No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda

Amanda J. Broderick, Catherine Demangeot, Eva Kipnis, Miguel Zuñiga, Abhijit Roy, Chris Pullig, Rene Dentiste Mueller , James M. Mandiberg , Guillaume Johnson , Geraldine Rosa Henderson , Nakeisha S. Ferguson , Natalie Ross Adkins

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Brands, as actors participating in the marketplace's social discourse, have the ability to lower and, equally, raise social and cultural boundaries. As such, it is important to understand better effects of brand-related cultural cues on consumer vulnerability, especially given the unprecedented diversification of cultural contexts in society today. First, we discuss the importance and complexity of cultural identity in the marketplace. Next, we explore the role of brands in creating social identity conflict. Finally, based on marketplace complexities and the role of brands as social actors, we offer several suggestions for research that will increase our understanding of how brand-based cultural cues might minimise feelings of consumer vulnerability and lower social and cultural boundaries within society. We demonstrate that relying on demographic characteristics when addressing cultural diversity in advertising appeals may result in misrepresentations or incomplete representations of complex cultural identities. Advertisers' failure to understand and reflect cultural identity complexities may aggravate consumer vulnerability and result in consumer withdrawal from the marketplace or from a particular brand. This paper calls for the need to deepen our understanding of mono- and multi-cultural consumer identification and behaviour in increasingly multi-cultural marketplaces. The social role of brands is to represent people's ideas about themselves and the world. An evolution in culture-based advertising and branding is proposed to address multiplicity in cultural identities and limit consumer vulnerability in the new reality of increasing cultural diversification in the marketplace. The paper contributes an augmented view of cultural identity that integrates links with multiple national, racial, ethnic groups and other cultural groups not connected to individuals through ancestry. It articulates the main research areas into consumer and brand vulnerabilities in multi-cultural marketplaces. Such a view would enable culture-based advertising and branding to enhance social cohesion in promoting cultural tolerance and diversity.
LanguageEnglish
Pages263-280
Number of pages18
JournalSocial Business
Volume1
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2011

Fingerprint

Branding
Research agenda
Consumer vulnerability
Cultural identity
Diversification
Vulnerability
Ethnic groups
Cultural context
Multiplicity
Demographic characteristics
Social cohesion
Cultural diversity
Tolerance
Misrepresentation
Social identity
Discourse

Keywords

  • multi-cultural marketplaces
  • culture-based branding
  • consumer vulnerability

Cite this

Broderick, A. J., Demangeot, C., Kipnis, E., Zuñiga, M., Roy, A., Pullig, C., ... Adkins , N. R. (2011). No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda. Social Business, 1(3), 263-280. https://doi.org/10.1362/204440811X13210328296586
Broderick, Amanda J. ; Demangeot, Catherine ; Kipnis, Eva ; Zuñiga, Miguel ; Roy, Abhijit ; Pullig, Chris ; Mueller , Rene Dentiste ; Mandiberg , James M. ; Johnson , Guillaume ; Henderson , Geraldine Rosa ; Ferguson , Nakeisha S. ; Adkins , Natalie Ross . / No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda. In: Social Business. 2011 ; Vol. 1, No. 3. pp. 263-280.
@article{5efae36a95d542cfac0a7aaff9575378,
title = "No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda",
abstract = "Brands, as actors participating in the marketplace's social discourse, have the ability to lower and, equally, raise social and cultural boundaries. As such, it is important to understand better effects of brand-related cultural cues on consumer vulnerability, especially given the unprecedented diversification of cultural contexts in society today. First, we discuss the importance and complexity of cultural identity in the marketplace. Next, we explore the role of brands in creating social identity conflict. Finally, based on marketplace complexities and the role of brands as social actors, we offer several suggestions for research that will increase our understanding of how brand-based cultural cues might minimise feelings of consumer vulnerability and lower social and cultural boundaries within society. We demonstrate that relying on demographic characteristics when addressing cultural diversity in advertising appeals may result in misrepresentations or incomplete representations of complex cultural identities. Advertisers' failure to understand and reflect cultural identity complexities may aggravate consumer vulnerability and result in consumer withdrawal from the marketplace or from a particular brand. This paper calls for the need to deepen our understanding of mono- and multi-cultural consumer identification and behaviour in increasingly multi-cultural marketplaces. The social role of brands is to represent people's ideas about themselves and the world. An evolution in culture-based advertising and branding is proposed to address multiplicity in cultural identities and limit consumer vulnerability in the new reality of increasing cultural diversification in the marketplace. The paper contributes an augmented view of cultural identity that integrates links with multiple national, racial, ethnic groups and other cultural groups not connected to individuals through ancestry. It articulates the main research areas into consumer and brand vulnerabilities in multi-cultural marketplaces. Such a view would enable culture-based advertising and branding to enhance social cohesion in promoting cultural tolerance and diversity.",
keywords = "multi-cultural marketplaces, culture-based branding, consumer vulnerability",
author = "Broderick, {Amanda J.} and Catherine Demangeot and Eva Kipnis and Miguel Zu{\~n}iga and Abhijit Roy and Chris Pullig and Mueller, {Rene Dentiste} and Mandiberg, {James M.} and Guillaume Johnson and Henderson, {Geraldine Rosa} and Ferguson, {Nakeisha S.} and Adkins, {Natalie Ross}",
year = "2011",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1362/204440811X13210328296586",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "263--280",
journal = "Journal of Social Business",
issn = "2044-4087",
number = "3",

