On the importance of generating accurate turbulent boundary condition for unsteady simulations

Z. A. Rana, B. Thornber, D. Drikakis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

21 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Turbulence is generally characterized by random, chaotic motion and has always been a challenging problem for fluid dynamists. Several methods for generating turbulent boundary conditions for computational fluid dynamics are in use today. One of the methods is by adding random white-noise to the averaged velocity profiles to generate turbulence in the flow field, which can be considered as the simplest and inexpensive method. Recently, another method has been introduced, which is based upon a digital filter to generate turbulent inflow data. This paper presents a comparison of the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique with three different methods within the framework of the large eddy simulations technique using the fifth- and second-order accurate methods in space and time, respectively. The case for comparison/analysis is a sonic jet of air injected transversely into a supersonic (Mach 1.6) stream of air, for which experimental and classical large eddy simulation data were available. It is demonstrated that the random white-noise-based turbulent inflow data dissipate immediately in the computational domain, giving incorrect velocity and pressure profiles. At the same time, the importance of two-point Exponential correlation used in the digital filter-based technique is demonstrated by scaling the random white-noise with the Reynolds stress tensor and ignoring the correlation. This improved the results compared with pure random white-noise, but still exhibits a high initial dissipation rate because the energy is not distributed over the required range of wavenumbers. It is demonstrated that the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique provides a reliable, accurate and consistent turbulent boundary layer in the flow field, which is required for the capture of correct flow physics. It is also demonstrated that the computational cost involved in all the methods presented is almost identical.
LanguageEnglish
Article number35
Pages1-39
Number of pages39
JournalJournal of Turbulence
Volume12
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 7 Oct 2011

Fingerprint

digital filters
White noise
Digital filters
white noise
Boundary conditions
boundary conditions
Large eddy simulation
large eddy simulation
Flow fields
flow distribution
Turbulence
simulation
velocity distribution
turbulence
air
turbulent boundary layer
Reynolds stress
stress tensors
computational fluid dynamics
Air

Keywords

  • compressible flows
  • digital filter
  • jet in supersonic cross-flow
  • turbulence
  • turbulent mixing
  • accuracy assessment
  • chaotic dynamics
  • compressible flow
  • computational fluid dynamics
  • flow field
  • inflow
  • jet flow
  • large eddy simulation
  • Reynolds number
  • turbulent boundary layer
  • unsteady flow
  • velocity profile
  • white noise
  • boundary condition
  • comparative study
  • computer simulation
  • flow velocity

Cite this

Rana, Z. A. ; Thornber, B. ; Drikakis, D. / On the importance of generating accurate turbulent boundary condition for unsteady simulations. In: Journal of Turbulence. 2011 ; Vol. 12. pp. 1-39.
@article{a2b92af3b33745e3bd4567931864f96e,
title = "On the importance of generating accurate turbulent boundary condition for unsteady simulations",
abstract = "Turbulence is generally characterized by random, chaotic motion and has always been a challenging problem for fluid dynamists. Several methods for generating turbulent boundary conditions for computational fluid dynamics are in use today. One of the methods is by adding random white-noise to the averaged velocity profiles to generate turbulence in the flow field, which can be considered as the simplest and inexpensive method. Recently, another method has been introduced, which is based upon a digital filter to generate turbulent inflow data. This paper presents a comparison of the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique with three different methods within the framework of the large eddy simulations technique using the fifth- and second-order accurate methods in space and time, respectively. The case for comparison/analysis is a sonic jet of air injected transversely into a supersonic (Mach 1.6) stream of air, for which experimental and classical large eddy simulation data were available. It is demonstrated that the random white-noise-based turbulent inflow data dissipate immediately in the computational domain, giving incorrect velocity and pressure profiles. At the same time, the importance of two-point Exponential correlation used in the digital filter-based technique is demonstrated by scaling the random white-noise with the Reynolds stress tensor and ignoring the correlation. This improved the results compared with pure random white-noise, but still exhibits a high initial dissipation rate because the energy is not distributed over the required range of wavenumbers. It is demonstrated that the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique provides a reliable, accurate and consistent turbulent boundary layer in the flow field, which is required for the capture of correct flow physics. It is also demonstrated that the computational cost involved in all the methods presented is almost identical.",
keywords = "compressible flows, digital filter, jet in supersonic cross-flow, turbulence, turbulent mixing, accuracy assessment, chaotic dynamics, compressible flow, computational fluid dynamics, flow field, inflow, jet flow, large eddy simulation, Reynolds number, turbulent boundary layer, unsteady flow, velocity profile, white noise, boundary condition, comparative study, computer simulation, flow velocity",
author = "Rana, {Z. A.} and B. Thornber and D. Drikakis",
year = "2011",
month = "10",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1080/14685248.2011.613836",
language = "English",
volume = "12",
pages = "1--39",
journal = "Journal of Turbulence",
issn = "1468-5248",

}

On the importance of generating accurate turbulent boundary condition for unsteady simulations. / Rana, Z. A.; Thornber, B.; Drikakis, D.

