates of sleep difficulties have been found in patients receiving palliative care. We aimed to explore the practical feasibility of implementing CBT-I among palliative patients using techniques such as stimulus control therapy, progressive muscle relaxation and guided imagery/thought blocking. However, issues such as the intervention protocols being relatively labor intensive and time consuming for participants that were receiving palliative care, involving completion of daily diaries and quantitative outcome measures, led to high non-completion rates among participants. Consequently, a shift in methodology was required and a qualitative approach was adopted to explore participants’ experiences of sleep disturbance within palliative care. The aim was to gain an in-depth understanding of the specific issues and challenges within palliative care that impacted on sleep. Focus groups were conducted with patients, informal carers and hospice staff who all described how they experienced sleep difficulties. This provided a broader understanding of insomnia from multiple perspectives within palliative care. Furthermore, it helped inform how we will go about designing future studies in CBT-I in palliative care; having illuminated the appropriate adaptions required to current protocols. This case study will discuss the complexities and ethical issues we faced at each stage of the research process and how adopting both quantitative and qualitative approaches helped provide useful insights that will inform future research.",
keywords = "palliative care, insomnia, CBT, focus groups, qualitative, vulnerable groups",
author = "Natasha Nabi and Kate Tweats and Karen Logan and Stacey Moore and Amy McMurdo and Shivani Vani and Nicola Cogan and Leanne Fleming",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "1",
language = "English",

}

Nabi, N, Tweats, K, Logan, K, Moore, S, McMurdo, A, Vani, S, Cogan, N & Fleming, L 2019, 'Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context', SAGE Research Methods Cases.

Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context. / Nabi, Natasha; Tweats, Kate; Logan, Karen; Moore, Stacey; McMurdo, Amy; Vani, Shivani ; Cogan, Nicola; Fleming, Leanne.

In: SAGE Research Methods Cases, 01.04.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context

AU - Nabi, Natasha

AU - Tweats, Kate

AU - Logan, Karen

AU - Moore, Stacey

AU - McMurdo, Amy

AU - Vani, Shivani

AU - Cogan, Nicola

AU - Fleming, Leanne

PY - 2019/4/1

Y1 - 2019/4/1

N2 - While previous studies have investigated sleep issues in chronic illness and the effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I), this has not been examined within palliative care. High rates of sleep difficulties have been found in patients receiving palliative care. We aimed to explore the practical feasibility of implementing CBT-I among palliative patients using techniques such as stimulus control therapy, progressive muscle relaxation and guided imagery/thought blocking. However, issues such as the intervention protocols being relatively labor intensive and time consuming for participants that were receiving palliative care, involving completion of daily diaries and quantitative outcome measures, led to high non-completion rates among participants. Consequently, a shift in methodology was required and a qualitative approach was adopted to explore participants’ experiences of sleep disturbance within palliative care. The aim was to gain an in-depth understanding of the specific issues and challenges within palliative care that impacted on sleep. Focus groups were conducted with patients, informal carers and hospice staff who all described how they experienced sleep difficulties. This provided a broader understanding of insomnia from multiple perspectives within palliative care. Furthermore, it helped inform how we will go about designing future studies in CBT-I in palliative care; having illuminated the appropriate adaptions required to current protocols. This case study will discuss the complexities and ethical issues we faced at each stage of the research process and how adopting both quantitative and qualitative approaches helped provide useful insights that will inform future research.

AB - While previous studies have investigated sleep issues in chronic illness and the effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I), this has not been examined within palliative care. High rates of sleep difficulties have been found in patients receiving palliative care. We aimed to explore the practical feasibility of implementing CBT-I among palliative patients using techniques such as stimulus control therapy, progressive muscle relaxation and guided imagery/thought blocking. However, issues such as the intervention protocols being relatively labor intensive and time consuming for participants that were receiving palliative care, involving completion of daily diaries and quantitative outcome measures, led to high non-completion rates among participants. Consequently, a shift in methodology was required and a qualitative approach was adopted to explore participants’ experiences of sleep disturbance within palliative care. The aim was to gain an in-depth understanding of the specific issues and challenges within palliative care that impacted on sleep. Focus groups were conducted with patients, informal carers and hospice staff who all described how they experienced sleep difficulties. This provided a broader understanding of insomnia from multiple perspectives within palliative care. Furthermore, it helped inform how we will go about designing future studies in CBT-I in palliative care; having illuminated the appropriate adaptions required to current protocols. This case study will discuss the complexities and ethical issues we faced at each stage of the research process and how adopting both quantitative and qualitative approaches helped provide useful insights that will inform future research.

KW - palliative care

KW - insomnia

KW - CBT

KW - focus groups

KW - qualitative

KW - vulnerable groups

UR - http://methods.sagepub.com/cases

M3 - Article

ER -

Nabi N, Tweats K, Logan K, Moore S, McMurdo A, Vani S et al. Overcoming the challenges and complexities of researching a vulnerable population within a palliative care context. SAGE Research Methods Cases. 2019 Apr 1.