}

Broderick, AJ, Demangeot, C, Kipnis, E, Zuñiga, M, Roy, A, Pullig, C, Mueller , RD, Mandiberg , JM, Johnson , G, Henderson , GR, Ferguson , NS & Adkins , NR 2011, 'No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda' Social Business, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 263-280. https://doi.org/10.1362/204440811X13210328296586

No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda. / Broderick, Amanda J.; Demangeot, Catherine; Kipnis, Eva; Zuñiga, Miguel; Roy, Abhijit; Pullig, Chris; Mueller , Rene Dentiste ; Mandiberg , James M. ; Johnson , Guillaume ; Henderson , Geraldine Rosa ; Ferguson , Nakeisha S. ; Adkins , Natalie Ross .

In: Social Business, Vol. 1, No. 3, 01.11.2011, p. 263-280.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - No harm done? Culture-based branding and its impact on consumer vulnerability: a research agenda

AU - Broderick, Amanda J.

AU - Demangeot, Catherine

AU - Kipnis, Eva

AU - Zuñiga, Miguel

AU - Roy, Abhijit

AU - Pullig, Chris

AU - Mueller , Rene Dentiste

AU - Mandiberg , James M.

AU - Johnson , Guillaume

AU - Henderson , Geraldine Rosa

AU - Ferguson , Nakeisha S.

AU - Adkins , Natalie Ross

PY - 2011/11/1

Y1 - 2011/11/1

N2 - Brands, as actors participating in the marketplace's social discourse, have the ability to lower and, equally, raise social and cultural boundaries. As such, it is important to understand better effects of brand-related cultural cues on consumer vulnerability, especially given the unprecedented diversification of cultural contexts in society today. First, we discuss the importance and complexity of cultural identity in the marketplace. Next, we explore the role of brands in creating social identity conflict. Finally, based on marketplace complexities and the role of brands as social actors, we offer several suggestions for research that will increase our understanding of how brand-based cultural cues might minimise feelings of consumer vulnerability and lower social and cultural boundaries within society. We demonstrate that relying on demographic characteristics when addressing cultural diversity in advertising appeals may result in misrepresentations or incomplete representations of complex cultural identities. Advertisers' failure to understand and reflect cultural identity complexities may aggravate consumer vulnerability and result in consumer withdrawal from the marketplace or from a particular brand. This paper calls for the need to deepen our understanding of mono- and multi-cultural consumer identification and behaviour in increasingly multi-cultural marketplaces. The social role of brands is to represent people's ideas about themselves and the world. An evolution in culture-based advertising and branding is proposed to address multiplicity in cultural identities and limit consumer vulnerability in the new reality of increasing cultural diversification in the marketplace. The paper contributes an augmented view of cultural identity that integrates links with multiple national, racial, ethnic groups and other cultural groups not connected to individuals through ancestry. It articulates the main research areas into consumer and brand vulnerabilities in multi-cultural marketplaces. Such a view would enable culture-based advertising and branding to enhance social cohesion in promoting cultural tolerance and diversity.

AB - Brands, as actors participating in the marketplace's social discourse, have the ability to lower and, equally, raise social and cultural boundaries. As such, it is important to understand better effects of brand-related cultural cues on consumer vulnerability, especially given the unprecedented diversification of cultural contexts in society today. First, we discuss the importance and complexity of cultural identity in the marketplace. Next, we explore the role of brands in creating social identity conflict. Finally, based on marketplace complexities and the role of brands as social actors, we offer several suggestions for research that will increase our understanding of how brand-based cultural cues might minimise feelings of consumer vulnerability and lower social and cultural boundaries within society. We demonstrate that relying on demographic characteristics when addressing cultural diversity in advertising appeals may result in misrepresentations or incomplete representations of complex cultural identities. Advertisers' failure to understand and reflect cultural identity complexities may aggravate consumer vulnerability and result in consumer withdrawal from the marketplace or from a particular brand. This paper calls for the need to deepen our understanding of mono- and multi-cultural consumer identification and behaviour in increasingly multi-cultural marketplaces. The social role of brands is to represent people's ideas about themselves and the world. An evolution in culture-based advertising and branding is proposed to address multiplicity in cultural identities and limit consumer vulnerability in the new reality of increasing cultural diversification in the marketplace. The paper contributes an augmented view of cultural identity that integrates links with multiple national, racial, ethnic groups and other cultural groups not connected to individuals through ancestry. It articulates the main research areas into consumer and brand vulnerabilities in multi-cultural marketplaces. Such a view would enable culture-based advertising and branding to enhance social cohesion in promoting cultural tolerance and diversity.

KW - multi-cultural marketplaces

KW - culture-based branding

KW - consumer vulnerability

UR - http://sb.publisher.ingentaconnect.com/content/westburn/sb/2011/00000001/00000003/art00003

U2 - 10.1362/204440811X13210328296586

DO - 10.1362/204440811X13210328296586

M3 - Article

VL - 1

SP - 263

EP - 280

JO - Journal of Social Business

T2 - Journal of Social Business

JF - Journal of Social Business

SN - 2044-4087

IS - 3

ER -