In: Journal of Turbulence, Vol. 12, 35, 07.10.2011, p. 1-39.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - On the importance of generating accurate turbulent boundary condition for unsteady simulations

AU - Rana, Z. A.

AU - Thornber, B.

AU - Drikakis, D.

PY - 2011/10/7

Y1 - 2011/10/7

N2 - Turbulence is generally characterized by random, chaotic motion and has always been a challenging problem for fluid dynamists. Several methods for generating turbulent boundary conditions for computational fluid dynamics are in use today. One of the methods is by adding random white-noise to the averaged velocity profiles to generate turbulence in the flow field, which can be considered as the simplest and inexpensive method. Recently, another method has been introduced, which is based upon a digital filter to generate turbulent inflow data. This paper presents a comparison of the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique with three different methods within the framework of the large eddy simulations technique using the fifth- and second-order accurate methods in space and time, respectively. The case for comparison/analysis is a sonic jet of air injected transversely into a supersonic (Mach 1.6) stream of air, for which experimental and classical large eddy simulation data were available. It is demonstrated that the random white-noise-based turbulent inflow data dissipate immediately in the computational domain, giving incorrect velocity and pressure profiles. At the same time, the importance of two-point Exponential correlation used in the digital filter-based technique is demonstrated by scaling the random white-noise with the Reynolds stress tensor and ignoring the correlation. This improved the results compared with pure random white-noise, but still exhibits a high initial dissipation rate because the energy is not distributed over the required range of wavenumbers. It is demonstrated that the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique provides a reliable, accurate and consistent turbulent boundary layer in the flow field, which is required for the capture of correct flow physics. It is also demonstrated that the computational cost involved in all the methods presented is almost identical.

AB - Turbulence is generally characterized by random, chaotic motion and has always been a challenging problem for fluid dynamists. Several methods for generating turbulent boundary conditions for computational fluid dynamics are in use today. One of the methods is by adding random white-noise to the averaged velocity profiles to generate turbulence in the flow field, which can be considered as the simplest and inexpensive method. Recently, another method has been introduced, which is based upon a digital filter to generate turbulent inflow data. This paper presents a comparison of the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique with three different methods within the framework of the large eddy simulations technique using the fifth- and second-order accurate methods in space and time, respectively. The case for comparison/analysis is a sonic jet of air injected transversely into a supersonic (Mach 1.6) stream of air, for which experimental and classical large eddy simulation data were available. It is demonstrated that the random white-noise-based turbulent inflow data dissipate immediately in the computational domain, giving incorrect velocity and pressure profiles. At the same time, the importance of two-point Exponential correlation used in the digital filter-based technique is demonstrated by scaling the random white-noise with the Reynolds stress tensor and ignoring the correlation. This improved the results compared with pure random white-noise, but still exhibits a high initial dissipation rate because the energy is not distributed over the required range of wavenumbers. It is demonstrated that the digital filter-based turbulent inflow data generation technique provides a reliable, accurate and consistent turbulent boundary layer in the flow field, which is required for the capture of correct flow physics. It is also demonstrated that the computational cost involved in all the methods presented is almost identical.

KW - compressible flows

KW - digital filter

KW - jet in supersonic cross-flow

KW - turbulence

KW - turbulent mixing

KW - accuracy assessment

KW - chaotic dynamics

KW - compressible flow

KW - computational fluid dynamics

KW - flow field

KW - inflow

KW - jet flow

KW - large eddy simulation

KW - Reynolds number

KW - turbulent boundary layer

KW - unsteady flow

KW - velocity profile

KW - white noise

KW - boundary condition

KW - comparative study

KW - computer simulation

KW - flow velocity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.0-84856417847&partnerID=40&md5=078c90febb96eaa6a4aabae3847150d4

U2 - 10.1080/14685248.2011.613836

DO - 10.1080/14685248.2011.613836

M3 - Article

VL - 12

SP - 1

EP - 39

JO - Journal of Turbulence

T2 - Journal of Turbulence

JF - Journal of Turbulence

SN - 1468-5248

M1 - 35

ER -